Werewolf Game 1

[MikenDanielle]

I agree it is very odd... although it could be 2 possibilities. Either 1) They are all mafia and cant get co-ordinated... or 2) in the case of DP anyways.. he keeps signing up and then deciding to not really play, he did the same thing last game. So, mafia or not, if he doesn't show up im voting for him next.

 

[IceH2O]

Less then an hour...

 

[ZSandmann]

Wolves Mike, not Mafia

I don't think they are all Wolves, but I woudn't be surprised if there were a few in there. DP wanted to play but at the same time admitted they didn't want to read posts. Still I am reluctant to vote them only because they aren't posting. Heck if thats what you want to base a vote on there are better picks. I think the Wolves are probably mostly vocal, in the past rounds the Don was quiet but the Mafia were mixed in with the Town. Charlie and jpappy still have me buzzing with the way they followed Ice and bkw not posting much at all has me wondering as well. The experienced players know that the lurkers always get called out on Day 1. Unfortunately the loud players do as well.

 

[ZSandmann]

Ah! joander too, I keep forgetting that joander is being very passive right now as well.

 

[IceH2O]

I retract Watuaga and vote to lynch Bkw

I could understand his vote on Mike as a ruffle vote but then he tried to explain it and pretty much convinced me, and when I called him on it, proved to me that he voted for Mike for doing exactly what Bkw was doing. How do you vote for someone for doing the same thing you are?

If he had come back and switched off to someine else I might have reconsidered but...

 

[bkw1982]

Bkw has never really been on a block this early into a game. We're usually content on hitting him later because of his low post count. I think he was taken by surprise being picked so early and doesn't have anyone to really put out there and tear down to take the motive off himself.

I've been thinking ever since that post he was someone worth watching, he is votable at the moment but I'd like to see if I can be convinced of any others more deserving.

I'll be honest that I've never been totally convinced of my own suspects. It was more of a shot in the dark at taking out 2 with 1 shot.

Okay. After going back through the game, I vote to lynch Bkw1982.

My reasoning is because his posts have been mostly nonsense. Confusing thoughts and random voting will NOT help the townspeople (innocent or not, unfortunately). I would hope that someone with a special role would make a little more sense and be more helpful instead of antagonistic. His one possibly useful suspicion is towards Zsand, and I am not convinced at this time that Zsand is not innocent, as his 'lay off the newbs' posts may be, like Mike, a way to keep the game going without burning out too soon and/or scaring new players away from posting and therefore contributing to the game.

EDIT: when i say "with a special role" i am referring to his behavior last game as the Detective. It seemed a lot more coherent, even though he still did not post very often in that game either.

Chalk it up to not having any responsibility. Not counting this game, game 1(didnt play in it), and game 2. ive had special roles. been tired of not being able to post the way i want, for fear of being lynched early and defeating my role. lynch me if u want, i havent been lynched early since game 2...If you all remember sir Topem Hat.

i retract my vote for mike and vote to lynch Charlie stubbs

 

[wataugachicken]

I agree it is very odd... although it could be 2 possibilities. Either 1) They are all mafia and cant get co-ordinated... or 2) in the case of DP anyways.. he keeps signing up and then deciding to not really play, he did the same thing last game. So, mafia or not, if he doesn't show up im voting for him next.

I pretty much agree with the theories about DP, though did not want to vote for her (?) in case it was a Judge Max type of vote. There is still time for her to post and vote. However, I am ready to assume that DP is an innocent and just not interested enough to really play and contribute until she gets an "interesting" role.

 

[bkw1982]

I pretty much agree with the theories about DP, though did not want to vote for her (?) in case it was a Judge Max type of vote. There is still time for her to post and vote. However, I am ready to assume that DP is an innocent and just not interested enough to really play and contribute until she gets an "interesting" role.

I believe Dp is acting that way because of being lynched the first round of a previous game. I think just tryin to avoid the chopping block.....layin low works well but it gets really boring cause u dont feel like ur apart of the game

 

[wataugachicken]

but not if it makes you look suspicious. . . . ?

 

[MikenDanielle]

I pretty much agree with the theories about DP, though did not want to vote for her (?) in case it was a Judge Max type of vote. There is still time for her to post and vote. However, I am ready to assume that DP is an innocent and just not interested enough to really play and contribute until she gets an "interesting" role.

Yeah I never thought about it that way... If she is an innocent and just doesn't want to play cus its not a fun role in her mind than It would be kind of dumb to vote her off. I think I will start tomorrow with a fresh slate and just take everyones reactions from what transpires tonight.