Re crystal clear water:
On Purigen vs active carbon - no contest. I have two tanks right now that both had a bunch of Almond Leaves soaking... until the water was a dark tea color.
Added a purigen packet to the canister on one of them and the NEXT day it was crystal clear - with the leaves still in there. The Purigent packet was now a "coffee" color. On the other tank, with the same filter setup, I added fresh activated carbon. Three days later, I still don't even see any improvement in the activated carbon tank.
Purigen for the win!