Mafia who done it! The Play

I am not sure at this point if I am dead or not....If I am sorry guys....if not I thought Emo was mafia, he didn't help the town much I believe Ice to be innocent and for him to say that he wasn't going to try and save Ice just sat wrong with me. I take full owner ship of my vote, I thought I bolded it too. Sorry.....I think it sucks that Jpap was taken out..And the Reverend of all things, why did he have to make that mistake.
 
Well the good news is that Andi UD'ed as mafia....

I've got some thoughts, but won't be able to post them until a little later today. I think the town will have alot of things to talk about today that may be helpful in weeding out some of the bad guys.
 
Beth, I think JM counted your vote and Emo got the coin toss between him and Ice...otherwise, Ice would have been the one to go. You're still with us, at least for one more night...

And I'm glad you made it, Ice...I really do think you're one of my fellow players trying to help the town. I'm glad at least a Mafia UD'd last night, otherwise it may have been ugly for us. Anyways, here's what I'm worried about right now: Mad and Cory. Both have left their votes on "Safe" places where they wouldn't matter. They didn't join the fight between Ice and Emo...and left us with almost no way to read them. Cory DID have his vote on Andi, and we both know Andi is Mafia...but was it a distancing tactic that didn't pay off, or did Cory really just not get here in time to join the fray? Mad has been a suspect of Ice's all game...and been rather defensive.

Bk has my worries because he switched to try to break the tie between Ice and Emo. If Bk is innocent, he wouldn't know if Emo wad too, and with Emo's confession, I'm suprised he go the other way...Maybe he was counting on Beth's vote on counting and wanted to give a 50/50 chance for Ice (rather risky chance, imo) or he wanted to make sure the stronger innocent left, figuring if Ice were gone tonight, Emo would be a good target tomorrow winning him the game?

The more I look at it, the more Bk looks like a good target...however I want some answers for Mad, and Cory. I think RB needs to help the town as well, though at this moment there are probably bigger fish to fry.

Oh, and the suspicions I posted about in my previous post (251) were contingent on finding Ice innocent, as I still suspect. As we haven't found that out for sure, I modified it as above.
 
Good news, bad news, worse news

A mafia UDed... that's wierd, but good for us.

I don't get what happened, I guess the mafia killed jpap. Reading JMax's mod posts are almost as bad as reading her player posts ;). So we lost the doc. Ice, how did you know jpap was the doc?

So tonight's the night, we get a mafia or lose.

Emo being innocent blows my theory of him protecting Ice out of the water. So was anyone protecting anyone? Or are they both innocent?
 
I wish Jmax was on so I would know for sure, I hate risking AD posts.
Ice-I have you leaning Innocent at the moment.

Emo-known innocent

HN-want hear from him before I post my thoughts.

Mad-you and Ice always go at eachother, but this feels different, I think you might be innocent.

CL-I am not sure about you, slightly mafia atm

Rb-I think your slightly maifa at this moment.

LC-your helpful, and this style suits you better, trying to help the town not just yourself. So do I think your innocent not so sure I will wait until later to make the decision.

Andi-Known Mafia well one down

Beth-I know me

Jpap-THe Rev and known Innocent....that sucks we lost him

BK-you are slightly mafia atm, yes I voted for Emo I made a mistake, it wasn't hard to do.

Ogre-slightly innocent

CS-I need more from you....

This is in no order and is subject to change.
Rb
BK
Mad
are whom right now I am thinking about.
 
I know I said that I had some thoughts coming later, and I still do... That post will take some time to pull together, but I wanted to address a couple of other things first.

I am not sure at this point if I am dead or not....If I am sorry guys....if not I thought Emo was mafia, he didn't help the town much I believe Ice to be innocent and for him to say that he wasn't going to try and save Ice just sat wrong with me. I take full owner ship of my vote, I thought I bolded it too. Sorry.....I think it sucks that Jpap was taken out..And the Reverend of all things, why did he have to make that mistake.

Beth, I vaguely remember the quote where Emo said something about not saving Ice, but I can't find it now... I'm pretty sure that it came well after you voted for Emo, though. Are you saying that's why you didn't remove your vote from Emo (as it couldn't have influenced your vote if it came afterwards)?

I wish Jmax was on so I would know for sure, I hate risking AD posts.
Ice-I have you leaning Innocent at the moment.

Emo-known innocent

HN-want hear from him before I post my thoughts.

Mad-you and Ice always go at eachother, but this feels different, I think you might be innocent.

CL-I am not sure about you, slightly mafia atm

Rb-I think your slightly maifa at this moment.

LC-your helpful, and this style suits you better, trying to help the town not just yourself. So do I think your innocent not so sure I will wait until later to make the decision.

Andi-Known Mafia well one down

Beth-I know me

Jpap-THe Rev and known Innocent....that sucks we lost him

BK-you are slightly mafia atm, yes I voted for Emo I made a mistake, it wasn't hard to do.

Ogre-slightly innocent

CS-I need more from you....

This is in no order and is subject to change.
Rb
BK
Mad
are whom right now I am thinking about.

Beth, in your list here you say that you think I could be innocent, yet you have me listed in your top 3 suspects. A little odd.
 
I did count beths vote,. she tried, and would be unfair to her. That was my decision.

Reverend green, was able to investigate.

Sorry for any confusion.
 
sorry Mad, I have leaning innocent atm, yet My eye is one you, because you and Ice are the hardest to read out of everyone. I am watching Ice too, sorry for the mix up I was trying to put thoughts together and post. Sorry my top suspects are
Rb
BK
not Mad
and thinking it over CS is there a little.
I have my eye on
Ice
LC
and Mad
 
sorry Mad, I have leaning innocent atm, yet My eye is one you, because you and Ice are the hardest to read out of everyone. I am watching Ice too, sorry for the mix up I was trying to put thoughts together and post. Sorry my top suspects are
Rb
BK
not Mad
and thinking it over CS is there a little.
I have my eye on
Ice
LC
and Mad

That answers my second question.... Can you address how Emo's assertion that he wouldn't save Ice played into your voting decision, as I recall it coming after your vote?
 
AquariaCentral.com