Stocking a 125g tank and need some idea's.

I would only put about 50 fish in there. Add them in groups of species of about 5-6. Add the least aggressive first and the most aggressive last. Yellow labs would be a good fish to start with. Trust me you can keep peacocks with these fish. They will be fine.
 
Compatibility is a tricky subject. What works for some is utter failure for others. And just because something 'works' does not mean it is the best thing for the fish. Peacocks are not as aggressive as mbunas. They are from deeper down and have different behaviors and diets. The tank setup is different for peacocks and mbunas. Mbunas need a ton of rockwork, either wall to wall from bottom to top, or two or three big piles that take up most of the tank. Peacocks need mostly open water with two or three smaller piles of rockwork. If you do it right it could work, but even then most likely would not work as well as if you only did one or the other. I have seen them together and I now have separate tanks for mine for a reason, they do better separated. The peacocks will be more comfortable and therefore have better colors, better growth, and be much less likely to have any health issues. By mixing them you will probably end up with a peacock or two being bullied by mbunas, and the other peacocks will still be stressed even if they are not getting the worst of it. Even when small the mbunas at work pick on the peacocks if we keep them in the same tank, so we even keep them separated when young at my work.

If you go with mbunas the stocking will be a tricky issue. Overstocking can decrease/spread out aggression. However, High stocking makes it that much more vital that big water changes are done every week, if not semi-weekly. You will have to have a ton of filtration, at least one Fluval FX5 if not two. I would shoot for more like 30-40 but add them as described. Add them in groups by species from the least to the most aggressive.

I would discourage you from mbunas because of the maintenance required due to overstocking, and because even then aggression can be a problem. The peacocks are much less aggressive and are therefore easier to deal with. My 150 has about 20 or so peacocks. The most they do is a male will chase another fish out of his territory. My mbunas are still much smaller and already I see twirls of fish and mad dashes through the tank, much worse than in the peacock tank.
 
Hi all, my tank is now up and running and hopefully it wont be much longer before cycling has finished. I called into my LFS today and while looking at the fish noticed some very nice jewel cichlids. The chap at the store said that a pair or jewel cichlids would be ok in a 125g tank with a pair of convicts and maybe a jack dempsey, severum or salvini cichlid. Just wondered has anyone tried keeping these together before as jewels come from africa and im not sure about mixing them with the american ones.:confused:
 
I have found Jewels to be the most agressive cichlids ive ever owned. If you keep them IMO keep them alone. I think a tank with a bunch of 4-6" fish will look better then one with only a few big fish IE the Jack dempsey can reach 12"+. Also when you get a question answered by the person at the LFS always assume their lieing until you can find out for sure by checking around on the internet. Not to say you LFS will lie to you, but 99.9999% of the time, their only in it for money and are not completely honest when it comes to selling you 50fish.
 
I go by fishbase.org, there may be exceptionally large ones out there, but you don't need to plan on an exceptionally large one, go by the trends. Most hit about 10" tops, every once in a while one exceeds the norm.
 
AquariaCentral.com