I took it as a joke. He had two people on that list (rb and kuhli) so obviously he wasn't being serious in the first place.
THE PLAY: Mafia #16 'Till death do we part...
- Thread starter judgemax
- Start date
I took it as a joke. He had two people on that list (rb and kuhli) so obviously he wasn't being serious in the first place.
Liz, really day one is the hardest of all. You have to look for inconsistancies in posting, weak reasons to vote, wording...yes it is dare I say "confusing" at first, if you make it through night one it will start to make more since as you go. If you are innocent, IMO it is the hardest role because ppl will nit pick your every word and turn things or read it wrong and you try to explain sometimes making it seem worse.
clown lover and plantling are both suspicious to me, since they didn't jump at the "lynch liz for she is obviously mafia" bandwagon, which I guess was legitimate because a lot of people did it, and they didn't have very strong reasons not to/they voted to lynch someone with a weaker case than I.
Let me look at that, see who they voted to lynch and if they had a stronger mafia case than I do...
Let me look at that, see who they voted to lynch and if they had a stronger mafia case than I do...
well it might be odd or different but doesn't it make sense?
I hadn't done anything to indicate that I am innocent,
I have only hinted that I am mafia.
So I think I'm the most suspicious one here. And the people who are voting for other people simply for not posting or for lesser reasons... i don't know. It's kind of suspicious?
I don't know who is more suspicious, clown-lover who suspected I am mafia and then chose to lynch someone less suspicious (Is dd less suspicious? I havent read the whole thread)... or plantling, who chose to lynch someone other than me simply because they haven't posted
I don't think anything I said has particularly indicated that I am mafia, but it must indicate it to other people since I've had so many votes against me (assumably from townies suspecting I am mafia, since I haven't given the mafia any good reasons to believe I am a townie). It's hard to tell though. Maybe plantling and clown lover didn't read into it as much? Maybe they didn't think I had a strong case against me? Hard to tell.
I hadn't done anything to indicate that I am innocent,
I have only hinted that I am mafia.
So I think I'm the most suspicious one here. And the people who are voting for other people simply for not posting or for lesser reasons... i don't know. It's kind of suspicious?
I don't know who is more suspicious, clown-lover who suspected I am mafia and then chose to lynch someone less suspicious (Is dd less suspicious? I havent read the whole thread)... or plantling, who chose to lynch someone other than me simply because they haven't posted
I don't think anything I said has particularly indicated that I am mafia, but it must indicate it to other people since I've had so many votes against me (assumably from townies suspecting I am mafia, since I haven't given the mafia any good reasons to believe I am a townie). It's hard to tell though. Maybe plantling and clown lover didn't read into it as much? Maybe they didn't think I had a strong case against me? Hard to tell.
Liz, may have a slightly off way of looking at it, but I believe she has a good point and believe it or not, I understand what she is trying to say.
I have to say, your answering has made me feel slightly better about taking my vote off of you at this time.
Pap, it did sound funny though....I think they are suspicious because they didn't think I was, LOL just sounds really odd. As a newb, I can see where she is coming from though (saying she is newb, not me)...I am pretty sure she is just saying that they look suspicious b/c they were not seeing what others did, one even mentioning her but voting elsewhere, try and remember being new and read what she is meaning.
Pap, it did sound funny though....I think they are suspicious because they didn't think I was, LOL just sounds really odd. As a newb, I can see where she is coming from though (saying she is newb, not me)...I am pretty sure she is just saying that they look suspicious b/c they were not seeing what others did, one even mentioning her but voting elsewhere, try and remember being new and read what she is meaning.
Can i ask why DD is in red here? not played before so it seems a little odd...Singling DD out?
I understand your logic Liz but I have a tough time agreeing with it.
Both Chas and plantling voted akapaul
Both me and cl voted DD
Why choose Cl and plant? All 4 of us have commented on you. I think sploke explained his thoughts on you pretty well and both Chas and plant still find you suspcious I believe but voted akapaul to draw him out.
Voting for someone not here yet is very common in this game. Though they might say it is to bring someone out it can be a great hiding place for mafia, the same goes with voting for a newb. But voting for someone not here can help. People tend to freak when they have votes placed on them and their reaction can tell a lot.
Both Chas and plantling voted akapaul
Both me and cl voted DD
Why choose Cl and plant? All 4 of us have commented on you. I think sploke explained his thoughts on you pretty well and both Chas and plant still find you suspcious I believe but voted akapaul to draw him out.
Voting for someone not here yet is very common in this game. Though they might say it is to bring someone out it can be a great hiding place for mafia, the same goes with voting for a newb. But voting for someone not here can help. People tend to freak when they have votes placed on them and their reaction can tell a lot.
