Mafia who done it! The Play

[Hooked Newbie]

How did I lead the charge on Emo? He made it sound like he was mafia and I voted for him.

How did I lead the charge on Charlie? Charlies death was of his own doing.I would have preferred he had just PMed JM and told her to UD him then make us waste all this time for nothing.

If you read the explanation of RBs post then you'd see I was pointing a finger at him, not protecting him. I was pointing out that he was laughing at the mafia playing me and that he thought it was game over.

I agreed with you about Emo and actually changed my vote off of Rb before I'd read your post. That was a big reason that I've read you as an innocent so far. I still think that Beth was a better choice than Charlie, but he did nothing to help himself and I wasn't going to get killed voluntarily. I believe one of the three I listed are the Colonel. It's either you, Rb, or bkw. I just can't quite figure out who's pulling the strings. If you aren't mafia, then someone's playing you, Mad, and I against one another. I almost would've rather been hit at this point. I can understand why they took jpap, but the hit on Cory still has me lost.

 

[IceH2O]

I retract my vote on RB

I don't feel safe about any of my assumptions at this time.

The ones I thought innocent now look mafia and vice versa. I'm still not sure about RB but I don't think voting him right now is in the towns best interest. I've taken to much out of context and need to go back over the thread.

Bkw looks to have been right about HN and LC setting me up. He believes RB is innocent, though I'd like to know what he sees to think that way.

HN did slip up and say someone pointed out that Andi was going to UD but it was just minutes before nightfall,long after his vote on RB then Emo. But he said it was the reason he didn't vote Andi to begin with.

Then the Beth slip up where she pulled a post after the fact to back up a vote that was made before the actual post by Emo saying he wasn't going to protect anyone.

I just need to read the thread again with an open mind.

I'm fine with a 24 hour day. Less agonizing lol. But tomorrow is Madden Day at my friends so from late morning to early afternoon I won't be around.

 

[IceH2O]

Okay I went through the 1st 300 posts. I'll continue the rest tomorrow. But this is what I found.

Ok pick the easy one who was not on-line....(was in class last night) and I do believe BK is you better bet for mustard.

Here Andi points to Bk as being mafia. This clears Bk IMO

My concerns right now are still mostly on the quieter players... Rb & Charlie. I know Charlie's been gone awhile, but it's not at all like him.

bkw deserves more attention IMO, but it's tough because of the infrequent posts.

My vote's on Cory right now because I think he hurt the town. It's possible that it was unintentional though so I'm not set and will probably be moving my vote after another read.

LC and his style change would make me nervous, but I think it's a more helpful style (and definitely not as irritating as the past couple games).

Mad has seemed helpful, but the way he's been "guiding" the thread concerns me even though I don't see anything scummy there right now.

Andi's promise to kick trees that wasn't followed through on is suspicious. g/o hope things get better if the reason you gave is true. g/o

I'm the last one that should be pulling out others lists and commenting on them but here you can see that HN wants the town to look at

Charlie- known innocent
RB-?
Bkw- think innocent
Cory-known innocent


LC he has as helpful so he is pointing away from him

Mad he won't come out and say scummy but points a finger in his direction

Andi we know is mafia


Like I said I'm the last one that should comment on this but I thought it should be pulled up so others could look.

It is a Day 1 list though its about 2 hrs before nightfall when it was posted. He could have added Andi as mafia in case she was lynched or UDed and shown mafia.

 

[LesbianChap]

Lol thanks for making me look smart. I so called mafia setting ice up later.

Oh, you're doing a good job looking way smart on your own.

Why are you following ice, maybe you should think for yourself. This tells me either ice is feeding your votes or your tryin to set him up....either way your mafia.

Looking at the votes, I did follow Ice...I made my own decision, but did so making the assumption he was innocent and that the evidence presented by him, the people he voted for, and everyone else, made it one of the best choices for the town. I keep telling you I'm not as good of a Mafia player as you guys think I am...but you're making me the master of the plot. What you suggest requires heavy team coordination...something I don't think exists in Mafia, and definately not something I could muster.

 

[IceH2O]

I've got it figured out and its the only thing that makes sense to me.

I vote to lynch RB

I think the mafia team is

RB
Mad
HN
LC

If RB isn't the Col then LC is.

I think they split into 2 teams.One to attack me and one to befriend me. Notice LC and HN never attacked each other enough to draw suspicion or votes onto one another and the same for Mad and RB. But the team of RB/Mad has attacked HN/LC and vice versa. That way if one team got lynched the other team looked innocent.

Nothing is going to change my mind on this,

RBs LMAO was a gloat to be saying I got played. Mad then asked RB what the LMAO was for so that RB could explain it the way he did.

