Werewolf Game 1

[Cory Lover]

why in the world would you even commit to playing if you're so tied up with other things??

I can post...as you have seen. I'm just not gonna be like a Ice or a Coler....and analyze everything over and over again. I like playing...thats why I play. If you have a problem with me that I don't post much go and lynch me. Its the way I've played most every game.

CL

 

[Coler]

*off game* sorry to hear about your grandparents KOTD

 

[Cory Lover]

If joander hasnt quit he is now my top suspect. Why you ask. Remember Day one? No hit. No Joander. Why did ogre talk him out of quitting? Because he's a wolf, and ogre sees we're crushing them thats why.

That logic makes sense. Anyone who decides to quit and then wants back is suspicious.

Therefore, I vote to lynch joander. Its not set in stone, and may be subject to change.

CL

 

[KingOfTheDeep]

Same for KoTD. His grandfather was sick last game and he claimed to not have time to post much or read much and kept asking what I would consider "dumb" questions...and he was mafia.

he is about 40% worse now, he has become more i'll since the ending of the sign up thread for this game. PLUS, like i said..he decided to stay away from chemo therapy, so his time with us may be limited.

you don't seriously expect me to be more concerned with the GAME, than him do you? that would be pretty sick..

AND, the reason for me not posting much last game WAS WORK

i am done explaining myself, either investigate me and see that i am a villager, or lynch me.

also, what are you talking about?..when did i ever ask you what would be considered dumb questions? and why are we discussing last game?

err..aslo. before you even suggest it..i did not know i would be this tied up when i signed on

 

[Coler]

I can post...as you have seen. I'm just not gonna be like a Ice or a Coler....and analyze everything over and over again. I like playing...thats why I play. If you have a problem with me that I don't post much go and lynch me. Its the way I've played most every game.

CL

well I don't know that that is fair tbh...the idea is that you analyse and find the bad guys.

speaking of which, I'm glad that the KOTD train has been halted and that there is at least one other suspect.

I've found it harder to come up with cases for suspects this game, because we have knocked out 2 for 2, so we don't have innocents lynched and culpability attaching to the people voting for them. This makes the voting patterns important.

My suspects - no order to these...and I'm being careful

1. Lady G - I'll have to admit that I have little to go on...but the posting during last 'night' together with early post, then inactivity just has a hint of lying low about it. And I havn't seen that Lady G has been trying to help us out here much.

2. Joander - the pm thing is highly questionable.

3. Malefic...no activity of any significance that I can find...yes this does make me think about wchicken as well...but wchicken does seem to be pro the good guys...

4. KOTD/bkw...I think bkw is innocent, which would if proven make the late vote on DP's lynch night very questionable...I did pull KOTD's posts out though and could find very very little...if I remember rightly joander was also late on bkw.

Now, as I compiled my thoughts this post came up :

That logic makes sense. Anyone who decides to quit and then wants back is suspicious.

Therefore, I vote to lynch joander. Its not set in stone, and may be subject to change.

CL

This is possibly either a) just a lazy vote (there are plenty of votes on joander now) b) a bandwagon vote or c) a wolf voting for a wolf but who will abandon ship if joander becomes a lost cause.

I'm sure CL will say he's following charlies logic, which is kinda fair enough...but I'm just noting the possibilities...CL has just in the last few posts been prodded for being lazy and now he's picked his vote.

 

[Coler]

ok those are basically my thoughts right now...I'll be around for a bit though

 

[Coler]

ref my earlier post re CL - in fact there is plenty of suspicion on Joander right now and he is looking like a candidate. Votes not so much.

If joander hasnt quit he is now my top suspect. Why you ask. Remember Day one? No hit. No Joander. Why did ogre talk him out of quitting? Because he's a wolf, and ogre sees we're crushing them thats why.

Charlie - I like this analysis a lot. If he was the alpha and didn't put in a hit his own side could have given him a hard time...perhaps enough to make him want to quit.

I am not moving my vote from Lady G for now, I need to review her actual posts a bit more.

 

[IceH2O]

Okay I don't know if this has much signifigance but I found this post by Lady G

Post 391

Now I'm off to work AGAIN and I vote to LYNCH NO-ONE because I do not have enough evidence to really vote someone off and haven't had enough time to really read through everything thouroghly yet.
----------------------------------------------------
This was at 3:38 PM about 6 hours before night fall.

Now do we assume she just didn't know she had to send in the hit? Was she running so late she didn't think to send it in? She knew she wasn't going to be home in time.

 

[joander123]

ok, im dead wait.

Lynch me and waste a lynching on someone who hasnt had the time to seriously play.

good by me.

 

[Coler]

Okay I don't know if this has much signifigance but I found this post by Lady G

Post 391

Now I'm off to work AGAIN and I vote to LYNCH NO-ONE because I do not have enough evidence to really vote someone off and haven't had enough time to really read through everything thouroghly yet.
----------------------------------------------------
This was at 3:38 PM about 6 hours before night fall.

Now do we assume she just didn't know she had to send in the hit? Was she running so late she didn't think to send it in? She knew she wasn't going to be home in time.

hmmmm...what I think :

a) the lynch no one is rarely good for the town, although I did it once myself

b) the work explanation did ring true but its so easily said and impossible to prove/disprove...I basically discount it somewhat. On the other hand Lady G is new to the game and perhaps understimated how much reading there is (note Ice's suggestion to set the page to 100 posts Lady G its easier that way)

c) the lynch no one with intent to read everything thoroughly gives leeway to join a bandwagon later.

I guess, we should perhaps see what Lady G comes up with for us on her return - taking her good intentions to go through the thread and show us her thoughts at face value...I think there is sufficient time for her to do that (on GMT over here so a little out of kilter with most of you guys)

I am leaving my vote there because votes = reactions = good but I am staying on the thread...i.e. I'm not abandoning her to a wagon.