Mafia Game #4 The Play

[ZSandmann]

I get what your saying judge but disagree. A good Mafia is a dead Mafia. Plus, she could be Don for all we know and if we get the Don we severly cripple the Mafia's power. Especially if we get the Don before they use all three investigations.

 

[plantling]

I wouldn't take mee-mee for the don. I would think the don would take a more invisible role.

 

[judgemax]

The don is taking a much more "quiet", sympathetic role...

 

[johnlarson66]

I wouldn't take mee-mee for the don. I would think the don would take a more invisible role.

:iagree:

I also agree there are some smart players in the mafia group, but as a whole or as a "team" they have not played well. That is what makes them WEAK.

I think some of them jumped to save Cory Lover, maybe they paniced at the thought of losing someone so quickly. I also think some of them made a point to get as far away from Cory Lover as possible. Now in death, Cory Lover explains the lack of contact with the mafia. I am not sure if that post should have taken place or falls within what was posted before the game started. I wish dead people would stay dead and not post. Maybe we can have a thread after the game is over to talk about it.

At this point, I still do not trust anyone.

 

[judgemax]

well than, does any one have any one else they want to toss into the flame?.

.I think I have also figured out the dr, and the vigilante, I am at a loss to the mayor, I am not asking you all to come forward, just saying, I think I found you .

so , now my concern, is whether or not the vigilante, is going to use his one shot, for the mafia, or for the good of the town...

 

[ZSandmann]

The Case for bkw1982

I have been suspicious of bkw since their very first post (see below). I have not been able to get up a group yet that will agree with me but please read and form your own opinions. bkw is being pretty quiet, but I've noticed their post frequency slowly increasing as we go along.
​

128 pointless post later and no good info.

I still find this funny, lots of players were getting in character, posturing, doing some roleplaying, I learned a lot from these first posts.

i had to skip like 8 pages just to get were the good stuff happend....i was on the role play band wagon......but now its just useless post that makes the game thread long. no offense to anyone but might be easier to follow if it didn't exsist

Admits to skipping posts. We need to read all that is written to make the best choices. But if you already know who all the Mafia are you wouldn't need to would you?

because i dont have to.....it was a suggestion. take note of ogre post how he responded. he didn't take a offense. don't be so snippy, i think it harms the game for ppl who come late and have to read through a bunch of junk hoping to pick out a tid bit of information. like i said i skipped alot of post, who knows what i missed

Indeed, who knows what you missed? This was in response to Nola telling bkw to leave the game if he didn't like the roleplay. Once again, reading what is written is the only real way to figure out who is who.

he is prob building a case........im sure it will be a good one. i like to see his reasons for voting for anyon at this moment besides being random

In response to Ogre not posting his "idea."

Do we get T-shirts with our name on em...oh and matching hats?

I have my number one pick

But he doesn't share just yet.

Ok since ogre is brave enogh to post his i will too. i dont have a list but i do have a target. i vote to lynch ZSandmann

Mainly because he insinuates instead of accusing. He dosen't come out and say i think so and so is mafia because.....i think he tryin to get a snowball started.

Next is that he tries to convince guppyguppyfish to vote before she leaves for her camping trip. rushing votes is dangerous and voting just so u can get a vote in is recklass.


Next is the post about the note being left on the door. tryin to look innocent without saying it.

finally is his band wagon jumping on the CL vote.

This is my vote and why i believe why i voted...take it for what it is...an educated guess

Well this was his longest post to date. To "out" me as his Mafia pick. I had already called him out on lurking and his anti-RP posting. I had also already solidified my idea of CL being Mafia (which was correct).I didn't tell GGF to vote before she left the game, I had originally thought she meant she would be gone for a day or two, I had no idea it was for a week. Lastly, I straight up accused the ones I was confident about, I have not been beating around the bush as he proclaims.

bishop you missed my vote #156. and i like the way u lay the votes out......GJ
Are we goin to get this type of service through the whole game?

Make sure I'm up there on the chopping block and not your buddy CL.

top picks after catchin up with the thread are Zsandman and Charlie stubbs. My vote for Zsandman remains cause he came after me...tryin to switch the attention off himeself.

Charlie stubbs cause he post in italics and doesn't add any info to his post. IMO posting without adding is just a way to keep your count up without getting fingered or look suspicious.

His list are two of the players that are Roleplaying and admits I'm on there as a revenge vote.

my picks arent because of the roleplaying. go back to my post and read why i picked Zsandman and IME mafia post just enough to get under radar, and this early the game they jump on bandwagons and agree with ppl instead of pointing fingers. I believe both Zsandman and Charlie fit this profile. Zsandman is vote is just a revenge vote, has no evidence other then he doesnt like me pointing things out

Your welcome to point me out, we're all suspects, but I jumped on the right bandwagon before it was "cool." IE before the mafia did it to distance themselves.

