Mafia Game #4 The Play

SHK_ATK said:
:offtopic:ha man vrs wild thats a good way to get killed

Nola seems to have the highest votes, But hasnt posted anything recently(unless i missed it) thats a hit or miss I do believe its a wasted vote..

My 2 suspects have been voted on about the same and now a new developement has emerged. For now I will vote to lynch CORY LOVER

Has been itching to be mafia, plus his plea for being inocent has been rather week in this game, it was more evident in game one. I believe that should put him up to 4 votes, plus since the whole nola and 13 scandal hes been in the backburner out of sight out of mind.

Bish why is 13 vote counting towards nola if he quit?
Click to expand...

SHK-ATk I think this post clears you because A) You voted for CL when the vote was tight between he and Nola AND B) You ask if "13"'s vote should be vetoed off nola. Those are not Mafia moves to me.

My list is narrowing
 
well im off to go drill Im glad that Z noticed that about me. GJ. I really dont have a person to vote for (thing is too hard!!) so I guess I will not vote this round, hopefully I can make it by sun, afternoon, and hopfully I havent been killed off by some embarazing disease. Good Luck town, I KNOW we will get the Mafia!!
 
Jensons 5
bkw1982 5
johnlarson66 5
SHK-ATK I6
Charlie_stubbs I6
Hooked Newbie I6
plantling I7 …
FishLady22 I7 …
jpappy789 I8 …
madcrawdad I8 - INNOCENT
OgreMkV: I9 - INNOCENT
judgemax I10 - INNOCENT by Precedent
ZSandmann: -- Form your own opinion

Too early in the Day to vote, but here is my list update after recent events and after digging a bit. I believe the last Mafia is one of the Top 3. There is no order to these top 3 so please don't read them as such.
 
Ok here's what I have for today. I am kind of at a loss on what to go on today and may revise this based on what I see (or don't see) posted as today progresses.


Leaning Mafia:
 Charlie_stubbs- For the same reasons as yesterday and since we're down to one mafia it seems like this may be a way to stay off the radar still. Seems very quick to "Go with the flow" for whomever is the current popular choice. This could be being new to the game (which I can relate to), but he's offered nothing but cheerleading and wagon jumping from what everything I've read.

No real read

Fishlady- Same as yesterday, not much to go on, but what there was seems to have been trying to help the town and was called out by Coler in the final hours.

SHK-ATK- Nothing to go on. This makes him close to leaning mafia for the same reason as Charlie above.

JohnLarsons- No real read, but close to leaning innocent to me.

Leaning Innocent
Plantling- Same as yesterday, I honestly don't have much of a read, but he seems to be helpful to the town and will share thoughts whereas some others won’t.

Ogre- Lots of helpful posts and I like the idea of everyone posting their reasoning.

bkw1982- Started out with alot of good posts and quieted down as soon as a couple people either named him or questioned some of his info and was called out by Coler.

Jensons- Not much info, but was called out by Coler in the final hours.

JPappy- Shades of Charlie, but not enough posts for me to place him "Leaning mafia" and was called out by Coler in the final hours.


Believed to be Innocent
Madcrawdad- Lots of good posts and seems very focused on playing well and helping the town. I wouldn't expect to see that combination if he weren't innocent.

Max- Regardless of the list and drama that ensued, to me the Dr. saving her pretty well cements it for me.

Zsand- Same as Mad from what I've seen. Very active and helpful.


Ogre- Lots of helpful posts and I like the idea of everyone posting their reasoning.



 
Thanks for the helpful posts, Z. And I think you may be right about HN. I'll have some time this afternoon and will go review more of NeonJ's rants and other's posts to see if I can find something. The last Mafia may be someone not on our radar. But it does make sense to rule out the ones that have made it on our radars first.

And HN, thanks for upgrading my status, but I'm a girl. :)
 
OK, at this point, I think everyone should be posting lists and as much of a reason as anyone has. I would also like to point out that Plantling has never been 'investigated' by a thread review. I know, I keep saying I'm going to and I''m working on, but I do have almost a life for a while now... sigh.

Sorry, Plantling, but you learned your lesson very well last game as mafia and it would be remiss of me to not include you as a possibility.

I'm of the opinion that Zsandmann, Madcrawdad (and where is he?), JMax, and myself are innocent.

Top mafia picks are now: everyone else...sigh.
 
OgreMkV said:
OK, at this point, I think everyone should be posting lists and as much of a reason as anyone has. I would also like to point out that Plantling has never been 'investigated' by a thread review. I know, I keep saying I'm going to and I''m working on, but I do have almost a life for a while now... sigh.

Sorry, Plantling, but you learned your lesson very well last game as mafia and it would be remiss of me to not include you as a possibility.

I'm of the opinion that Zsandmann, Madcrawdad (and where is he?), JMax, and myself are innocent.

Top mafia picks are now: everyone else...sigh.
Click to expand...

you forgot me ogre!!!!
 
plantling said:
Thanks for the helpful posts, Z. And I think you may be right about HN. I'll have some time this afternoon and will go review more of NeonJ's rants and other's posts to see if I can find something. The last Mafia may be someone not on our radar. But it does make sense to rule out the ones that have made it on our radars first.

And HN, thanks for upgrading my status, but I'm a girl. :)
Click to expand...


Ouch! 2nd time this game I've done that! Sorry! :)
 
Hooked Newbie said:
Ok here's what I have for today. I am kind of at a loss on what to go on today and may revise this based on what I see (or don't see) posted as today progresses.


Leaning Mafia:
Charlie_stubbs- For the same reasons as yesterday and since we're down to one mafia it seems like this may be a way to stay off the radar still. Seems very quick to "Go with the flow" for whomever is the current popular choice. This could be being new to the game (which I can relate to), but he's offered nothing but cheerleading and wagon jumping from what everything I've read.

No real read

Fishlady- Same as yesterday, not much to go on, but what there was seems to have been trying to help the town and was called out by Coler in the final hours.

SHK-ATK- Nothing to go on. This makes him close to leaning mafia for the same reason as Charlie above.

JohnLarsons- No real read, but close to leaning innocent to me.

Leaning Innocent
Plantling- Same as yesterday, I honestly don't have much of a read, but he seems to be helpful to the town and will share thoughts whereas some others won’t.

Ogre- Lots of helpful posts and I like the idea of everyone posting their reasoning.

bkw1982- Started out with alot of good posts and quieted down as soon as a couple people either named him or questioned some of his info and was called out by Coler.

Jensons- Not much info, but was called out by Coler in the final hours.

JPappy- Shades of Charlie, but not enough posts for me to place him "Leaning mafia" and was called out by Coler in the final hours.


Believed to be Innocent
Madcrawdad- Lots of good posts and seems very focused on playing well and helping the town. I wouldn't expect to see that combination if he weren't innocent.

Max- Regardless of the list and drama that ensued, to me the Dr. saving her pretty well cements it for me.

Zsand- Same as Mad from what I've seen. Very active and helpful.


Ogre- Lots of helpful posts and I like the idea of everyone posting their reasoning.
Click to expand...

Hey quit trying to draw attention to me i'm innocent for crying out loud you gotta believe me!!!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom