Zombies -- Mafia #11

[Lady G]

Ok well for this is what I see so far and can't decide which way to go...
JL, DC, Mad and Bkw all as no good, this can't be since DD was also evil. There have only been 4 zombies altogether this game so far (including DD), sooo that would mean one of my 4 top's are NOT evil. After the last few post's and a little looking back I am thinking maybe Mad is not the evil...I have no IDEA what order I think everyone came on..it hurts my head trying to figure out that part!

 

[jpappy789]

Ok well for this is what I see so far and can't decide which way to go...
JL, DC, Mad and Bkw all as no good, this can't be since DD was also evil. There have only been 4 zombies altogether this game so far (including DD), sooo that would mean one of my 4 top's are NOT evil. After the last few post's and a little looking back I am thinking maybe Mad is not the evil...I have no IDEA what order I think everyone came on..it hurts my head trying to figure out that part!

I would put mad last on that list, though I don't think that jl is a zombie either. But I do see why you think he is, his gameplay always confuses me. One minute you think he's evil, the next minute he isn't, but then he says something that just doesn't quite settle with you right...

 

[Swayde]

Okay something that disturbs me a bit about the DC vote... DD mentioned a few names in her posts. She started off with Coler and Ogre, we clearly know Ogre was innocent. She slightly mentions Ice, she mentions Lady G, and she mentions me. She also mentions DC. She could have been trying to protect him by throwing out his name in with her couple of innocents, but I don' t know.

Bkw really doesn't mention anyone cept for GGF, myself and Jpappy.

I admit I just skimmed their posts. I could be missing something. I gotta go, time to go out for dinner.

 

[Lady G]

I would put mad last on that list, though I don't think that jl is a zombie either. But I do see why you think he is, his gameplay always confuses me. One minute you think he's evil, the next minute he isn't, but then he says something that just doesn't quite settle with you right...

See that is what is getting me with him, yes usually I am back and forth w/ him because he will post something here and there usefull and good..but this time I see nothing that has been helpful and everything has seemed off to me. When I was evil w/ him I really didn't pay attention to his post so I don't know how he posted really.

 

[Lady G]

Okay something that disturbs me a bit about the DC vote... DD mentioned a few names in her posts. She started off with Coler and Ogre, we clearly know Ogre was innocent. She slightly mentions Ice, she mentions Lady G, and she mentions me. She also mentions DC. She could have been trying to protect him by throwing out his name in with her couple of innocents, but I don' t know.

Bkw really doesn't mention anyone cept for GGF, myself and Jpappy.

I admit I just skimmed their posts. I could be missing something. I gotta go, time to go out for dinner.

Bkw voted Mad 1st night

 

[Lady G]

Now this is going to throw us completly different but I have to mention something else I noticed, Did you realize Coler voted Orge both night one and two? I don't know that it means anything but I'm not sure. I so see it for night 1 yes, because really at that point I thought him evil..it wasn't until night 2 that I started thinking he was a PR and I had misread his post. That is why I said you could read his post in 2 different ways...but I didn't want to say he could be a PR.
Also do you think DD would name one of her fellow zombies knowing she was going to be lynched?? If not then I think Ewurm was innocent..I say was because he COULD of been last nights turn. I don't think he was at this point but still possible.

 

[Lady G]

Well, guy's I gtg for now, I'll be back later...hope to see thoughts from everyone.

 

[jpappy789]

Okay something that disturbs me a bit about the DC vote... DD mentioned a few names in her posts. She started off with Coler and Ogre, we clearly know Ogre was innocent. She slightly mentions Ice, she mentions Lady G, and she mentions me. She also mentions DC. She could have been trying to protect him by throwing out his name in with her couple of innocents, but I don' t know.

Bkw really doesn't mention anyone cept for GGF, myself and Jpappy.

I admit I just skimmed their posts. I could be missing something. I gotta go, time to go out for dinner.

My guess is that DD was trying to confuse us by throwing so many names out there to the point where we wouldn't think too much about her posts after she was dead and confirmed a zombie. I think she threw one of her teammates in there. Possibly one that wasn't suspected, who we would look at last? Again, just a thought...

 

[jpappy789]

Now this is going to throw us completly different but I have to mention something else I noticed, Did you realize Coler voted Orge both night one and two? I don't know that it means anything but I'm not sure. I so see it for night 1 yes, because really at that point I thought him evil..it wasn't until night 2 that I started thinking he was a PR and I had misread his post. That is why I said you could read his post in 2 different ways...but I didn't want to say he could be a PR.
Also do you think DD would name one of her fellow zombies knowing she was going to be lynched?? If not then I think Ewurm was innocent..I say was because he COULD of been last nights turn. I don't think he was at this point but still possible.

I am soooo going back and forth with Coler, his Ogre vote last night was odd as I didn't quite get his point after throwing around some names beforehand, but I too can't distinguish the difference between PR's and scum...it's sad after all these games...

That's the other thing that I have been thinking about with ewurm. I think he looks suspicious and I would love more thoughts from him but the way DD acted towards him was either planned and they got lucky with the turn OR ewurm is innocent. I am starting to believe the former. BKW and DC now top my list with ewurm, jl, and lady g a little farther behind.

 

[Madcrawdad]

As requested, here's a list of players currently on my radar.

Lady G - seems linked to DD

IceH2O - a possible turn on night 1? Seemed to be quick to defend DD/LG's innocence. His recent comment that the mutant must have been turned evil, in order to have injected Ogre, seems a little off (as Ice voted to lynch Ogre).

Coler - a possible turn on night 1? Coler had been mostly off my radar until yesterday. Posted a lot, as he wanted to help get things in order in case he was turned. A lot of in depth posts (which is good), however, I didn't necessarily follow the logic behind his multiple vote changes. At one point he tried to link Ogre to DD, and then ended up voting Ogre.

ewurm - Most of the folks on his suspect list appear to be people that have cast suspicion on him during the game. He did, however, help lynch DD.

BKW - been off of the radar since Day 1, as he's barely posted since then. As pointed out, he did seem excited about the game at the beginning, so why so few posts?

Deputy - the current topic of discussion with other folks. Cast a vote for LG on Day 1, for an 'anti-town' reason and has kept that vote since, without vocalizing much of a reason. Normally this might seem scummy to me, however, since he's been voting for my favorite gal, I may have not been paying as close attention.

------------------------------------

On a separate note, folks will need to really keep their eyes open for changes in posting style. With the sheriff dead, no investigations means anybody is really fair game to be turned. In addition to watching your most suspicious candidates closely, keep a close eye on those you may be starting to trust. Those deemed most trustworthy are the ones most likely to be turned, as it seems unlikely that zombies would target anyone who has townfolks already bearing down on them.