Zombies -- Mafia #11

[Coler]

My reasons are my own

Seriously folks, perhaps I should have said

'hmmmm...as I look at my list now, oddly enough, I still fall more comfortable voting for JL and Ogre, notwithstanding that e.g. swayde and jpappy are higher on the last. Isn't it curious the way the mind works when considering individuals versus pairs and such ?'

But I didn't say that - consider it said. As I say it I think this is part of the difficulty...I have been looking for a duo from day 1...if the zombies played well they would not be identifiable in this way.

Unless one of them was under pressure by way of having accrued a vote or too.

 

[Coler]

How did Ice fall so far down on your list? What am I missing? If I am a zombie, then so is Ice. He saved me. Why did he save me? I want to know.

I don't presently think ice is presently a zombie is all...I don't accept that if you are he automatically is at all - that's very flawed logic

 

[Coler]

Then why is jl farther down your list? I don't understand...

see above...

 

[jpappy789]

There is still the possibility that there are playing with their own motives...they don't have to be connected Coler.

The best "mafia" teams don't leave trails that lead to their teamates...

 

[jpappy789]

ok I didn't see your post before your answer to jl...

 

[Rbishop]

For clarification to an earlier post....

The Mutant has no idea what vial does what. The vials were as randomly selected as the roles were, prior to game start.

 

[Dangerdoll]

OMG you guys are crazy (yes, I said it again). You are really saying that any I even mention has something to do with something? Wowee... how very sad this little town is....:headshake2:

 

[OgreMkV]

of all my candidates I am probably currently happiest to vote for Ogre or JL

edit : I'll hold off for now and will get a vote in towards 8:00pm EST (2 hrs 45 mins by my calculation)

My question was asked and asnwered. I'm not real comfortable with the answer, but I guess that's to be expected.

Here's my current thinking

sway - 3
jpap - 3
dangerdoll - 3
ogre - 3

lady g - 4
jl66 - 4

Ice - 5
ewurm - 5
bkw - 5
Deputy - 5
Mad - 5

Coler, please explain (when you get a chance) your reasoning behind Sway, jpap, and Ewurm. Thanks.

I am more concerned about Lady G, Ice and ewurm at this point.

I am a little cloudy on the DD stuff, except she claimed to KNOW that Lady G was innocent.

So here is a scaled list:

Ice - 2
lady g - 3
ewurm - 3
dangerdoll - 4
bkw - 5
jl66 - 5
ogre - 5
jpap - 5
sway - 5
coler - 6
Deputy - 6
Mad - 6

I would like to vote for one of my top three.

Would you be willing to make it one of your top four?

well, it ain't me.

Right now, I consider you and Ice as equally probably turn or original zombies.

I read post 471 - very strange and doesn't have any logic to it. Lady G is saying to lynch her if we believe Ogre and JL, and then we will know they are evil, because 'the plan' is to have DD lynched, establishing Ogre and JL's credentials as townies and making Lady G look bad for 'the link' with DD, then have Lady G turned and have her lynched, and again we all think Ogre and JL are heroes and are untouchable.

My question is why is it all of a sudden, me and JL? Mad was the one who seconded my comments on the LadyG/DD pairing. I think I added the Ice connection (or at least parts of it). I know you aren't saying it, Coler, but it still is weird.

Thing is...on night 1 and night 2, the zombie czar had/has to submit 3 names and RB randomly works out who gets turned...so the zombies can not guarantee that they get exactly who they want.

Crud Coler, you could have gone all day without reminding me of that. I appreciate it though.

 

[Coler]

Sway & Jpap - as I was looking through day one they looked like a duo in voting for each other, then removing and going on charlie especially. Also especially just after daybreak.

Ewurm is a 5 because I got nothing, simple as that, not even a feeling at this stage (I did have a hypothesis in an earlier post but can't back it up now in any real sense).

would I vote for DD.....ummmmmmmmmmmm...maybe...I will think on it.

I think its obvious that I am confused by this game. I don't have a whole lot of confidence in my reasoning or read of it.

 

[Coler]

me and ice as zombies/one of us as zombies ?

it isn't me anyway.

@Ogre - Lady G's post makes no sense - absolutely illogical, especially when you factor in that the zombies can not pick who they turn on the first 2 nights.