I didn't use sand in mine. I used a thin layer of Peat, then aquatic plant soil, and then a layer of gravel. My plants have done great. There is always the possibility of sand becoming compacted and lacking oxygen. I understand that pool filter sand is slightly larger than play sand and compacts less. If you want the acidic and blackwater effect of peat, you should put it in a stocking in the filter. Lots of driftwood helps to create soft, acidic, tea-colored water too. I have a mainly south american biome with Angels, cardinals, rummy nose and cories, lots of sword plants.