I picked up a “pair” of these at the lfs. He told me that one was female and one was male. The bigger of the two chases the other one all over. I am thinking that I have two males. What do you guys think
1st two are the male
The second two are the “female”
And the last two are them together
Cool looking fish, but I think you have 2 males. Both have long dorsal (top) fins & anal (bottom) fins that says males to me. The larger, more colorful fish is the dominant male IMO, the submissive smaller fish will try to get away & look as much like a female as it can to avoid the "alpha" male aggression. Female's fins rarely go much past the caudal peduncle (the fleshy part just before the tail starts)
Unfortunately I too agree you might just have 2 males there. Those are very beautiful fish though regardless. My female apistogramma cacatuoides is much smaller than the male. Maybe your fish store would trade you a male for a female if your looking to breed them. These fish are notorious for have sleeper males that appear to be female so choose carefully if you are able to exchange one.