What are these fish??

[KarlTh]

Thing is, these fish don't even have suckermouths; they're carp and have no teeth at all.

 

[meili.harrison]

Agree with squeek, my guess is the pleco is an L260 Queen Arabesque, which is a dwarf pleco.

 

[Xythadar]

To me, 3 looks like an Otocinclus. Don't know how small it is though.

If they are sucking on the sides of other fish it'd have to be SAE, be careful, when these guys get big they can kill your fish quickly.

 

[Squeakfish]

To me, 3 looks like an Otocinclus. Don't know how small it is though.

If they are sucking on the sides of other fish it'd have to be SAE, be careful, when these guys get big they can kill your fish quickly.

The ones in the tank are well over the size limit for otocinclus. Like, 3-4 inches.

 

[Lupin]

1) A mountain loach of some kind.
2) Raphael Cat (I hope I spelled that right).--Talking cat family.
3) Flying fox.
4) Some kind of pleco (but not the common one).
5) Cherry Barb
6) Cuttle fish.

1. Garra flavatra.
2. Raphael catfish (Platydoras costatus)
3. Siamese Algae Eater.
4. Queen Arabesque.

Third one is a Siamese algae eater (looks nothing like a chinese algae eater or sucking loach, don't know how people confuse these) and I'm very surprised it's being aggressive; they generally aren't.

Chinese algae eater (as you can see, totally different markings)

Fifth one isn't a tetra at all but a cherry barb.

looks like an sae to me too. definetly not a cae or flying fox.

:iagree:

I'm surprised too, but today I transferred several gouramis to sick bay because they all had suckermark lesions next to their gills. The SAEs were responsible.

What else are in the tank? That is not typical SAE behavior.

Thing is, these fish don't even have suckermouths; they're carp and have no teeth at all.

:iagree:

To me, 3 looks like an Otocinclus. Don't know how small it is though.

If they are sucking on the sides of other fish it'd have to be SAE, be careful, when these guys get big they can kill your fish quickly.

In Chinese algae eaters (CAE), it is true they can get nasty however SAE's are not like that which is why I seriously doubt the claim that SAE's would act like that. And SAE's grow to 5-6 inches only, no more than that.

The ones in the tank are well over the size limit for otocinclus. Like, 3-4 inches.

Yes.

 

[Squeakfish]

The SAEs are in a tank with kissing gouramis, a lot of cory cats of different types, and clown loaches. The dwarfs and pearls have been moved out of the tank.
And I swear to you that these fish have been leaving suckermarks on the dwarfs. They're supposed to be peaceful, but they harass each other and the dwarf gouramis (and then the pearls after the dwarfs were moved out). I assume the kissers are next.

 

[SchizotypalVamp]

kissing gouramis are aggressive....

 

[Lupin]

I will suspect kissing gouramis more than SAE's to be honest. That is still not a typical behavior for the SAE.

 

[Inka4040]

Take a good look a the sae's mouths squeak. Theres literally no way they could be leaving sucker marks on the pearls. The mouth locking behavior of the kissers however, could easily leave what appeared to be sucker marks. My sae's are coming up on about 5 years old now, and they have never ever taken a swipe at anything in the tank.

 

[Squeakfish]

I...physically watched them go after a downed dwarf.