Removing Bio-Balls in Sump and Replacing with Live Rock

Ugenstugen

AC Members
Dec 27, 2004
25
0
0
I am in the process of removing my bio-balls out of my sump and replacing it with rock. A few questions:

1) With bio-balls, the water trickles over them. However, when I but rock in there doesn't the rock need to be fully submerged in water?

2) Can I use died rock (i.e. from www.hirocks.com), or do I have to use live rock in the sump?

Any info will help...Thanks...
 
Well, live rock is usually not kept in dark trickle towers my friend. It's expensive and folks usually want to cultivate/monitor the encrusting coralines and inverts in the main display for a lot of reasons.
Years ago trickle towers were filled with crushed coral, rolled pads and well, just about every kind of crazy plastic media you can imagine.
I suppose you CAN use dead or base rock in the tower as long as the rack can support the weight, but what is your goal here; other than a waterfall what is your anticipated benefit?
 
Several people suggest removing the bio-balls because they trap nitrate. My goal is to eliminate nitrate. By removing the bio-balls and filling the space with rock, the rock will act as a more efficient bological filteration, since it essentially will not trap nitrate...
 
I have about 7 lbs in my nano filter that used to contain bio balls. I run a PC light over it when the main tank light is off. I'm starting to get a corlaline growth in there as well. About half if it is above the waterline but it's always covered in running water.
 
Replacing with rock in the tower will not create a more efficient filter my friend. The trickle filter is extremely efficient already. The highly oxygenated media tower is designed for explosive bacterial growth.
Your understanding of nitrate is well, unclear I think.
Nitrate is a result of nutrient conversion. Fact is, the bio ball media houses bacteria which PRODUCE nitrate, not trap it. No trapping here; in fact the various crannies and cracks in the rock will likely trap more debris than your bio balls; which are designed not to trap anything. The rocks will quickly become covered/clogged with slime/detritus/gook. If the goal is to reduce the BACTERIA culture, you are simply replacing the balls with rock (more media) which will be replaced with more bacteria; maybe not as much bacteria but still will produce nitrate, so maybe not the best solution IMO. Before you go elminating or tinkering with your bio filter, please outline your complete system/filtration/bioload/current water parameters and any problems, then maybe I can offer more help. If, and again IF, you have a small bioload, enough live rock and a huge skimmer you may not need the bio media at all or maybe just reducing the balls will do the trick.
You also might need to research deep sand beds and tumbling macro algae filters as options for reducing nitrates.
 
AquariaCentral.com