What to feed a Torch coral

So you're saying that if, for example, my hammer coral grew 1 new head in 3 months before spot feeding, and after starting spot feeding it grew 3 more heads in 2 months, I'm probably just imagining it, because it wasn't an "elaborate, controlled study"?
 
So you're saying that if, for example, my hammer coral grew 1 new head in 3 months before spot feeding, and after starting spot feeding it grew 3 more heads in 2 months, I'm probably just imagining it, because it wasn't an "elaborate, controlled study"?

I think he was referring more so to perception in linear, continuous growth of corals, like Acroporids, not discrete growth like polyp fission (which is easily compared, even by hobby means).
 
So you're saying that if, for example, my hammer coral grew 1 new head in 3 months before spot feeding, and after starting spot feeding it grew 3 more heads in 2 months, I'm probably just imagining it, because it wasn't an "elaborate, controlled study"?


can you prove that those heads wouldnt of appeared had you not been spot feeding
 
No, but comparing the growth rate from before and after, each period being a several month observation, its easy to see an increased rate. Going from 3 months/head to .6 months/head with the only change in the tank being the addition of spot feeding is strong enough clinical evidence for me.
 
Hmm, I see that maybe perception is being a little underestimated. Let me give you an example of perception.

I am a motorcyclist, yes I know... a temporary resident, and organ donor, etc. I get involved in tuning motorcycles, remapping ECU maps etc, seeing the difference different exhaust pipes do to increase performance etc. Now, we dyno a bike to test its power and torque this is graphed, place a new exhaust system on and for a few weeks the person is convinced that the power increase is amazing, describing it as an amazing rush of power... now this is where perception comes in. We place the bike on the dyno and get the data... first thing that is quite evident is that the bike is louder, this makes you perceive that you are going faster. We then get both power and torque curbs from both runs and superimpose them, not only did it create really bad power and torque after the addition of the new pipe at low to mid revs, but it suddenly curbed up steeply in the mid to high range. At no time apart from just prior to the rev limiter did it produce more power and at no time more torque.

The sound made if feel faster, when the power started to come on, it was a rush, not because it was producing more, but how it was producing it.

Perception is a very interesting thing.
 
Just have to add a bit more.

Now, as you know I don't spot feed. I also believe that very little left over fish food gets to the fuge section of my sump...

One day no torch coral, some days later some unidentified coral. A month or so later about 4 separate new torch corals have appeared from what was unidentified.. these are now, within a couple of months about 1" in diameter.

What is that growth rate? I don't understand all the factors involved, far from it. But I do know what we are far from, and that is being able to produce controlled tests.

I don't think one person can say that every tank is the same.. it simply isn't.
 
just wanted to add that i don't spot feed my torch coral or any of my corals. while i do believe that they would go faster if i did they grow plenty fast feeding on what they catch out of the water column. when i first got my candy cane i spot fed it, and when the clowns didn't steal the mysis it ate and grew. after i stopped feeding it i thought it would grow much slower, honestly, it still is growing pretty darn fast!
 
keep in mind growth factors in much more than food, i over dose iodine a bit, and add plenty of nutrients and calcium and my Neon octopus frogspawn grows like mad. i have though noticed that feeding sick/dieing LPS corals that they tend to start healing/ regrowing. i personally feel it is a combo of things that cause more growth, (i never feed my hammers or frogspawns). but feeding does seem to help quite a bit, just like feeding waxworms to a reptile, or liver to mammals, its not needed but benefits well.
 
AquariaCentral.com