As of now, it looks like the only person that's completely off the lists is Swayde...otherwise it seems fair game....
Werewolf Game 1
- Thread starter OgreMkV
- Start date
Ok, you didn't say to "lynch" her...my bad sorry about that she is the one you want Ice to hit then right? Or am I reading that wrong also?
Well, I would like to know some reasons for Jpappy? I was looking through his posts and am not seeing anything. Is it because he hasn't been posting? You know we all jumped on Jo for that and he ended up innocent. The one thing I did find was his vote (which he retracted only b/c everyone was voting z) on Maleific, which so far as proven to be on each WW list...not sure about DP cause I didn't really look at his. So please someone fill me in on what I am missing I will go with what seems best for the town I just need to know some more facts before I decide he is a better choice then KOTD at this time.
Opps, forgot about this one...ok if Swayde beleives it and based on the Malefic and BKW...which I did notice on Z and Coler lists (although he was on many people list) I am going to have to say Jpappy also for the hunter. I will leave it at that for now we do still have another full day if something else comes up we can change.
So this is how it stands in my eyes (at the moment):
LYNCH COLER
Hunter take out Jp
Oh please let us be right on this I hate to lose another villager....and lets all pray Ice is telling the truth, if he's not:devil:
i had bkw on my list, but ice said swayde investigated him and h turned up innocent, so i'm putting mee-mee in his spot.
i vote to lynch coler
Just to make myself feel better about Ice I went through a few of his post and I have decided I do beleive him, if he is still here after next nightfall....that is a different story.
In case anyone is wondering why I feel this way this is the way I see it:
Post #1446- He states to the Preist to "stay on Swayde" (which he should), I don't think he would of made this statement if he was wolf because if I understand correctly the preist does not know who is wolf/innocent he just prays for someone that night and they are protected, sooooo if he was trying to trick us I think he would want to be saved then the wolves could of taken out Swayde and weaken us tremindously.
Post # 1452- He suggest for US to take the lynch on coler instead of him b/c it would be a forsure lynch if we did it. If he was wolf I think he would of stayed with the idea of him going after coler and us lynching someone else then he could of "missed" coler and they would still have him and we may of Lynched a villager making them that much stronger.
I did find in post # 1440, he suggest him taking out KOTD and swayde investigate Jp to see if he was wolf, if we are all taking out Jp instead than Swayde I would suggest looking at KOTD if you would so we can see if he is wolf or not. Of coarse if Ice is still here after the nightfall and has not been hit by WW you HAVE to use your bones and magic to check on him the following night.
Someone else I would like some more info on why others find possible wolf is DD, this being my first game I do not know her style and from what I have seen so far I don't get it. So please help me out with her and with Jp. I am still going to be looking at their post also an maybe I will find something on my own, but please let me in on what you see.
In case anyone is wondering why I feel this way this is the way I see it:
Post #1446- He states to the Preist to "stay on Swayde" (which he should), I don't think he would of made this statement if he was wolf because if I understand correctly the preist does not know who is wolf/innocent he just prays for someone that night and they are protected, sooooo if he was trying to trick us I think he would want to be saved then the wolves could of taken out Swayde and weaken us tremindously.
Post # 1452- He suggest for US to take the lynch on coler instead of him b/c it would be a forsure lynch if we did it. If he was wolf I think he would of stayed with the idea of him going after coler and us lynching someone else then he could of "missed" coler and they would still have him and we may of Lynched a villager making them that much stronger.
I did find in post # 1440, he suggest him taking out KOTD and swayde investigate Jp to see if he was wolf, if we are all taking out Jp instead than Swayde I would suggest looking at KOTD if you would so we can see if he is wolf or not. Of coarse if Ice is still here after the nightfall and has not been hit by WW you HAVE to use your bones and magic to check on him the following night.
Someone else I would like some more info on why others find possible wolf is DD, this being my first game I do not know her style and from what I have seen so far I don't get it. So please help me out with her and with Jp. I am still going to be looking at their post also an maybe I will find something on my own, but please let me in on what you see.
Lady G after hearing about her fellow villagers problems offers a hand...she happens to know of this "resume" thing and has way's of making them. She is thinking with the WW problem if Wata really needs some help and would be willing to share some of her wolfsbane Lady G would be willing to help her an any way (hopefully this is not a wolf tactic to draw someone out that wata can "turn"). But Lady G is willing to take that chance, her trust in people has always been her weakness.
Not to add more confusion to everything but I decided to go back through older post from Z b/c I remember him mentioning names and thought maybe it could help is some way, this is the post after he was called out as wolf. Now what I found interesting at first was the mention of Coler and Ice, I'm sure to make us think innocent but we now know Coler is WW, Does it worry anyone else that Ice is mentioned to...or do you think he threw his name in there figuring that we would find out about coler and then just ASSUME Ice was WW also? I really do believe Ice is innocent though as I had stated earlier with my reasons. Wata & Malefic have been on a couple lists so far, but b/c the wolves we have got talked about Malefic I do believe him to be innocent also. Wata I'm still not sure of yet, nothing pops up looking through her post to me but is one we should look through some more if nothing else to get her off the lists if she is innocent. Then I think he named Coler w/ Ice 1 WW other most likely innocent, so maybe he added Wata & Malefic the same way..Wata WW & Malefic innocent? Then he added Miken & Charlie together, I really believe Charlie to be innocent so if we follow the pattern it leads me to Miken as WW? So what I am getting from this is we should look more into: Wata & Miken, could be WAY off with this but it is a start.
But Coler was WW, so we have to read SOMETHING into this don't you think?
Here he mentions Wata again...now this doesn't really mean anything BUT we need to check out some more. Then he says KOTD and Jp are Seer/Hunter...interesting now they are our top two WW suspects, we KNOW they are NOT seer/Hunter so I am ready to bet just about anything they are DEFINATE WW!! And what makes him think there are 3 Barons men? Was this mentioned somewhere?
Funny that was the next hit from the wolves..here he was obviously just foolin!
Another known innocent
The only thing that bothers me here is the naming of 2 again I'll bet almost anything 1 WW, 1 innocent..guy's I'm almost thinkin we should go with KOTD on this one (for the hunter) then investigate Jp, I believe there is a pattern here, I realize Z was wolf but look at everything and tell me do you see what I see here or am I just getting to overloaded in my brain????
im pretty sure he threw those names in to confuse us, he wants us to think the people he mentioned are WW, sure he mentioned coler..and coler is a WW..but that would just add to the confusion..making the people listed look even more like WW's....the alpha probably told him to put those names in with colers to get some heat on innocents so we as villagers would lynch them, giving the wolves a chance to win, right now they are cowering with their tails inbetween their legs, they will try anything.
believe me, as a former mafia..there is a certain amount of pride that comes into the mix..they DO NOT want to lose, but if we make the right decisions..the town will be ours again, and wolf free.
It would help me out immensely if you guys could go back and pull up anything that makes you think these 3 are guilty. I'll only have a few hours after work to look through and decide.
I think the 3 that need to be looked at are
KOTD -obvious reasons been top of everyones list for some time
Jpap - Sway doesn't like something, I haven't reallly looked into him
DD- her not understanding why the village needs to take out Coler is driving me nuts.
One last thing DD, If I was lying about being the hunter then no hit on Coler would happen and you would have to lynch him and me pushing you back 2 night falls. I'm not lying but you make no sense., Coler is more impotant to take out then anyone.
How about you guys underline your Hunter take out vote so its easier to pick out and I'll go with majority.
I think the 3 that need to be looked at are
KOTD -obvious reasons been top of everyones list for some time
Jpap - Sway doesn't like something, I haven't reallly looked into him
DD- her not understanding why the village needs to take out Coler is driving me nuts.
One last thing DD, If I was lying about being the hunter then no hit on Coler would happen and you would have to lynch him and me pushing you back 2 night falls. I'm not lying but you make no sense., Coler is more impotant to take out then anyone.
How about you guys underline your Hunter take out vote so its easier to pick out and I'll go with majority.
The only one I can come up with an actual case for is Jpappy. The voting records and his absolute lack of participation with the town has raised major red flags. KoTD is posting a lot, but I haven't noticed any real substance (valid accusations/cases or anything), which I do find suspicious. DD is strange, but she hasn't really tried to push any cases on anyone like she did in the last game and gave herself away with her typos, so she may very well be a villager.
