Stocking for Marine

Hey not a problem at all mate!! I know how confusing it can get with so much information out there. But you're doing the right thing by asking questions first and not going out and buying all the stuff, only to realize that half of it is either not fit for your tank, or that your livestock won't get along with each other. I'd do all your research and ground work first and then start slowly ... not only will that save you lots of money (since all the stuff for SW is WAY more expensive than FW stuff).

Regarding your questions:

As far as buying livestock goes, personally, I much rather get them at the LFS as opposed to buying online. It eliminates the stress from shipping, and you can actually observe the critters before buying them, to make sure they look healthy, eat well etc etc. You mentioned that you have a newly opened LFS in your area. What kind of livestock do they have? As far as costs go, usually, the online places are a little cheaper on prices, BUT, you also have to factor in the shipping charges, which can be really high, since your package obviously needs to be shipped overnight. So, when you add the price of the livestock and shipping charges, you're going to be pretty close to the higher livestock prices at your LFS, if that makes sense :)

The site I gave you was more for information purposes. I'll list some more below that you can look at. The "package deals" that most sites offer for cleanup crews mostly start with 30 gal tanks. So, I'm afraid that going with one of those will leave you with one too many of each critter. Also, the packages might contain certain critters that you want to stay away from given your tank plans (for example a package might contain turbo snails or margarita snails). It really might be more economical to simply pick each individual critter and make your own crew from your LFS. If the LFS is not an option, here are a couple more sites you can take a look at:

Petsolutions
Saltwaterfish

Compare the livestock they have in their packaged deals, and also factor in the shipping costs to see what works better for you. If online works for you, as you said, you can simply pick and choose each individual spiecies and make your own "pack"

Regarding your corals question, I wouldn't think about that right now. Give your tank to get established a little bit as far as water quailty etc. A lot of the corals might be a little sensitive to sudden water quality changes (which can be expected in a new tank). Also, since you're new to the SW world, it might take you some time to get used to the care and maintenance required to keep the tank stable before you want to dive into corals. The LR (with all the critters that might come with it) and fish will keep you fairly occupied and entertained for a while.

Let me know if you have any more questions ... I'm more than happy to give you all the help you need!

Cheers!
Yash

EDIT: yes - it is the serpent star ... that was a typo on my part :)
 
Last edited:
Evan214 said:
Are there any other kinds of starfish that I could get?

Most of the other starfish are either really difficult to keep alive (due to their overly sensitive nature towards water quality), or they might get hostile towards other inhabitants, or might not be reef safe. So, for a beginner, a serpent really is the way to go.

Even with the serpant star you'll need to make sure to acclimate it VERY carefully ... using the drip method is always advisable, especially in this case. I'd recommend the drip method of acclimation for ALL your livestock as it the best way to get them used to the tank water and params. You'll need this at some point so I might as well give it to you now ... here's a great description of the drip method from Live Aquaria:


DRIP METHOD

Cheers!
Yash
 
Once again, Thank you so much Yash. If I have any questions later, I'll be sure to ask you. The current stocking plan is as follows:

2 Percula Clowns
3 Red Leg Hermits
2 Cleaner Shrimp
2-3 Cerith Snails
2-3 Astraea Snails
2-3 Nerite Snails
2-3 Nassarius Snails

THanks
Evan
 
Not a problem buddy ... let me know once you have your tank set up and ready to add the LR, start your cycle etc ...

Cheers!
Yash

PS: Feel free to PM me if you have a question that you don't necessarily want to start a whole new thread about.
 
Last edited:
Oh by the way, your stocking plan looks perfect!! That should work very well for you in your tank.

By the way, as an off topic question, I noticed that in the FW section, you mentioned that the tank you're talking about was previously used for a rat? If that's true, you might want to start a thread about that in the Marine Section as well to get peoples' opinions on whether or not there would be any issues with using the same tank for fish. I'm not sure what to say at all so you'd be best asking the experts around here.

Cheers!
Yash
 
I have been doing a bit of research on the web and on AC and have come up with a list of equipment that I will be needing. if there is anything else that I'll be needing, please tell me. I'm buying all my equipment now because there's a sale at drs. f&s.

Playsand from Home Depot
Aquaclear Powerhead 20
VisiTherm Stealth Heater 75 Watt
Instant Ocean Reef Crystals
Fission Nano Skimmer
Digi-Mag Digital Thermometer
Eclipse Lighting and Filtration System #3

I know that I'll be needing quite a bit more than this, can you please tell me what else I need?

Thanks,
Evan
 
Last edited:
Your choices of sand, powerhead, heater, salt mix, and thermometer should be good. I don't know much about the Fission skimmer so I'll leave that to someone else.

Regarding the lighting, I'd personally look at other options. Depending on what you plan to keep, that may not be enough lighting for your tank. Besides, you don't really need a filter if you have enough LR & sand, and good flow in your tank. Filters (esp. those with biowheels) are good in FW tanks, but are not needed for SW tanks. They might end up getting gunky and turn into nitrATE factories.

Cheers!
Yash
 
Live Aquaria is not a good place to do research.
Hey Freddy ... just out of curiosity ... Live Aquaria is not good for what kind of research? Equipment? Livestock? Corals? Everything? Any particular reason behind it?

Cheers!
Yash
 
AquariaCentral.com