correct - but easier on Ogre if you unvote in bold and then place your vote in bold again.
Werewolf Game 1
- Thread starter OgreMkV
- Start date
correct - but easier on Ogre if you unvote in bold and then place your vote in bold again.
remember when Z accosted Ice and I for "tearing into a newb" at the start of the game....very fishy...
I vote to lynch Malefic.
lets hear your pleas of innocence malefic. Z seemed to want to protect you early in the game. Why?
lets hear your pleas of innocence malefic. Z seemed to want to protect you early in the game. Why?
he did??? i missed that. even still, it could have been a distancing tactic. Z mentioned he couldnt stay in contact with his team. Z told us some things that were lies, and some things that were true. He mentioned 10 names (wata, malefic, mike, charlie, ice, coler, KOTD, joander, jpap, and swayde). On this list, i think he was telling the truth about mike and ice. I know he was telling the truth about me and sway. He said joe was innocent. Do i believe him? I don't know. Joe seems suspicious, but could be a frustrated innocent.
I asked if Coler was a wolf. Z said no. Do i believe him? I do right now, but lately i have a thought tugging and tugging on my mind. Was Z lying? Coler is a very clever fella' who would likely have little trouble foolin' old Charlie Stubbs because i want to believe he's innocent, and will look for reasons to.
so, i have to go out for a bit, but will have time to do some suspect research we i get back. it seems harded to make a case this time, people are either too busy or too afraid to make posts. Mee Mee is very quiet this round, she's usually trying to help and loves her little town. whatup wit dat? just a thought.
I don't really know where to go with the information and theories that have been presented so far, but I'll try to make sense of it.
KOTD and Jo. My vote as of this time is still on KOTD because i haven't decided whether or not i want to change it. Both of these players are having busy personal lives, which is not their fault, nor a sign of their guilt. However, as others have mentioned, lynching innocents is less of a disaster this game because of the potential for the wolves to 'turn' a villager. My order of importance is first to go after wolves, and if we can't do that, to weed out low-posters who seem guilty. That way even if we don't have a bona fide WW, we still have a good chance of either taking out a WW or avoiding a problem in the future when a low-poster is turned and not discovered because there is barely anything to compare from before and after. The lynch for JL, IMO, came out of left field, and I think it would have been excellent for the wolves if he was turned instead of killed.
Malefic - After finding out that Z was WW, I was also suspicious of malefic being a wolf as well. I forgot about Z's vote for him, but possibly if Malefic is innocent Z was selling tickets to his train and nobody else jumped on, taking advantage of the suspicion about me and Male early in the game. Not sure about this yet.
I am not sure I believe ANYTHING that Z posted in his "i'm a WW" post.
KOTD and Jo. My vote as of this time is still on KOTD because i haven't decided whether or not i want to change it. Both of these players are having busy personal lives, which is not their fault, nor a sign of their guilt. However, as others have mentioned, lynching innocents is less of a disaster this game because of the potential for the wolves to 'turn' a villager. My order of importance is first to go after wolves, and if we can't do that, to weed out low-posters who seem guilty. That way even if we don't have a bona fide WW, we still have a good chance of either taking out a WW or avoiding a problem in the future when a low-poster is turned and not discovered because there is barely anything to compare from before and after. The lynch for JL, IMO, came out of left field, and I think it would have been excellent for the wolves if he was turned instead of killed.
Malefic - After finding out that Z was WW, I was also suspicious of malefic being a wolf as well. I forgot about Z's vote for him, but possibly if Malefic is innocent Z was selling tickets to his train and nobody else jumped on, taking advantage of the suspicion about me and Male early in the game. Not sure about this yet.
I am not sure I believe ANYTHING that Z posted in his "i'm a WW" post.
