Mafia who done it! The Play

Wow...it's quiet this morning. By now in the last mafia games there would be 20+ pages.

I don't have any thoughts yet...not enough posts really.

I'll try to post my suspect list tonight, if I have one by then.
 
Quick question for you, Hooked Newbie...

Here are my first two posts of the game...
Madcrawdad said:
Judging by the Colonel Mustard description, it looks like it's 8 innocents vs. 5 mafia. An awful lot of bad guys in relation to the number of good guys. It pretty much means that the town NEEDS to lynch mafia on days 1 or 2 to even be around for day 3.

Stay frosty, people.
Click to expand...

Madcrawdad said:
I'm not analyzing the vote for Chas here, JPap, but nightfall is 2 days away. What I'm analyzing, is your vote for anyone at this point...

You essentially say that your vote for Chas means nothing, yet should you not get a chance to post again within the next 2 days, your current vote (which means nothing), will essentially become your final vote. Not a real pro-town move there, Pappy.
Click to expand...


After these two posts, Ice has an epiphany that I must be scum. He calls it 'gut instinct'. Whatever.
IceH2O said:
You want analysis?

Your 1st post doesn't sound pro-town. No mention anywhere that you are a townie. I thought well not always smart to admit innocence in your 1st post. But then in your 2nd post you kind of hint at being a townie, so if it isn't smart in the 1st post it can't be smart in the next post you make.

Or I could take the 2nd post as mafia pointing out a non townie move on Jpap.

How is it not pro town to make sure you don't UD? How can you say his vote is non townie if its his final vote before nightfall? He made sure he didn't die and if thats the best he can do right now then fine.
Not saying he is innocent as I just posted that quiet ones are going to be my main focus. I really wanted to vote the least helpful out so we stay strong longer. Doesn't bode well to lynch the strong players and let the mafia just pick them off.

But your posts just hit me funny and I've learned long ago with you if my gut says so then go with it,just didn't expect it this quickly. I vote to lynch Mad
Click to expand...


Here HN, you mention to Ice that it looks like alot of analysis for two posts...but that you can kind of agree with some of it...
Hooked Newbie said:
Wow, that's alot of analysis for the amount of posts made. I can kinda agree with some of it, but it seems like it could be "contrived" to do exactly the opposite of what you said.
Click to expand...


Can you be more specific as to which parts you kind of agree with?
 
Wow, I got a headache, and I think it's you-alls fault. You people are all over the place...are you trying to stay off the radar by being crazy? *moans*

I don't see anything that's worth mentioning yet...except I may have been wrong about Emo and his playstyles...but I don't feel like going back to make sure...such a pain.

But yeah, that still leaves us with a very busy, unusually serious Day One.
 
LesbianChap said:
Wow, I got a headache, and I think it's you-alls fault. You people are all over the place...are you trying to stay off the radar by being crazy? *moans*

Says the guy who changed his vote 10 times in one day...

I don't see anything that's worth mentioning yet...except I may have been wrong about Emo and his playstyles...but I don't feel like going back to make sure...such a pain.

But yeah, that still leaves us with a very busy, unusually serious Day One.
Click to expand...

Sorry, I just couldn't let that one go.

My main concern is that, once again, all the innocents are going after each other and letting the mafia have a free ride. Yes, I know it's good to kick trees and analyze posts heavily, but I can't help but feeling we're doing the same thing that always happens. We fixate on one or two vocal players' posts and ignore the low posters completely.

With that in mind...

I vote to lynch rbishop
 
charlie_stubbs said:
Note the above section highlighted in red. You say your vote for me is mostly random. Mostly random. Which part isn't random? The fact that you want to vote for someone who might disrupt your evil plan??? And already making excuses so you can lay low for a couple days??? Should I salute you Colonel???
Click to expand...

Sure Chas. Mostly random because I didnt target anyone for any specific reason and then chose you, its a nice welcome back to the game dont ya think? And I really cant call it random as theres a pretty good chance you could be mafia. Mostly likely it will change, unless you want to get it over with and proclaim that you are mafia...

bkw1982 said:
If nightfall ended tonight my vote would either stay on LC or land on JP.

LC-is acting way to calm and isnt as out there, and yes im aware that its only been a few post, but compared to last game he was all over the place. My assumption is tht he either matured in the game(*note not a shot at your actually maturity lvl) or he is being instructed by someone

JP-the joke vote for c-stubbs and proclaiming he'll be away so he did so he wont UD
Click to expand...

Um, yeah thats why I placed my vote. I seriously dont think you would want me to UD, any death other than mafia is bad for the town. RL is an issue as always with me being in school and Im with my dad on Tues/Wed nights w/o interent funcioning properly so I wasnt sure if I would get a vote placed before nightfal, which hadnt been posted at the moment.

If it makes you feel any better I guess I will change the vote I retract my vote on Charlie

Cory Lover said:
Hmmm...look at the word 'saving'...the color of it is dim gray...the whole rest of the post is in black. Are you giving a hint to your team, jpappy?
Click to expand...

Why would I need to hint to my team? I honestly never noticed that, but nice catch I guess. Only I think you are trying to turn this into something bigger than it actually is CL...a mafia-like thing to do.
 
OgreMkV said:
Sorry, I just couldn't let that one go.

My main concern is that, once again, all the innocents are going after each other and letting the mafia have a free ride. Yes, I know it's good to kick trees and analyze posts heavily, but I can't help but feeling we're doing the same thing that always happens. We fixate on one or two vocal players' posts and ignore the low posters completely.

With that in mind...

I vote to lynch rbishop
Click to expand...

As it's been pointed out that lurking plays into the mafia's hand (even moreso this game) I think that lurkers do need to be looked at a little harder.

The near silence from some players, has not gone unnoticed.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom