After doing more research on the anoles, I came across newts (was researching earlier). I was at this LPS and they had some newts called "Eastern Newts". Their mouths were smaller and by looking it up, they grow to only about 2.5-3". They seemed to be smaller than Fire Bellied Newts. Could someone provide me with more information about them, please?
I think I'll end up getting just the newts since they seem to be much more easier and letting them go across land and water is one of the things I planned for.
I was gonna get fire belly toads but I've been unsure with the toxicity that ever talks about. That's one of the major things about mixing the fire bellies (toad and newt).