New cycle or revive old bacteria?

anonapersona

Reads a lot, knows a little
Mar 7, 2003
1,736
0
0
Houston
Visit site
If a tank has had no fish in it for a month, does it have viable bacteria or must the cycle start all over fromthe beginning?

This question comes up from time to time and so before I clean out this tank, I figured I'd do a quick experiment.

The fish in the 58 gallon tank were sold on Nov 21, today is Dec 23. The tank has been running with no water changes or filter cleaning since the fish left. Dual Canister filters are running, water temp at 72, gravel is pretty clean as the tank was recently moved and totally cleaned then and gravel was kept very clean after that. It also has some Tx holey rocks and plastic plants. For while there was one tiny live anubias plant on a rock but I removed it a week ago. It is possible that there was enough decay of plant parts that some bacteria may still be alive in the tank.

Although I did an initital ammonia test, I forgot it takes 5 minutes to read, so I cannot be certain the tank was ammonia free to begin with, but let's assume it was. I have dosed it to ~3.0 ppm ammonia with 20 ml of household ammonia to a 58 gallon tank.

I'll retest tomorrow at about 2 pm (hopefully, being Christmas I may get distracted) to see how the ammonia has dropped, if it has dropped. I suspect that the bacteria will rapidly spring back into action. If the ammonia is down substantially in 24 hours, we'll know.
 
Last edited:
I would think (which usually gets me into trouble) that there would be some bacteria still alive and you would be able to revive the colony. How many and how quickly (the growth being exponential) is dependant on how many survived which is dependant on how long they went w/o food. There must have been some decaying matter in the tank/filters to sustain some bacteria...the question is...how many? Get out the microscopes!!! :D
Neat experiment anonapersona!
btw, are you an alien? If you remove the 3 a's out of your name, you get nonperson? No, you must be an artist! where's the smilie for "nuts"?
 
2 more data points

After a bit over 24 hours, actually 28 hours, there was no noticable decline in the ammonia from ~3ppm.

After 55 hours, ammonia tested at 2 ppm, a clear drop from the starting value.


Artist or alien?? Or perhaps an alienated artist!
 
Ah, lost track of this experiment during the holidays.

On the 5th day (something like 120 hours) after adding the ammonia the ammonia level was zero.

It may have hit zero earlier, I did not test after the 55 hour point.
 
AquariaCentral.com