Questions about Filtration on a 92 Gallon Corner Tank

Exodus00FF

AC Members
Jan 31, 2009
10
0
0
42
Well I was looking around on Craigslist the other day last week, and I happend to stumble upon the fishtank of my Dreams! A 92 Gallon All-Glass Aquarium Corner Tank! I was floored because it came with a Wet Dry Filter, Water Pump(Quiet-One 2200) & a Stand! All for 300$!

The Aquarium was originally set up for Marine, and the gentleman that I purchased this tank from lost the overflow box in his last move. So now I am looking around online trying to figure out what I need to purchase to setup my filtration in the tank, which is going to be a Freshwater Planted Aquarium.

I've determined that there will be approximately 5 feet between the Waterline of the tank and where the Filter will set in the Wet Dry Filter, And after reviewing the Manufacturers Brochure, I've determined that with 5' of headspace that it will be approximately 350 Gallons Per Hour. Which Means that I still need to purchase an Overflow box for probably 600 Gallons and limit the flow with a ball valve.


Which means I'm going to be forking out some cash for that alone, It looks like Overflow Boxes usually run ~80$+. So Now I start to Wonder if i'm going to be forking out that kind of cash (which does not include Plubming for the Wet/Dry Filter,) what about a Canister filter.

I'm trying to put this tank together as patiently as I can, but also as cost effectively as possible. With this in mind I managed to find out that Big Al's Sells the Penn-Plax Cascade 1000 Canister Filter. With shipping it turns out to be ~92$. So now I am considering buying the Canister Filter instead.

After doing some reading though, I've noticed that a lot of people for some reason use multiple cascades on their tanks, and I can't figure out why. The Cascade 1000 is rated for 265GPH, which seems like a fair amount of turnover. In the course of an hour my tank would be turned over twice, in theory.

On one hand I like the Wet Dry Filter because it'll add extra water to my tank which in theory would help stabilize my water quality. On the other I've always wanted to have a Canister Filter.:rolleyes:

I would like to get someone else's opinion. Should I stick with the Wet Dry or go with the Canister filter. Is the Canister Filter not strong enough for my tank.
 
i have a cascade 1000 canister its a very good filter and silent. some people dont like them but i have never had a problem. you can always pick up over flow boxes on EBAY for a lot less and canisters some very good deals on them. i buy almost all my aquarium stuff on ebay and save so much money in fact i think there is a cascade 1000 canister new for 59.99 on ebay right now if it hasnt been bought with the buy it now auction. i would go with the cascade 1500 canister for your size of tank and they can usually be bought for around 100.00 on ebay. just remember the flow rate will be lower when you have it filled with filter media then the advertised flow rate i think this applies to all canisters.
 
kensfish.com is currently having sales on the cascade canisters I think
 
First off, I have not heard all that wonderful things about cascade filters. While cost effective yes, very few things in this hobby can be done cheap, not without a price, trust me, I know.

That said, for $92 shipped, don't expect much. You will just wind up replacing it 3-12 months down the road. A far far better option would be the Marineland C-530, while it is $246.07 (shipped) your looking at over twice the flow of the above cascade, with at least twice the performance.

Now, after that, 265 GPH is not near enough as a single filtration on a tank that size, 2 would be in order, and after its said and done, you have 2 products that would be far inferior to the C-530 @$60 less.
 
Hey THanks for the answers guys, now here is the next question. :)

If you could pickup a Fluval 405 or a Cascade 1500 for 139$ which would it be?

I'm thinking the Fluval 405. I just increased my budget a bit by checking out Ebay... Thanks for the tip :)
 
AquariaCentral.com