how important is substrate

  • Get the NEW AquariaCentral iOS app --> http://itunes.apple.com/app/id1227181058 // Android version will be out soon!

jasonG75

AC Members
Jun 1, 2010
1,644
0
0
48
Memphis, TN
If I was doing a 20gal or maybe even a 30gal I would consider plant specifc substrate. However doing a 75-90-110 I wouldn't consider it, at 20$ a bag and atleast 2 - 3 inch substate will cost more than my regulator EASILY.
 

rockhoe14er

AC Members
Jul 19, 2010
2,043
0
0
37
Richmond VA
Real Name
Sean
If I was doing a 20gal or maybe even a 30gal I would consider plant specifc substrate. However doing a 75-90-110 I wouldn't consider it, at 20$ a bag and atleast 2 - 3 inch substate will cost more than my regulator EASILY.
haha true. Yeah i'm playin with the idea. I want to use ADA soil but one of the problems is that i hear it can increase ammonia a lot and i'm wondering if that would destroy the shrimp i already have in my 29 gallon.
 

reptileguy2727

Not enough tanks, space, or time
Jan 15, 2006
1,799
0
0
Northern Virginia
Plant Tabs are inserted every 1-3 months, not every 2-4 weeks.

Any plant specific substrate will become exhausted eventually. It will not last forever. It will definitely last much longer than any root tabs, but not forever. If you are not planning on an high tank, higher end planted tank where the substrate will be your limiting factor, I personally would still stick to an enriched (with root tabs) sand substrate.
 

reptileguy2727

Not enough tanks, space, or time
Jan 15, 2006
1,799
0
0
Northern Virginia
What is high tech about it?

If it is low light then I wouldn't worry about special substrates, the light will be your limiting factor. It is important to maintain balance with all the components of plants (light, CO2, ferts, substrate, temp, etc.). If it is out of balance that means you have excess of something, which will be used by something (usually some sort of algae).
 

rockhoe14er

AC Members
Jul 19, 2010
2,043
0
0
37
Richmond VA
Real Name
Sean
What is high tech about it?

If it is low light then I wouldn't worry about special substrates, the light will be your limiting factor. It is important to maintain balance with all the components of plants (light, CO2, ferts, substrate, temp, etc.). If it is out of balance that means you have excess of something, which will be used by something (usually some sort of algae).
by high tech i mean pressurized co2 and EI fertz. Right now i have a single T5HO bulb 6 inches above my 29 gallon tank and that seems to work pretty well with all the plants i have at the moment. I guess changing substrate is more work than benefit.
 

jasonG75

AC Members
Jun 1, 2010
1,644
0
0
48
Memphis, TN
it can increase ammonia a lot

It does do that...It is recommended for a newly set up tank with nothing in it except plants, until the Ammonia is lowered.
 
zoomed.com
hikariusa.com
aqaimports.com
Store