Mineralized Topsoil in Riparium Planters

hydrophyte

AC Members
Apr 13, 2009
791
0
0
I have occasionally observed problems with nutrient deficiencies in riparium plants that lead to poor overall plant health and less than optimal visual appearances. Chlorosis and leggy growth are especially unattractive. The method that I have most frequently used to fertilize riparium plants is to drip liquid fertilizer solutions directly onto the surface of the planter gravel, but this highly soluble form of fertilizer is likely to be used quickly by the plant and diffuse into the open aquarium water. It is probably best to dose liquid ferts at least once per week and perhaps more often.

I recently started to experiment with the use of mineralized topsoil (MTS) in riparium planter cups. I hope that the use of MTS can serve the following objectives:

  1. more attractive foliage
  2. increased blooming
  3. less demanding fertilization regimes

A major expected advantage of the mineralized topsoil is that it should maintain a long-term, slow-release nutrient source for the plants. It also might provide a broader range of nutrients than are easily provided in liquid fertilizers doses.

The following picture shows the material that I used. I acquired this MTS in trade form another hobbyist:

23-x-09-mts-ii-s.jpg


Proceeding through the steps of planting that I used, the next photograph featres the planter cup with the basic substrates, but only 1/2 full: it still requires the rooted plants and a cap of planter gravel. On the bottom is a layer of Hydroton clay pebbles. These are topped with planter gravel filled to about 1/3 of the depth of the cup. Lastly, a shallow layer of mineralized topsoil was added on top of the planter gravel. I only added one & one-half tablespoons minerallized topsoil:

23-x-09-mts-i-s.jpg


If you look closely you can see that the MTS layer is below] the level of the suction cup keyholes in the back of the planter cup. Since it will be covered with another layer of gravel this placement will help to prevent it from washing out through the keyholes.

Here is the plant that I used, a Ludwigia sp.. I think that it is L. repens(?). It forms a pleasing floating carpet if planted in the Hanging Planter, then trained to grow across a Trellis Raft:

23-x-09-mts-iii-s.jpg


This next picture shows the planter with all substrate layers, Trellis Raft and plant.

23-x-09-mts-iv-s.jpg


The thick top and bottom layers of planter gravel should prevent the mineralized topsoil from washing into the aquarium. It will be even more tightly held inside the planter cup as the plant roots begin to form.
 
Last edited:
I really want to try some of your ideas on my next tank, I'll be watching this thread to see how the MTS works out
 
Wow, another 'MTS' to add to the vocab haha!

I thought of using this as substrate with with my tank, but I decided to scrap it due to all of the complications of dealing with mineralized soil.

I think Barr wrote an article on it in the use of aquariums, and he was having a hard time (can't remember if it was Barr, or someone else, but whoever it was had a LOT of experience with plants and had trouble keeping algae in check)

Good luck!
 
I don't think there is much danger of very much MTS getting loose in the tank and causing trouble: the clay gravel holds it in there well. Once the plant roots start to grow they also hold everything really tight in the planter cup.

Here is an additional shot of the planter with the plant and the raft all ready to situate in the tank:

23-x-09-mts-v-m.jpg


With time to grow and some pruning to control shape, the plant will eventually cover the raft and planter and form a nice floating carpet of foliage.
 
what are your thoughts on low/no sodium coir bricks? i would think it would hold nutrients well for the roots.

i am interested to see how this turns out. of course.
 
I think that coir would just start to rot in the tank water. That clay gravel really works pretty well.
 
gotcha!
 
Genius.

Where did you get the trellis raft?
 

That gravel is clay-based, so it should be able to hold nutrients well. Clays have a special chemical property, cation exchange capacity, which allows them to grab nutrient ions, then hold them for plant roots.

Most of the popular planted aquarium substrates (e.g., Fluorite, Aquasoil) are made from fired clay gravel and have this same property: they are better plants than more inert materials, such as silica sand or regular stone gravels.
 
AquariaCentral.com