I dont think CL is mafia i also don't think he is mayor...it's obvious he is tryin to save himself. My top two stll remain Zsandman and Charlie, if you need me to go into detail go read my previous post, if you need more detail just ask.

We see how that turned out.

WOW reading these last pages was like reading a novel....and then the twist with the doc saving judge? awsome couldnt written better then that. This reminds me of the game show Mole.

i suggest we all reread from the point of CL goof and follows ogre's outline.

Originally Posted by Madcrawdad

Hey Ogre, does your wife ever wake you at night and say, "Ogrecito, you've been whispering 'Madcrawdad' in your sleep again..."?

Anyone else crack up at this....top 10 quotes on AC.....

Ill see you guys later for my top 3

Now CL was a good idea eh? All of his posts since Cl was voted off have been light off-topic postings. I've not included them all but you can search them out.

i guess it does prove him innocent unless they tried to whack their own, but that would be to risky. Im not 100% sure the list is accurate, cause leaving judge alieve would benefit them more then whacking him.

Trying to now cast doubt on judge's list.

DD i doubt judge's list made the mafia nervous even if it was 100% true. All they would have to do is let townies lynch judge and then they wouldn't out themselves so early in the game. They tried to lynch him so that tells me that the list is not all it's cracked up to be. Unless there is some double reverse thinking here im taking the list with a grain of salt.
Now is the time to read with an unbias eye, strip clean all accusations and start from of CL's goof. Good luck to everyone.

Casting more doubt on the list and throwing in a bit of reverse logic as well.

My number 1 right now is MADcrawdad. Now im not goin to copy and paste and quote every thing that lead me to this but here is the short version. post 430 he seems to be pointing finger at ICE and protecting CL. IN 434 it's against judge. These are just my observations, and i think we are deling with a great mafia team, who are great at causing confusion and misdirection. Just my two cents. im at work and my break is over so i elaberate more when i get home

Thanks, now I've added Mad to my "Unlikely to be Mafia list. You really came out of the blue with this claim and youdon't try to give any reason why he is Mafia. I believe that is what you said I was doing at the beginning with CL??? Very odd time to introduce this new claim. I'm more sure than ever you are Mafia.

 

[Madcrawdad]

:iagree:

Now in death, Cory Lover explains the lack of contact with the mafia. I am not sure if that post should have taken place or falls within what was posted before the game started. I wish dead people would stay dead and not post.

I agree about the CL post after dying being improper, probably even bad for the mafia.

JohnLarson - you mention that CL was probably 'renegade' or out there on his own. I never got that impression, but CL's message would appear to confirm your thoughts.

JudgeMax - the appearance of you being an innocent due to an attempted hit (although the Don can hit his own, and the vigilante has a hit also) certainly exists, but CL mentions that his inbox was full, and strangely enough, you're bolding the letters 'p' and 'M' in your now-famous 'pM' post. You claim computer glitch or accident....BALONEY!

The fact that you two (JohnLarson & JudgeMax) have become pretty chummy of late also seems a little suspicious to me. Not saying you're mafia, but I'm looking closer, and definitely not putting Judge on my list of innocents, yet.

 

[KingOfTheDeep]

i have already made a case for my innocence, you all can either believe it, or not..but like i have said before..the town will suffer if i am lynched


and as far as me being defensive last night..i was being accused of being mafia..and i'm just supposed to sit back and say nothing?

you people are WAY too confused to be voting.

 

[bkw1982]

MAd i always come after you cause you're a good player and that the same reason i went after ogre in game 3. coping and pasting what ppl say is nice and looks impressive but to me you havnt built a case. you defended CL and tried name judge and thats my reasoning for picking you. even reading you post all the way i still don't see anything new i didnt read myself. In the end i think you're posting to post.

As for Zsandman you're still mad at me cause i didnt like you're role playin. and what you just posted was point less...all you did was took what i posted and made sly remarks. I voted for you because to me a mafia is someone tries to redirect the blame by not standing up and yelling but suggesting.

I knew Mad wouldnt be a popular vote because ppl like his post but hey defend all you want it's what i think. And it's not how long the post is it's what you say in it that really matters.

 

[ZSandmann]

But I'm not mad at you because you dislike roleplaying, heck I'm not even mad. But I do think your Mafia, we'll have to wait and see. You're right my posts on you and mee-mee are long, as there is a lot of "evidence" out there. I don't think mad is Mafia, but you ARE.