Originally Posted by SidtheMonkey
"Sometimes, some plants give off chemicals, like phermones, that inhibit other plants growing. So some plants dont do well in the same tanks with others."
yes, this is an argument, disagreement, discussion, etc.. we disagree and are making points in rebuttal or refuting each others claims. the quote above is basically where it all started. that quote and another response you had afterward suggests you think i or we should be focusing on allelopathy as well as the other points made in this thread in reference to the op's issues. i, following the teachings of other more experienced, acclaimed and educated aquarists am giving a plain out NO to whether or not that could even possibly be an issue in this case. i am not saying i don't understand it or would like or need to know more about it. as a matter of fact i've stated that i've done the reading and research to come to a conclusion that i won't have to worry about it in my aquarium so there'll be no need to pick plants according to their allelopathic properties or compatibilities related to such chemicals. my interest in this forum and aquatic plants stems from my fish tanks. whether or not allelochemicals exist or work in the wild are basically of no interest to me. nor will that information have any bearing on what's going on in the op's tank so long as we know it's not an issue likely to be dealt with in an aquarium with normal maintenance procedures.
on the note of them being washed away or diluted in the wild... think about that statement for a minute. plants don't exactly grow in the depths/channels of rivers where the water is constantly flowing nor is it likely you won't find huge patches of a single species where they've rooted themselves. there are also swamp plants, pond and lake plants... but they're usually accompanied by a large mass of the same species... not one lowly patch of plants like we keep in our aquariums. the likelyhood of such chemicals (that we know exist and work) working in such situations is far greater with the numbers we'd find gathered together in a group in the wild. not only that, but have you ever stood in a patch of plants on the side of a river and took a step past that patch and noticed an immediate increase in current? i have. all that mass would certainly slow the flow of water, possibly to the point that the large patch of plants could produce enough chemicals to prevent other species from getting started in that particular area.
will allelopathy be an issue in the op's tank with his current stock? NO, and that is definitely my final answer. i also believe that is the topic at hand (making the op's plants grow) and that this issue/topic (allelopathy) is now hijacking his thread.
sorry red_wall.
Well I agree that it is not the issue for this aquarist...but wouldnt rule it out. But my initial statement (above, bold) stands, and it was a further exploration.
Your view is a bit limited re: where aquatic plants occur and their in and outflow of fresh water. Ponds and lakes often have a great deal of turnover...and marshes & swamps also have currents and flow. Have you ever studied hydrology and/or pond ecology?
The 'layer' in the aquascape where plants grow has to do with many factors, not just allelopathy or current. All plants have evolved to exploit certain niches...in many ways. Your comments on chemicals & currents are a bit out there...but at least you are trying to look beyond what you have already read.
IMO allelopathy exists in our aquarium environs....but is likely controlled by our husbanding & maint efforts. And that when tank parameters change or plant competition ramps up, such stresses may trigger releases of the chemicals.
Having had many planted tanks in the past, I wouldnt say allelopathy had much affect at all in the overall success of plant growth, but of course there were a few plants that did poorly and no reason apparent. So maybe....
Again, when people are struggling to understand a problem with their plants, I wouldnt discount it when other criteria dont fit.