New 5 gallon- Best fish?

wbaker01

AC Members
Dec 26, 2005
52
0
0
Parker, CO
We bought a 5 gallon tank for our kids for X-mas as a way to introduce them to aquariums(I'm kicking myself that we didn't buy a larger tank after reading the forums but figured this is a small step to get out feet wet in the hobby). I'm looking for some suggestions for some fish to stock the aquarium. Also, I was researching some of the small catfish bottom cleaners and did not find any that would be recommended for my small tank, is that true? :)
 
bottom feeders

We have some smaller tanks and I find that otto's are really good. The only problem is that they are schooling fish and like hidey holes, you would want to make sure that if you go with any mid-water/bottom water fish to check that they can withstand the same temperatures, water conditions and that the mid/upper water guys are compatable, and they will need supplimental food other than wafers (just like any bottom feeder - check the catfish/bottom feeder forum for a thread on proper feeding). So as far as the other fish and the number I am not sure. But I know that you will get some responses for them soon.

Good job mom and dad for getting info for the kids. :clap: I have three kids and each have a tank... translation... we do a lot of tank cleaning now that they are moving on. But it was worth it and I like the fish.

Merry Christmas
S.A & T.A
 
We actually decided to bump up to a 10 gallon tank, any new ideas on initial fish to stock it with?
 
I am asssuming you are new to the hobby?

Before thinking about the fish for stocking, make sure you become very well versed in all the aspects of fish keeping from cycling the tank, understanding water parameters, proper water change schedule and procedure, etc.

Make sure you're using quality equipment from the outset; there is no sense in skimping on any items because you'll end up replacing them anyway.

Don't stock the tank all at once. It needs to be cycled, and even then you have to be sure you only add a few fish at a time.


Okay with my rant over, I suggest that for a ten gallon tank you get a few peaceful, hardy fish. Cherry barbs, black tetras, zebra danios, cory cats, female bettas - just for some examples.


I would actually advise againt a male betta for a community tank when you're a beginner for three reasons:

1) They can have compatability issues that you might not be aware of, such as with gouramis, paradise fish and often female bettas. Because of their long tails, they are also prone to be nipped a lot by nippy fish like danios and tiger barbs.

2) They are slow swimmers and can be outcompeted for food by faster swimming inhabitants.

3) If you have a strong power filter, the currents will annoy them and worse than that, I once had a male betta get sucked up against my filter intake. By the time I caught the problem it had been hours and he was so weak that he died a few days later. (This can be easily remedied with several methods of covering the intake, but that's hardly something you'll want to be dealing with as a beginner.)

I wouldn't recommend otos either. They can be very sensitive to water conditions and require algae or supplemental foods to do well. If you want a cute bottom feeder, go with corys. Those guys are the goods.


So just to recap - read up on everything you can, pick smaller, hardier fish that are relatively peaceful, stock slowly only one or two...maybe three fish at a time, don't overstock the tank....and have fun.
 
Last edited:
Cory cats are a definite. They are some of the most peaceful fish you can get. Get three, because they love each others company. If you want a centerpiece fish I agree with UncaBret - one male betta or one dwarf gourami and then go with one small school of fish (5 or 6 neons, glowlights, cardinals, or rummy nose tetras). Just don't put bettas with fin nippers like barbs or other fancy fish like guppies because they might take them for another male betta. If you don't want a centerpiece fish them you could go with two small schools.

Don't put all the fish in at once!!!!!! Decide on your final stocking list and then pick a few to start. I would recommend a fishless cycle, but I'm sure that's not pratical since it's the kids tank.
 
AquariaCentral.com