My favorite LFS in town doesn't require a sample to purchase fish, but they do require one for returning fish, regardless of what else was purchased at the time.WHICH is my biggest petpeeve...When you buy tank and filter, a liquid ought to be required in order to get any money back from dead fish.
If I owned a fish store NOONE would be able to purchase fish UNLESS I had a sample of water. Of course I know my business wouldn't last long
They also have signs posted explaining that fish do not "grow to the tank size", and all of their labels are accurate, containing both common and scientific names, and true adult sizes. They are also very knowledgeable, with specific experts in saltwater, cichlids, freshwater, and plants, that handle sales/questions in those corresponding areas of the shop. They won't refuse a sale to a customer, but they do everything they can to inform their customers prior to purchase.
Personally, I would rather see things the way you describe Jason, but like you mentioned, the business wouldn't last long. This LFS is realistically about as good as it gets when it comes to the balance between business & ethics when it comes to aquatic life.
If anyone lives in the Eugene/Springfield area of Oregon, the place is called Aqua Serene. If you haven't been there, it's worth checking out!
...ok, gonna stop incidentally bumping this ancient thread now...