Beth Bkw and Ogre I believe 100% you are innocent, you need to really look into this idea with an open mind and ignore whats been said about anyone else at this point. We need to all vote for the same person and let the coin decide. If you think you know who the Col is then thats who we need to vote. If we can't agree on the Col lets at least agree on 1 of the 4 to vote for.

 

[LesbianChap]

Well I looked back a bit...re-skimmed the thread...if I weren't playing this game, based on the vote record alone, I'd say Ice, HN, myself and Mad were the Mafia team...Ice, HN, and myself have voted the same every night, and voted for an innocent every night, which doesn't look good for us. Mad's placed his vote each night where it would do no damage.

And since I am playing, I know one of those players isn't Mafia...my modified team would have to be: Ice, HN, Mad and either Beth or RB. RB was willing to sacrifice Ice the first night, which doesn't look well...so I don't think Ice is the Col...Beth has been on the radar for a while now. I think Ice was helping to keep Mad off the radar by accusing him so hard...if I were to name a Col, it'd be him, and they're either willing to lose RB, or Beth's the Mafia and they're trying to lynch another innocent.

I've been fooled, and played...but hopefully this will be the start of fixing the situation:
I vote to lynch Mad

 

[bethkira2000]

I have looked at the the thread with an open mind, it sucks that we lost 2 innocents last night. I think that the Mafia team is as follows:
In no particular order:
Rb
LC
Ogre-Colonel
HN
I really don't see Mad as mafia, he and Ice always go after eachother, but they have both been helping the town since day1.

 

[IceH2O]

Well I looked back a bit...re-skimmed the thread...if I weren't playing this game, based on the vote record alone, I'd say Ice, HN, myself and Mad were the Mafia team...Ice, HN, and myself have voted the same every night, and voted for an innocent every night, which doesn't look good for us. Mad's placed his vote each night where it would do no damage.

And since I am playing, I know one of those players isn't Mafia...my modified team would have to be: Ice, HN, Mad and either Beth or RB. RB was willing to sacrifice Ice the first night, which doesn't look well...so I don't think Ice is the Col...Beth has been on the radar for a while now. I think Ice was helping to keep Mad off the radar by accusing him so hard...if I were to name a Col, it'd be him, and they're either willing to lose RB, or Beth's the Mafia and they're trying to lynch another innocent.

I've been fooled, and played...but hopefully this will be the start of fixing the situation:
I vote to lynch Mad

I believe Mad is LC even with you voting him. I believe you are trying to split the vote onto 2 mafia players so you can all last minute jump to an innocent. Its game over, you guys should have taken me out last night.

I have looked at the the thread with an open mind, it sucks that we lost 2 innocents last night. I think that the Mafia team is as follows:
In no particular order:
Rb
LC
Ogre-Colonel
HN
I really don't see Mad as mafia, he and Ice always go after eachother, but they have both been helping the town since day1.

If us innocents split the vote on 2 mafia players then the actual mafia players can all jump last minute to an innocent and win outright.We need to agree on 1 player and since RB is one of your choices will you be willing to vote him?

The only reason I think Mad is partners with RB is his not looking at the way RB has been a nonhelper to the town. Any player that refuses to pull quotes and sits on just 1 person an entire game deserves to be looked at and Mad didn't even consider looking. If it makes you feel better we can save Mad for last. Vote RB then LC then HN then Mad (or whoever is left lol since it will be 1-1 at that point)

 

[LesbianChap]

I believe Mad is LC even with you voting him. I believe you are trying to split the vote onto 2 mafia players so you can all last minute jump to an innocent. Its game over, you guys should have taken me out last night.

Oh yes, we're one and the same. And I don't think they'd hit one of their own when they could take out an innocent instead.

If us innocents split the vote on 2 mafia players then the actual mafia players can all jump last minute to an innocent and win outright.We need to agree on 1 player and since RB is one of your choices will you be willing to vote him?

The only reason I think Mad is partners with RB is his not looking at the way RB has been a nonhelper to the town. Any player that refuses to pull quotes and sits on just 1 person an entire game deserves to be looked at and Mad didn't even consider looking. If it makes you feel better we can save Mad for last. Vote RB then LC then HN then Mad (or whoever is left lol since it will be 1-1 at that point)

I agree...we need to go after a single Mafia member, and hopefully get the COL. Mad is my best target, now I'm wondering if the rest of the innocents are going to join me against you.

 

[IceH2O]

I'll vote anyone but Mad at this point out of the team RB/Mad HN/LC. I'll be leaving in a bit but if we can all agree on who we think is Col, which I'm leaning either LC or RB then I'll vote that way. The more I think about it I would think the Col would befriend me to keep me off their ***.
The only reason I went after RB 1st was the gloating LMAO post. If you guys would rather go after LC I'll follow suit.