Mafia #6.....The Play

plantling said:
Madcrawdad-Made a late post about Coler being the protector of Mafia, more displeased with Mike for being the alleged snitch than the average townie.
Click to expand...

More displeased with the snitch than the average townie? Yup, that'd be me. I'm the one Coler kicked in front of the train to save the snitch. :)
 
Thanks Charlie, but I need to hear from sploke. It's important that I hear from him.

Mad. thank you... your vote helps some too. I think I'm on to something here.

I vote to lynch Miken... whatever his user name is

This will be my vote until I hear from Sploke.

Looks like he's gone... as is Zsand, Ice, and the others that were watching.

NIght guys. I'll try to be on at lunch, but I can't guarantee I get in. Hence the vote now.

I might be willing to buy into HN and Sway is still on my list.

Mad is looking very innocent to me... still want an explanation of that... Cory Lover, bkw, joander are also looking mostly innocent.

If I'm right, I may be dead tonight. Hopefully, I won't be though.
 
I'm not completely sold on the guilt of Mad or Mike. I'm tempted to vote Swayde for not responding to anyone's accusations. Just going into hiding seems like she's given up because she's been found out. But I don't want to waste my vote, so I'll wait and maybe tomorrow will bring more responses and clues.
 
plantling said:
I'm not completely sold on the guilt of Mad or Mike. I'm tempted to vote Swayde for not responding to anyone's accusations. Just going into hiding seems like she's given up because she's been found out. But I don't want to waste my vote, so I'll wait and maybe tomorrow will bring more responses and clues.
Click to expand...

Here's the really funny thing. I'm on alot of folks lists along with Swayde. I'm the one who first fingered Swayde as mafia for a really valid reason, and stuck with it. Does it make sense that if Swayde and I were mafia that I would so strongly point her out? Seems to me that if folks thought Swayde were mafia that they would see that she is on their list because I was really the only one who gave a real reason for her 'mafia-ness'. IMO it doesn't make much sense to have both of us on the same list. One of us would be mafia, but not both.
 
I am real guilty of not reading the rules. I thought this game had a mayor and had the botched hit. Seems there is neither.

Of course Coler was not mafia, nor the Don. The only way they would try that is if there was the 50/50 chance of the botched hit. I also think this is the first game that the doctor could save someone from a lynching.

I am kinda embarressed about skimming over the rules.

There are sure a lot of posts and most to the role playing is already gone. It is good that we are getting down to talking about things that matter.

We are in not much better place than we were yesterday. Besides being down a good player, we are right where we were.

If the town votes to lynch Mike and the Doctor saves him, then we will be down 2 players and still have not learned anything. I am concerned about this, because we could just be wasting our time. If the Doctor is sure that Mike is innocent then I can understand why they are saving them.

Maybe voting for Mike is the same as voting for nobody. If that is the case then that is bad for the town.

I can understand the spot the Doctor is in. So as a town, we either need to vote for someone else or we need to get the doctor to understand that protecting one of us from being lynched is bad for the town. It is like veto power.

I hope some other town members can talk about this so we can get through to the doctor. I sure wish they woud have protected Coler instead.
 
I agree that the doctor should rethink saving pple from lynches. Much as I don't think Mike is Mafia, it would have been nice to know for sure. And knowing one way or another gives us more clues to go on.

And Mad, what you said was bugging me when I made my list also. Swayde sounded a little like I did at the beginning of Mafia3, trying to appear innocent with the goldfishies and all. I'm keeping my eye on you and DP, but for now I vote to lynch Swayde. I do hate changing votes around, but I will if it seems my vote will go wasted and there is a better candidate in mind.
 
nickmcmechan said:
Hmmmm....Miken....I need to find out what he is after all the debate....only one way:

I vote to lynch Miken
Click to expand...

what if he is an innocent? or the detective..or mayor?

you want to lynch him ..just for the sake of knowing what he is?

interesting..
 
Busy night! I am working tomorrow, so I may not be on until after night has fallen. I am feeling cautious of Mad, but by no means enough to change my vote. Several others are perking my mafiamometer, but I really have to get to bed. Tomorrow I'll post a list of my top 3, with reasons. I'll see y'all on the flip side. ~brandy
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom