Werewolf Game 1

ok I just thought up a bit of a crazy idea and thought I would share it with the town. With the whole people switching sides thing, woul it not be a good idea to maybe a wolf around, unless we really, really think they are the Alpha, that way if we have 2 or 3 that we know for sure we should have no proble winning in 1 or 2 nights and not have to worry about innocents being turned and raising the wolfs higher and higher. I also think, now that it has happened, the number of turners should have been predefined. If they are turning on a 50% chance, that means every second person who is an innocent that we take out is going to turn into wolf, the game could go on forever practically, and could be too much in favor of the wolves. I think it should be capped at 1 or 2 turns for the whole game.
 
argh. i've gone back over jpappy's posts, and I really don't see anything that yells 'wolf'. I can understand having a gut feeling, but i can't follow that road unless i have more information.

As far as the Hunter, I am still leaning on KOTD, especially since bkw is now off limits (?).

I vote to lynch Coler
 
ok I just thought up a bit of a crazy idea and thought I would share it with the town. With the whole people switching sides thing, woul it not be a good idea to maybe a wolf around, unless we really, really think they are the Alpha, that way if we have 2 or 3 that we know for sure we should have no proble winning in 1 or 2 nights and not have to worry about innocents being turned and raising the wolfs higher and higher. I also think, now that it has happened, the number of turners should have been predefined. If they are turning on a 50% chance, that means every second person who is an innocent that we take out is going to turn into wolf, the game could go on forever practically, and could be too much in favor of the wolves. I think it should be capped at 1 or 2 turns for the whole game.

Too late, we're in it for the long haul, that's why I think we should go for the ones we can figure out and eventually we'll hit the Alpha....It's not like we're ever going to get concrete proof like a sign on their neck saying "I'm the Alpha Wolf"....At best they'll act like the other wolves, atworst they'll seem like one of us....
 
Too late, we're in it for the long haul, that's why I think we should go for the ones we can figure out and eventually we'll hit the Alpha....It's not like we're ever going to get concrete proof like a sign on their neck saying "I'm the Alpha Wolf"....At best they'll act like the other wolves, atworst they'll seem like one of us....

Good point. Back to reading.
 
argh. i've gone back over jpappy's posts, and I really don't see anything that yells 'wolf'. I can understand having a gut feeling, but i can't follow that road unless i have more information.

As far as the Hunter, I am still leaning on KOTD, especially since bkw is now off limits (?).

I vote to lynch Coler


It's nothing in his posts Wat...it's the way he's been voting (for proven Villagers, the same ones Coler and Z have voted for) and his LACK of posting.
 
The only one I can come up with an actual case for is Jpappy. The voting records and his absolute lack of participation with the town has raised major red flags. KoTD is posting a lot, but I haven't noticed any real substance (valid accusations/cases or anything), which I do find suspicious. DD is strange, but she hasn't really tried to push any cases on anyone like she did in the last game and gave herself away with her typos, so she may very well be a villager.
The only thing that bothers me with having the hunter take out Jp for "lack of posting" is that is what got us on Jo and he ended up innocent. I do agree his voting is suspicious..but Jo didn't vote the first time & went against the village the second. I still feel most comfortable w/ KOTD myself, his post all off AND the fact that Coler kept trying to pull us away from him that part is a big red flag IMO.

I really think we should have the hunter on KOTD.
 
The only thing that bothers me with having the hunter take out Jp for "lack of posting" is that is what got us on Jo and he ended up innocent. I do agree his voting is suspicious..but Jo didn't vote the first time & went against the village the second. I still feel most comfortable w/ KOTD myself, his post all off AND the fact that Coler kept trying to pull us away from him that part is a big red flag IMO.

I really think we should have the hunter on KOTD.


The only person I've voted for on the lack of posting was DP and he was WW. I voted for Joander because of his behaviour the other day and what an *** he was being. He later said that it was because he was drunk. I didn't believe it when he said it, but after finding out he was a villager I do believe he probably was drunk.

It's not just a lack of posting why I believe Jpappy is a WW. It's also his voting record. The ONLY other people to vote for Malefic are both dead WW's and then Jpappy also voted for BKW at a time when I was absolutely positive he was a Villager. Jpappy hasn't even bothered to try and make any kind of response or anything about the accusations against him. When he votes, he gives no reason, yet he's one of the first to cast a vote (except when we've got a WW train going and then he is silent). Add all that stuff up and unless you are a WW I don't see how you can't think he's suspicious to say the least.
 
No i"m not saying he isn't suspicious, I never said or insinuated that, I was just worried about voting out someone for lack of post (again) Jo really threw me off I was sooooo sure he was wolf and when he came up innocent it just made me weary of other votes. I did put Jpappy in my hunter hit thread and will not change it I am just saying I am more than a little unsure of myself right now after Jo. I have went through the threads and Jpap has done nothing to try and clear his name and I do agree about his voting. Just to clear things up I DO THINK he is WW or I would of stated reasons I think he isn't, I just think we all believe KOTD is also. This would be my list:

1. Coler-well because he is a WW no doubt about it.
2. KOTD-because his post are so off, and known WW tried to steer us away.
3. Jpap- nonsense posting, lack of post and voting style
4. DD- this one I am just going with because vet. players are saying she is acting WW, she hasn't posted enough for me to read anything into her but so many others who have played before are seeing something.
 
AquariaCentral.com