Recomended CO2 Systems

FWIW here is what I got and the prices (as of a year and a half ago):

-15# CO2 bottle from welding shop, baked, cleaned, certified food grade. After tax and fees was around $75. 5# bottle was only $10 cheaper and they didnt have any smaller than 15 in stock.

-CO2 fill at the same place as above was around $22 for certified food grade CO2. Its been a year and a half and the bottle is not showing signs of loosing pressure yet. Welding grade CO2 is about half that price but for $10 more every couple years I like not worrying about the possible toxic gasses you could get in the welding grade stuff.

-The regulator I got the cheapest one I could find at the time was the JBJ combo that had dual guage regulator with selenoid, needle valve, buble counter, and check valve, all pre-assembled. Was about $65

-tubbing... think I spent about $5 at lowes, forget what kind it is, I think its polyethylene tubing.

-Rena micro bubler was $5 and used in conjunction with a $20 powerhead (the powerhead is situated to blow over the top of the bubbler so as the bubbles start to rise they hit the current and are blown throughout the tank).

So that totals $190, probably closer to $205-210 with shipping, not including the CO2 glass diffuser I started out with but switched to the micro bubbler / powerhead.

The paintball systems I have just heard abot recently and look pretty appealing, especially if you dont have the space to house something like a 15# cyclinder, youll just have to refill them more often. If you use a selenoid and timer you would get double the time before refills though. The 24hr CO2 vs CO2 on with lights is a whole other debate though.


Good luck on your CO2 endeavors!
 
Goatman said:
I bought a red sea paintball system from thatpetplace.com, and it works excellent. I initially ran my CO2 through the intake of my canister, but recently built an inline reactor on the outflow that gives 100% dissolution,

hey goatman, can you tell me which inline reactor you are using if it's not diy? i am having a difficult time finding one that will fit on the canister tube.

also how do you refill the paintball co2? is there somewhere you order online or just happen to live near a paintball field?

thanks,
gaga
 
I made my diffuser myself, it took about a half hour. It's an 18" length of 3" pvc capped at both ends, full of lava rock. The water flows in from the top, just above the CO2 injector (wooden airstone). Water flows down through the tube and the bubbles fight both current and turbulence against the lava rocks. It works excellent, 100% dissolution. As for CO2 refill, there is a paintball field that closes seasonally, but there is a fire extinguisher shop that fills paintball tanks too. It's common for anywhere that fills standard CO2 tanks to fill paintball, it's a $25 fitting set to convert. You can't order compressed gas online over a certain weight (not sure what it is). Wal-mart also does tank exchanges for $7 on a 20 oz tank.
 
I am still planning on getting a CO2 system...do I need a bubble counter? Is it just so that you can say how much CO2 goes into the aquarium per minute?
 
clayt101,

1) 10-20# CO2 tank unless you have no space that you'd need a 5#
2) JBJ or Milwaukee regulator, those come with bubble counters. Yes, they allow you to see how many bubbles of CO2 are entering your tank. Not crucial, but nice to keep track of things.
3) CO2 tubing
4) Diffusion method. I use glass diffusers myself.

You have no real need for a pH controller if you're a regular planted tank aquarist. I just sold mine.
 
Wow, I am finding this all so confusing for some reason. I would like to set up a CO2 injector into my planted tank as well but my head is spinning from all the different suggestions.

So I need to get a CO2 tank, from a local welding shop. I can use welding grade CO2, if I want…

Then I need a regulator… Maybe this one? http://www.automatedaquariums.com/mw_ma957.htm

Then what? How do you install these? I do not have powerheads running because I did not install an undergravel filter.
 
In my Guide there is a basic pictorial guide on how to setup a CO2 system.

Note that I used a real CO2 system and not some sissy regulator that needs 10 steps to get it going to avoid damaging the regulator.

So setting up the regulator that you linked to is a bit more involved.
 
AquariaCentral.com