Better read the ingredients in the Kent Freshwater Plant Supplement. Personally, i wouldn't be adding anything at this moment.
Your test results don't make complete sense to me. How would you explain these GH discrepencies between what comes out of the tap and what's in the tank? Don't bank on phosphate testing. But the phosphates get counted as part of the KH results.
You mention Phos-Gard. I suppose you are also doing water changes? 30 or 40% every few days, until PO4 levels are close to your tapwater levels.
What other conditioners are you using now?
When you say "lava rocks from Iowa" I wonder if you mean tufa? Tufa is a porous limestone. I can't think where you'd find lava rock in Iowa.