So Ice... how do you feel about playing follow the leader with the voting?
I'll call my Emo with your Cory. lmao
Mafia who done it! The Play
- Thread starter judgemax
- Start date
So Ice... how do you feel about playing follow the leader with the voting?
I'll call my Emo with your Cory. lmao
wow lots to go on in the night.
Ice-other think you are being ot vocal, I think you are the same as always nothing either way yet.
Mad-you,Ice and HN are all the hardest for me to get a read on in these games, to be honest I doubt I ever will. Nothing either way yet.
HN-you are being more careful this time, do I think that makes you Mafia...no I just think your tired of being the King of Controversy.
CL-good point about Andi, however perhaps things came up and she couldn't post again. Then again maybe not.
Jpap-nothing Mafiaish yet
LC-you seem to helpful this time, and not all over the place, you are one to watch.
Andi-I wish you had come back and posted more, I hope you have something to add today.
Rb-old, yes slow not you. If there were anyone that I would alwasy suspect it would be you. YOu have a very cunning mind, and play these games very well.I got my eye on you.
Beth-Well I know me nothing there
Emo-seriously dude I need to know how you think HN revealed himself, it isn't very nice to vote and run with no explaination. You slide up on my list.
Ogre-nothing says Mafia.......yet
Bk-you seem like you could be helping.....
CS-are you still playing?
If I missed anyine I will try to fix it, and If I added someone twice I apologize. There are somethings that have caught my attention, but it is still early and since the numbers don't favor a mistake I want to make the right choice.
Ice-other think you are being ot vocal, I think you are the same as always nothing either way yet.
Mad-you,Ice and HN are all the hardest for me to get a read on in these games, to be honest I doubt I ever will. Nothing either way yet.
HN-you are being more careful this time, do I think that makes you Mafia...no I just think your tired of being the King of Controversy.
CL-good point about Andi, however perhaps things came up and she couldn't post again. Then again maybe not.
Jpap-nothing Mafiaish yet
LC-you seem to helpful this time, and not all over the place, you are one to watch.
Andi-I wish you had come back and posted more, I hope you have something to add today.
Rb-old, yes slow not you. If there were anyone that I would alwasy suspect it would be you. YOu have a very cunning mind, and play these games very well.I got my eye on you.
Beth-Well I know me nothing there
Emo-seriously dude I need to know how you think HN revealed himself, it isn't very nice to vote and run with no explaination. You slide up on my list.
Ogre-nothing says Mafia.......yet
Bk-you seem like you could be helping.....
CS-are you still playing?
If I missed anyine I will try to fix it, and If I added someone twice I apologize. There are somethings that have caught my attention, but it is still early and since the numbers don't favor a mistake I want to make the right choice.
@Cory/HN
I don't really see where HN has defended JPap quite a bit, but apparently HN somewhat agrees... HN, you mention that you have reason to defend JPap. What reason?
@JPap
I didn't find the whole shaded word thing all that interesting at first. I don't see any reason that scum would need to send signals in the thread...also don't see what shading the word 'saving' would even convey to a teammate. The interesting thing is that you seem to deny doing it now. Are you saying that the whole word 'saving' got somehow accidentally shaded in grey?
For the time being I vote to lynch LChap . His pretty general observations (scenarios, post counts, restating events) and unwillingness to jump into the fray (ie, not really questioning anyone, as he claims that he wants to be 'careful) kind of smells like scum trying to blend in.
Beth, you start out this post by saying 'wow lots to go on in the night' but your list still seems pretty general (ie, nobody really seems to be tipping your scales much toward mafia even with all of the activity that you claim went on in the night).
I do agree with you on Chas, though. Somebody had better call the Mounties, as I think Charlie's gone missing.
Well, I'm adapting my playstyle each game to find something that works. Every time I've fully jumped into the fray, or tried to stay out of it completely, I've been a target the first night. So, I'm staying on the edge, adding my thoughts when I have them, and doing my best to be helpful without making myself the lynch that'll hurt the town.
Most people seem to be happy with my new playstyle, and think I'm finally adapting to happy medium...why aren't you? Seems to me like you want several people on your target list: Ice, Beth, Myself, HN. While I can see why some of them seem evil, I think you're trying to make the rest of the town suspect the strongest innocents we have.
OgreMkV
Father of Earth's Next Emperor
This is a very general, 'duh' statement... but it might show some insight.
It seems that there are many people voting their own way here. Well, duh, Ogre, what does that mean? It means that we are screwed. Almost half the field is mafia, with all of us innocents voting individually, it won't even take the entire mafia team to move the vote however they want to.
I don't know if everyone is afraid to start a kynch train or what is going on, but what we have now means we're pretty dead.
Unfortunately, the info we have to go on is not the best. I've been thinking about this and I vote to lynch Ice. I'm not 'following' rb because he's pertty much admitted to an OMGUS vote. Here are my reasons:
1) The 'instant' analysis that occured very early in the game
2) The 'gut instinct' comments
3) IMO, Ice is playing very aggressive, even for him. It's almost like he wants us to vote for him. Maybe this is a distraction from the Colonel?
If Ice is mafia, then we're in good shape for tomorrow whether he's the Colonel or not. I'd rather get the Colonel tonight, but the chances of that are slim. I just think Ice is our best shot at a bad guy right now.
It seems that there are many people voting their own way here. Well, duh, Ogre, what does that mean? It means that we are screwed. Almost half the field is mafia, with all of us innocents voting individually, it won't even take the entire mafia team to move the vote however they want to.
I don't know if everyone is afraid to start a kynch train or what is going on, but what we have now means we're pretty dead.
Unfortunately, the info we have to go on is not the best. I've been thinking about this and I vote to lynch Ice. I'm not 'following' rb because he's pertty much admitted to an OMGUS vote. Here are my reasons:
1) The 'instant' analysis that occured very early in the game
2) The 'gut instinct' comments
3) IMO, Ice is playing very aggressive, even for him. It's almost like he wants us to vote for him. Maybe this is a distraction from the Colonel?
If Ice is mafia, then we're in good shape for tomorrow whether he's the Colonel or not. I'd rather get the Colonel tonight, but the chances of that are slim. I just think Ice is our best shot at a bad guy right now.
Okay Mad fair enough, I think that CL should have let the whole "Shading incident go. And I told him to. But then you say that Jpap said he never did it, The only reference that I could find about that was #79 where he said he didn't see that he needed to hint to a team mate. But did he actually say he didn't do it?
Beth, go back to post #79. Jpap says something to the effect 'I didn't even notice that.' Says to me that he's claiming that it was unintentional. I absolutely don't think it makes him scum, but it's a little weird is all.
LChap, you say 'every time' as if you've been playing this game forever. I do seem to recall you being lynched as mafia on one of those night ones. Also, I've mentioned it in previous games, but the main reason that you tend to be a target is your selfish play (your attempt to run townies in circles for your own enjoyment even when playing as innocent). You play the game for yourself and not for the town... With your first post this game being 'Should I even read my PM?' I can't even be sure that things have changed this game.
With regard to your claims about me putting others on my target list, questioning people is how you play the game. I've questioned people. It doesn't mean that I want to vote them off... Most have answered sufficiently (at least for the time-being).
You mention Ice, HN, Beth, and yourself possibly being the strongest innocents the town has... That's kind of an unusual claim (especially on Day 1), isn't it?
