Mafia Game #4 The Play

My top 3 list is

Ice and Z tied for 1...because of the bantering back and forth to try and make them seem like they are pointing the finger at each other...(done in game 3 between 2 Mafia)

NolaPete for 2....having a conversation with NJ and calling her nosy...hhhmm

and GGF...acting the same way in all the other games....hhhmmm

major RED flags for all 4....but Ice and Z are on my main radar screen for sure hit Mafia....

I VOTE FOR ICE...:lipssealedsmilie: and if I am wrong and he isn't Mafia and he is lynched then I will hang my head in shame...and plant lots of flowers for him outside my Pastry Shop and name a new Pastry sandwich after him...

I wanted to pop this post back up for folks. Mee-Mee names Ice (Innocent), GGF (innocent), Nola (Innocent), and myself. I have a scaled list I'll be posting very soon. Back to reading these older posts, they tell a lot more now than they did originally.
 
I wanted to pop this post back up for folks. Mee-Mee names Ice (Innocent), GGF (innocent), Nola (Innocent), and myself. I have a scaled list I'll be posting very soon. Back to reading these older posts, they tell a lot more now than they did originally.

Be careful with the scaled list... it's trouble ;)
 
Be careful with the scaled list... it's trouble ;)

true it might be trouble as you might get whacked at night, but we still have a doc, plus it is a good idea to re read everything since like sand said it brings out more info. plus it can help us narrow down suspects and overrun the mafia.
 
While brevity may be the soul of wit, apparently I have to speak more to ensure my own safety as a townie. Please take what you will from the following...




In reference to my original post about Nola and 13, I was expressing dismay at the fact that they had decided to quit the game and f=not finish out their commitment to the other players. You left out the part where I ask RB to tell us what each palyer had decided, which is why I was holding my vote. When I saw that rb had not replied before my bedtime, I continued in my vote for Nola, for reasons already stated.

The second part of your statement has me concerned, as many people voted to lynch Nola, well before I posted my reasoning. Rather, it seems to me that you, jpappy, are trying to shift much blame to me and look like the town hero.



mee-mee, you seem awful quick to side with jpappy, without posting why you agree with him.

My list for possible mafia is the following:

Jpappy (reasons stated above)

mee-mee (reason stated above)

SHK_ATK - weak reasoning- but he seems to follow jpappy and sandy (sp?) in his voting/thinking

ZSandsmann- follows jpappy, again without reason, couldn't find the quote I was looking for... :(

plantling - following the mafia crowd, looking to point fingers at people who voted for Nola for valid reasons.


These people also seem to be out to get Cory Lover, who I believe to be innocent (dont string me up, it really is "just a hunch!") Others are voting for CL also, I I believe some of them are mafia, but can't muster the evidence yet.

I'm sure this post will bring a fairly violent reaction from some people. Look for jpappy, who I sincerely feel to be mafia, to attack each accusation and support the rest of his clan.

I vote to lynch jpappy789. I believe that he is very good at turning people's heads, without drawing attention to himself.

"When sorrows come, they come not single spies, but in battalions". - Hamlet

~brandy

p.s. NeonJulie, the book I am currently reading is The Virgin's Lover, By Philippa Gregory. It is the story of Elizabeth the First'searly reign. Also look for The Constant Princess, same author, which follows the life of Katherine of Aragon. They are fascinating reads, fairly accurate in terms of the history, and written with a very skillful and compassionate hand.

p.p.s. rb: GREATJOB with the lynchings! I was rotflmao!!!

Why did Jensons build a huge case about jpappy on Day 2 when Mee-Mee and corey Lover were both named and CL was as good as gone? Jensons just lost a peg.
 
lol Ogre, I am willing to take the chance. Here is a scaled list 1-10, 1-4 leaning Mafia, 6-10 leaning Innocent. I tried to make no one a five but some have just not posted enough to really get a read on so M4's and I6's are waffley at best. This list is based on the first 50 pages, and everything to date, as well of course but I reread the first 50 as some things jump out now that we know two Mafia. It is too much to quote and I know I'll be called on this but I ask you to first reread the early stuff for yourself. Make your own opinions I'm not asking anyone to agree with me.

KingOfTheDeep M2
bkw1982 M3
Coler M4
Jensons M4
SHK-ATK M4
FishLady22 I6
johnlarson66 I6
NeonJulie I6

Charlie_stubbs I6
Hooked Newbie I6
plantling I7
jpappy789 I7
madcrawdad I8
Dangerdoll I9
OgreMkV: I9

judgemax I10 - Innocent
ZSandmann: Form your own opinion
 
I like the list, and all the research you do Zs. Heck of a job, going through the material. You show your mafia suspects at the top - I have to admit I need to watch BK, SHK and Jensons more closely, I think we all know the reasoning for KOTD and Coler. But for us weak (meaning me) people, with limited awake time, would it be too much to ask if you can break down the top 5 with a line or two summary on the reason. Then I'll start combing through to see if it clicks for me, and maybe we can all put a vote together for a third win for the town!
 
I vote to lynch KingoftheDeep

I like ZSandmann's list for the most part. I think that combined with judgemax's list makes a good list. I need to look at it compared to Ogre's list.

Once I am able I will make my own list. I like the scaled list and will rank everyone myself. Just for the record, I will make myself a 5.

I also think that following judgemax's lead is the best plan of attack right now, at least that way, I know I am not being guided by the mafia.
 
I think you'll find my list pretty similar more a matter of degree than kind... although another person has been brought to light recently and I'll probably be running through charlie's posts tonight.
 
AquariaCentral.com