Zombies -- Mafia #11

jpappy789 said:
After getting caught up, my top two suspects are bkw and ewurm, mostly for both being quiet, which is a crappy reason for both but it's all I got. Bkw is my choice for zombie czar but could have been the first night turn and his quick vote with no explanation and no other thoughts last night has me concerned. And ewurm would be an excellent choice for a turn last night, even though the zombies didn't know exactly who they would get, if they did get lucky, the fact that DD made a case against him would possibly clear him in some people's minds which he is trying to convince people of...just my thoughts. Otherwise I see DC as a possible candidate for a zombie. Some thoughts below...



First vote for Lady G. Not solid enough reasoning imo, but I will let it slide for night 1.



I just found this amusing, yet scary...:lipssealedsmilie:



Said he threw LG's name out there to get a reaction, but notice that he bascially copies other people's ideas, but says he doesn't know what lg's game plan is...what it boils down to imo is DC wasn't sure of his read on lg but decided to keep the vote anyways because he somehow felt comfortable...because she plays convincingly...:confused:



DC's reaction to me, Ice, and swayde for his comments about lynching Chas. Now I'm going to drop that whole argument because what is done is done, but one part really jumped out at me then and I think it is worth mentioning again now...from what I can tell, DC never made a case against lg (although it was night 1 at the time) or even considered anyone else. He also never tried to convince anyone else, just voted because of his own thoughts...



Still focuses on Lady G. Note that this is a very early vote "yesterday"



Thoughts on this post above in blue



Pops in for a vote yet no real explanation except for the fact that he believes he nailed lg off the bat.



Get's questioned by Lady G. He's right that he hasn't followed any votes but he only stated one reason OF HIS OWN, about why he should vote for lg, and that was on night one (posted above).



One mafia tactic that I used in the past, that actually worked well, was zeroing in on one person for the entire game.

Now I'm not saying that DC is a zombie on my list and I would definitely not be comfortable voting for him unless something else more convincing came up, but he is definitely one person I am really considering. Possibly he threw out lg's name at first to see if she would get defensive (which she did) and also see who else latched on to the idea. If lg actually turned up innocent, which I am starting to suspect, he could just say that he misread her the entire time and move on to someone else. I also found it odd that once others started considering lg as a zombie he stopped giving out any other names as suspects what-so-ever...
Click to expand...

Wow, you posted while I was posting, you bring up many good points here about DC and I have to agree..he has been a toss-up in my head for a while. For the exact reasons you posted. Any thoughts on Mad or JL?? I have a strong feeling for BKW also though, so I'm not sure. To say JL AND Bkw were both zombies I would have to knock either JL or Mad off my list..those are the two I feel strongest about. What are your thoughts on them??
 
Jpappy...thank you, but you just made me so much more confused lol. That's a great case against DC, very damning. It's very possible that DC is the lead zombie and Bkw was turned Night 1, which would certainly explain why he went silent when he'd started off so gung ho and innocent like. It would explain why there was no real need for any of the zombies to build cases against anyone, we all did it for them. It would explain why everyone else has been so hard to read. I really wish Bkw would post more. I hate trying to codnemn him based on his sudden lack of posting and unexplained vote on someone I feel is most likely innocent. Unfortunately we still don't know who got turned last night, but maybe if we can unravel stuff we can find them.

I retract my vote for bkw and I vote to lynch DeputyChiefJR. I like this theory of DC as lead zombie, DD as his first pick and Bkw as night 1 turn.
 
I don't know if this is going to help at this point or not but I'm adding a vote tally for now:
So everyone understands I have the name of the voter, then their vote.
Coler-Ice
JL-LG
DC-LG
Swayde-Bkw, DC
Ewurm-Bkw
Mad-LG
LG-JL
 
Swayde said:
Jpappy...thank you, but you just made me so much more confused lol. That's a great case against DC, very damning. It's very possible that DC is the lead zombie and Bkw was turned Night 1, which would certainly explain why he went silent when he'd started off so gung ho and innocent like. It would explain why there was no real need for any of the zombies to build cases against anyone, we all did it for them. It would explain why everyone else has been so hard to read. I really wish Bkw would post more. I hate trying to codnemn him based on his sudden lack of posting and unexplained vote on someone I feel is most likely innocent. Unfortunately we still don't know who got turned last night, but maybe if we can unravel stuff we can find them.

I retract my vote for bkw and I vote to lynch DeputyChiefJR. I like this theory of DC as lead zombie, DD as his first pick and Bkw as night 1 turn.
Click to expand...

Dang it guy's your killin me here..I see the case for DC, but I also see it for Bkw, I just don't know which I would pick over the other at this point. Now I'm rethinking everything I have thought AHHHHH:wall:
 
Lady G said:
Wow, you posted while I was posting, you bring up many good points here about DC and I have to agree..he has been a toss-up in my head for a while. For the exact reasons you posted. Any thoughts on Mad or JL?? I have a strong feeling for BKW also though, so I'm not sure. To say JL AND Bkw were both zombies I would have to knock either JL or Mad off my list..those are the two I feel strongest about. What are your thoughts on them??
Click to expand...

Hmmm...well I would pick Jl over mad but I am not convinced either way with both of them. If jl was a zombie he would pretty much have to be the czar imo because he was under too much attack right off the bat to be a logical choice for a turn. Mad on the other hand has been proven to be more helpful towards the town. I am leaning innocent with him.

After DD the rest of my suspects were wishy-washy at best so it's hard for me to say where I stand on others as of today...Swayde peaked my radar early day one, but dropped off, same with coler and ogre, briefly. Then Ice a little the next day, with lg finishing off the day confusing the heck out of me. Bascially my thoughts have been everywhere...

My top 3:

bkw
ewurm
dc

then it would be...

lg
jl
ice
coler
and so on...
 
Ok, so you really think nothing of Mad? Anyone else? I am considering relooking into Mad, as it is very possible I was clouded in my judgement against him. I am TRYING to take a deep breath and look back, possibly his missunderstanding of my post (which yes, I can see where he would feel the way he did) I didn't mean it in that way and when I tried to explain he attacked me so maybe being on the defence toward him has made me see things that really weren't there. I really want everyones (if they post) opinion of Mad.
I don't think I can/will change my stand on JL, he just oozes evil IMO. If you don't see it, you don't but I want to take out a zombie and if no one else is willing to join w/ me on JL (which if you look back at votes he was in the high up there) so people had to of seen something.
Anyway what I am trying to get at is IF I can take Mad off my "radar" so to say I can completly see both DC and Bkw as Zombie.
Thus changing my list to JL, DC, and BKW.
I really need/want others thoughts on Mad. I will only be here for about a half hour more before I have to leave and wont be back on until 7-8 (8-9gametime).
 
Lady G said:
Dang it guy's your killin me here..I see the case for DC, but I also see it for Bkw, I just don't know which I would pick over the other at this point. Now I'm rethinking everything I have thought AHHHHH:wall:
Click to expand...


I like both of them as evil, however, I think it would make most sense that IF they are both evil, that DC was evil from the beginning and would make him most likely the Czar.
 
Swayde said:
I like both of them as evil, however, I think it would make most sense that IF they are both evil, that DC was evil from the beginning and would make him most likely the Czar.
Click to expand...

Kind of what I was thinking...but like I said before, I am not sure of it enough to vote.
 
jpappy789 said:
Kind of what I was thinking...but like I said before, I am not sure of it enough to vote.
Click to expand...


I am willing to vote either DC or Bkw...I am not convinced enough on anyone else to vote for them. And since it makes most sense for DC to be the Czar, I'll vote him unless someone can convince me it's a big mistake.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom