Starting a cycle

slowlyburn

AC Members
Jun 26, 2006
355
0
0
45
Pittsburgh PA
Can I take a rather large spunge filter from an existing tank that has been up for years and put it in a new tank up for a few days now and drop in the new fish all right now? It would be like a 100% water change? This is the advise im getting from my lfs owner. The water peramiters are right where i need them. Or does this tank still need cycled? He says all at once with the fish and filter. Yes or No???
 
Yes you could basically (exactness depends on whats in both tanks). However, you would just have a spike in the tank from which you took it.
 
Just be sure to continue monitoring your water levels to be safe. Do a partial water change when an ammonia or nitrite spike occurs. Good luck :D
 
everything in the tank had bacteria growing on it not just the filter, gravel, plants, even tank glass, the sponge will be a huge step but i would watch for a small cycle.
 
yep, like folks said, you still need to do a cycle, even if it's a smaller one. i recently changed my gravel out (rough gravel was tearing up loach's barbels) and am constantly watching it for a mini-cycle, too, even though the original filter, sponge, decorations, tank are still there.

with anything new (whether it's a tank or a treatment for an illness), it's always best to monitor water quality before doing anything drastic, like adding a full stock of fish. for your new tank, you might want to add 1 or 2 hardy fish to produce ammonia to feed the bacteria and keep your biological filter alive. the fish won't be exposed to too much ammonia because your sponge will already have good bacteria on it to remove it, so it won't be totally cruel like a fish-in cycle. if the biological filter doesn't have any food (ammonia), it will die and you will have to start from square one with a complete cycle.
 
AquariaCentral.com