Mafia Game #4 The Play

[Madcrawdad]

MAd i always come after you cause you're a good player and that the same reason i went after ogre in game 3. coping and pasting what ppl say is nice and looks impressive but to me you havnt built a case. you defended CL and tried name judge and thats my reasoning for picking you. even reading you post all the way i still don't see anything new i didnt read myself. In the end i think you're posting to post.

Here's the thing, I didn't defend CL because I necessarily thought he was an innocent, but because people were lynching the guy based on his first post in the game. As far as posting to post, I think that I put the first real argument out there to lynch Mee-mee...I still stand behind that argument, and now am starting to think that Mee-mee could actually be the Don by the way some folks are trying to deflect attention from her.

Also, as far as Judge, I said in an earlier post she's not yet 'cleared' in my eyes. I wish people would make Judge put some explanations behind her list before they start following behind her. She claims to have the remaining 5 mafia identified (along with the doctor, mayor and vigilante?). C'mon, I'm smart, too and I'm not picking up on this. Maybe Judge's special role in the game was Town Psychic....

 

[judgemax]

I agree about the CL post after dying being improper, probably even bad for the mafia.

JohnLarson - you mention that CL was probably 'renegade' or out there on his own. I never got that impression, but CL's message would appear to confirm your thoughts.

JudgeMax - the appearance of you being an innocent due to an attempted hit (although the Don can hit his own, and the vigilante has a hit also) certainly exists, but CL mentions that his inbox was full, and strangely enough, you're bolding the letters 'p' and 'M' in your now-famous 'pM' post. You claim computer glitch or accident....BALONEY! yes, my infamous PM post, I said it before, I will say it again, I do not know what happened, If I were to do that, First Off, I would have used them in the same word, or at least closer together in that sentence, ..remember Corey was mafia, do you think maybe that was a planted ghost line?...

The fact that you two (JohnLarson & JudgeMax) have become pretty chummy of late also seems a little suspicious to me. Not saying you're mafia, but I'm looking closer, and definitely not putting Judge on my list of innocents, yet.

I have no affiliations in this town, my interest lies solely in catching the mafia,Just because he agrees with me, he is now suspect?..If you want to think me guilty, go ahead, Like I said before, you will see at the end of the game, if I am right or not...

i have already made a case for my innocence, you all can either believe it, or not..but like i have said before..the town will suffer if i am lynched


and as far as me being defensive last night..i was being accused of being mafia..and i'm just supposed to sit back and say nothing?

you people are WAY too confused to be voting.

since when did confusion come into play for votes?..and who is really voting?..we all are just talking?..trying to convince us we are on the wrong trail?..and um...whats with the good of the town thing?...are you claiming to be someone special?..

MAd i always come after you cause you're a good player and that the same reason i went after ogre in game 3. coping and pasting what ppl say is nice and looks impressive but to me you havnt built a case. you defended CL and tried name judge and thats my reasoning for picking you. even reading you post all the way i still don't see anything new i didnt read myself. In the end i think you're posting to post.

As for Zsandman you're still mad at me cause i didnt like you're role playin. and what you just posted was point less...all you did was took what i posted and made sly remarks. I voted for you because to me a mafia is someone tries to redirect the blame by not standing up and yelling but suggesting.

I knew Mad wouldnt be a popular vote because ppl like his post but hey defend all you want it's what i think. And it's not how long the post is it's what you say in it that really matters.

I don't think mad is mafia, I think he has suspicions as the rest of us do, ..and further more, I think bkw, isin't mafia as well, so maybe the two of you, could put your brains together , and find someone you two agree on, because you are both very smart players...

 

[judgemax]

Here's the thing, I didn't defend CL because I necessarily thought he was an innocent, but because people were lynching the guy based on his first post in the game. As far as posting to post, I think that I put the first real argument out there to lynch Mee-mee...I still stand behind that argument, and now am starting to think that Mee-mee could actually be the Don by the way some folks are trying to deflect attention from her.

Also, as far as Judge, I said in an earlier post she's not yet 'cleared' in my eyes. I wish people would make Judge put some explanations behind her list before they start following behind her. She claims to have the remaining 5 mafia identified (along with the doctor, mayor and vigilante?). C'mon, I'm smart, too and I'm not picking up on this. Maybe Judge's special role in the game was Town Psychic....

no, i said, i think i have the them, and i have no idea about the mayor..you can be suspicious of me, ..I have given reasons, I just can't explain them as well as most of you,. ..and wouldn't you feel silly, if I was a psychic...:silly:

 

[ZSandmann]

Sandy packs up his bag and drives slowly towards the clinic. Time for blood to be drawn and XRays to be run for his arthritis. He feels like he's walking the Green Mile, but hopefully he can return home before too late

Seriously. BBL

 

[judgemax]

and mad, you are smart, start looking at it all in plain sight, and you will see it...

 

[bkw1982]

well you have to look at wht the mafia risked if they whacked Judge. they woulda whacked one of their own for no reason...why would they do that? it has no purpose, unless they new the doc would save judge, but that to big a gamble. So judge is at the top of my list for innocent.

Judges's list is another thing, as i stated before it's a toss up. either it's right or it's wrong, but it has shown us alot. I believe the mafie tried to whack Judge to add to judge's crediblity, knowing tht if judge was gone ppl would believe their list. THe doc was a total left field which no one expected, prob not even judge.

So what have we learned from that event? IMO judge is innocent, 2 the list he made is no where near the true identity of the mafia and it was their plan to cause confusion....and thats why i think that there is great group of mafia. it was one of the best plans ive seen in the 3 prior games, but they underestimated having an active doc in this game

 

[OgreMkV]

i have already made a case for my innocence, you all can either believe it, or not..but like i have said before..the town will suffer if i am lynched


and as far as me being defensive last night..i was being accused of being mafia..and i'm just supposed to sit back and say nothing?

you people are WAY too confused to be voting.

I think KOTD made a little boo-boo here.

OK,Am I correct in thinking that amoung the top three mafia right now are:
mee-mee
bkw1982
KOTD

I think that everyone who has posted has at least one of these two on their list. So these are probably the three we should chose among for today's lynching.

Can all the town agree on these three?

 

[judgemax]

BKW, incase you missed it, I am a female, lmao...

i did not expect the dr, and if you believe that discredits me, then so be it, I also want to say, that I respect you for your opinion, If you so choose not to believe, its ok, ..As I have said before, you will see by the end of the game...

 

[judgemax]

I think KOTD made a little boo-boo here.

OK,Am I correct in thinking that amoung the top three mafia right now are:
mee-mee
bkw1982
KOTD

I think that everyone who has posted has at least one of these two on their list. So these are probably the three we should chose among for today's lynching.

Can all the town agree on these three?

I agree on KOTD, AND MEE-MEE, i would rather wait on bkw, i think theres more to his story...

 

[OgreMkV]

I'm not asking you to wait or vote on bkw... I'm asking if these are three good choices for the town to select a lynch from. We can debate which one at length in a bit.