Question about how often to change filters

platytetrafan

AC Members
Jan 20, 2007
1,564
5
38
NY
Ok I have 4 tanks two minibow tanks one is a 5g cycled and the other is a 2.5g still cycling the other two are a corner bow 36g cycled tank and an eclipse 3g cycled. My questions are both minibows have a whisper filter which I was told by LFS had to be changed every month including the carbon. I believe the media is a sponge filter. My 36g corner has a filter that already contains carbon the eclipse 3g is the same a filter that already contains carbon I also have a biowheel in that tank. My questions are for the whisper filters is it really necessary to replace the sponge filter and the carbon monthly or can I just rinse the media in tank water and add the carbon also how to get the old carbon out rinse it in the old tank water? I only have a betta in the 3g the filter does not look that dirty today is a month since I changed that filter I am going to do a water change but can I go 8 weeks with a filter that already contains the carbon or do I have to replace it monthly? I was replacing the filter monthly but the filter really didn't look dirty. My 36g just cycled about 2 weeks ago so I wanted to wait atleast another 2 weeks before I change the water and filter I haven't touched the filter at all the last water change was about 2 weeks ago when the water finally went from nitrites to nitrates and I haven't changed the water since the parameter have been fine since then. My 2.5g has the whisper filter as well but since it is still cycling I am not changing the filter until it is well cycled and established there is a betta in that tank now. Any help would be appreciated.:huh:
 
you really don't need to replace the media unless its falling apart.. otherwise, you can rinse it in tank water every other week or once a month, whenever it gets clogged.

as for carbon, its not required for clean water, and doubles as biomedia, so if you dont want to change that you dont have to, just keep in mind that it will stop working after a couple weeks.
 
Yes, unless its fallling apart and/or the flow rate is slow even after rinsing - you dont need to replace them. Plus its best to keep all that active bacteria around! The LFS and the filter companies would rather you change them every 2 weeks - dont do it unless its absolutely necessary.
 
AquariaCentral.com