Skimmer dilema

claygirl13

AC Members
Jan 14, 2007
11
0
0
Rhode Island
So I'm just starting to gather the equipment my first salt tank.

The tank is a 45 gallon tall.
I have:
2x96 watts of cf.
2 koralia 2's.
A refractometer.
2 150 watt heaters
test kits

I am ordering a ro/di contraption from ebay this week.
I plan on ordering about 70lb of live rock and 50 lbs of sand after I receive the water purifier.

So the next thing on my list is a skimmer...
Currently I am looking at the Coralife Super Skimmer and the Octopus HB-100. I hear Octopus is a better brand but I can't seem to find any reviews of the HB-100. Does anyone here have any experience with it? Is there anything else in this price range that is better? I am hoping to get one for under $150. Oh and there is really no room for a sump under the tank :(
Thanks!
 
I would get an Aqua C Remora http://www.marinedepot.com/ps_ViewItem~idProduct~ACRM.html
or the CSS. The octopus hangon looks to be a copy of the CPR Backpack and I am not a huge fan of the CPR but they do work

If you haven't used it don't judge it, just because it looks like a cpr doesn't mean it functions like one. I have owned a cpr bakpak for 7years and all I got was green tea and have recently switched over to a octopus bh100f, this skimmer is on my 45gallon. The skimmer works great right out of the box, its a great value, it skims well.
Heres my most recent skimmate
3 days of skimmate.
skimmate.jpg

top view

topview.jpg


Bubble view
bubbleview.jpg

The tank has
1 coral beauty
pair of ocellaris
sixline wrasse
bicolor blenny
yellow tail damsel
and some zoas

For more information on the octopus hob check this out, reefcentral has a thread dedicated to the skimmer.
http://reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=1260766&perpage=25&pagenumber=19

Well I searched around this forum for some info on this skimmer and came up empty handed. so I thought I'd share my experience with these hobs. Althought these skimmers resemble CPRS they are no where compared to them. The body of the skimmer is bigger, the intakes and outlets are different, the pumps a needlewheel and the collection cup is different. Here are the three models,
BH100F $150~
Module_350_combo_FS.jpg

Dimensions: 18" tall x 13" long x 3" deep
BH100 $100~
Module_350_external_FS.jpg

Dimensions: 18" tall x 8" long x 3" deep
BH300 $135~
Module_2x_external_FS.jpg

Dimensions: 18" tall x 11" long x 3" deep
I own the BH100F and its on a 45gallon bow Front, the live stock is: Coral Beauty, Bicolor Blenny, 2 ocellaris clowns, six line wrasse and a yellow tail damsel and some zoas and shrooms. Before I got this skimmer I had a cpr bakpak and I have been using it for 7 years, and all I got was green tea. But before I swithced to the octopus hob I had doubts because I would hear people say its the same as a CPR BakPak but after using it there is no comparsion, my CPR never gave me brown stuff. So once I switched to this new skimmer right on the first day I started to get pee yellow skimmate which was pretty impressive. This skimmer has some bonus features a cpr doesnt have and for the price of a CPR BakPak I get more out of this. The pump is internal so you see one less pump floating around in your tank, a surface skimmer box comes in handy to skim off surface scum. And last it has a extra chamber for filtration media and a heather, getting this skimmer started may be tricky since it relies on a siphon just like a overflow box with the U tube. But once it gets started you wont have to worry about it, just like any hob these skimmers still produce micro bubbles. but there is a easy fix which is to get the cpr bubble trap.
1017071954.jpg

I have been using it for 3 months and now every 3 days the outcome of the skimmate is brown and nasty,
102707_1916a.jpg

A quick comparison to the Remora
octovsremora.jpg

This thing is a monster.
The BH100F skimmer would be a great alternative for those that are looking into getting a CPR BakPak, this skimmer cost the same amount as the cpr bakpak but comes with more features. The BH100 is 100 dollars is the true look alike as the CPR BakPak but this one also outpreforms it too. Koraltek from Reefcentral is using this one his 15gallon nano and its pulling nice skimmate aswell.
12 hours of skimming
skeemers030.jpg

30 hours of skimming
skeemers017.jpg

Tank shot
skeemers026.jpg

A fellow reefer used the BH100 on his 90 gallon and in 3 days hes gotten really nasty skimmate
This skimmer is really impressive, don't let the look alike CPR fool ya its nothing like it :D
IMG_1231.jpg

IMG_1196.jpg

There are others who have used this skimmer and have had good results from it. If you would like more information about this skimmer check out RC's octo hob thread
http://reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.p...mp;pagenumber=1
Part2
http://reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.p...mp;pagenumber=1
It has some good info on all the models shown above. I would highly recommend others to try it, you wont be dissappointed. Since I checked alot of forums and I never could find good information about it. If you have any questions fire away at the RC thread or post them here and I will ask the others about the other models.
Locations to buy one of these
Aquacave.com
CustomAquatics.com
TheReefStop.com
The following is a user's review of the Octopus Hang on Back protein skimmers. This review was written in the hope that it might supply a bit of first-hand knowledge and experience to fellow reefers in the pursuit of assisting them to make informed purchasing decisions. Some Comments are based off personal opinions
 
Wow! Great Post! I have a remora c pro on my 46 bow. I like the look with the surface skimmer - it almost is invisible in the tank ( I don't like the look of a monster power head in a small tank).

I don't pull massive amounts of skimmate, but I believe I have a small bioload (3 fish) and I only feed every other day. I get zero micro bubbles and it is very quiet.

I had a coral life super skimmer and it was way past ugly - loud- and a micro bubble machine.

The Octopus thread you mention on RC is something I followed when it first started - $%^& it is BIG! That is why I like this forum - it seems to be much more user friendly.

Anyway - very informative post.
 
I had a coral life super skimmer and it was way past ugly - loud- and a micro bubble machine.

its dam loud and doesnt really skim well.
 
AquariaCentral.com