Mafia 9: The Bloody Coup

[Lady G]

Lady G, not sure if you saw me mention it, but I think my browser stays open sometimes even when I leave the site. Because I'm an innocent I don't feel the need to be invisible. That's how I played it last game and I felt no need to change anything about that for this game.

Yes, I saw your post. I wasn't saying I found you suspicious b/c you were on/not on...my point was I thought it had been mentioned that we were NOT holding that against someone, and I thought it was a pretty "weak" reason to say you look rebellious.

 

[DeputyChiefJR]

Ohhhhh, I read that one wrong...hehe, no harn, no foul..

 

[Lady G]

Ok guy's I am at a toss up here, Jpap still seems off in my mind, MM is definatley playing different and not making sence in post which many were pointed out by Rb (I beleive) also others have posted on her, so I am not going to repost all the same things that have been posted..if you look back at what has been said about her and look through her post I'm sure you can see it. Ogre stands out in my mind too. These are the main ones I am trying to focus on right now. So many people have something here and there that catch my attention but I am going to go with these 3 for now. My list in order would be at this time:
1.MM
2.Ogre
3.Jpap

from Ice's rules...

The rebel group that gets the hit completed doesn't get an investigation completed, the rebel group whose hit didn't go through will get an investigation completed

UHG!! I thought they had to choose one or the other, if they chose the wrong one they were just "out"..that bites, I guess at least they don't get both.

I vote to lynch joander.

I had this long post about how I was worried about switching my vote. I know it look rebelish. There are also several of my suspects voting for Joander as well... but of the top vote getters, he my top candidate.

Ok you said "several" of your suspects were voting Jo..so why would you go for the same as your "suspects"? Oh wait no one on your suspect list you posted voted for Jo?

My list #166 and #190 weren't much of lists, but I'd like to reiterate them here.

Charlie - posting very differently
Mad - somewhat different too... may be due to work, I'm very curious as to what today will bring from him.
JOhnLarson - also posting differently and the list-that-wasn't

rb - somewhat redeemed himself... I hope he and zsand stick around a while, because I'm not taking notes.

There are a few players that are also posting somewhat differently, I won't name them because I want to see what happens and who does what when I mention it. But there are some players with excellent, well thought out posts... that normally don't have them. A little mentoring going on?

Here is the list you posted lets see Charlie voted for JL, ok so he didn't vote Jo, Mad is on your list he didn't vote Jo..no he voted for MM so there are 2 ppl on your list that did NOT vote Jo. Hmm maybe the others lets see..JL nope he voted for Charlie and the last one on your list is RB and he voted for MM soooo Ogre who on your "list" voted for Jo???

rb, I never voted for you, I too said you were one to watch. I nominated you for the list that you are generating.

As for a current list. I'm still concerned by charlie. His PC problems do not correct his different posting pattern pre-PC meltdown.

Mad is still somewhat concerning as is JohnLarson... again, both are posting abnormally (as far as I can tell). If everyone else says that I'm wrong, then I'll leave it be.

Note that I haven't voted yet and won't until much later.

Here is your List again all the same ppl, thought maybe you made a different list of suspects and maybe they were the ones who voted Jo, but nope they are the same ppl.

Again I didn't get one of mine to muti-quote, just so you know what made me "look into" you more b/c I originally was going to look more into RB not you until I read the post where you said Everyone can take a flying leap, and you were going on your own..thank you for posting that cause it made me look into you alittle more.

seems the action for tonight is dying down. Rbish just wanted to point out that no one this game knows who is cc, or atleast the way ice put the rules the only ppl the rebels will know is their fellow rebels in their group.

thats the most difficult part of this game. ice has made it hard for both sides(rebs and CCs) becasue both sides are flyin blind. In a way this game is more fair the the reg mafia games.

tht being said after reading plants post,

My Watch list

Jl-Plantling built up a case for him but ended up voting dc, but so did jp and jo. my suspision of the jo, mad, and jp trio fell through. but now im wondering if this was a distancing tactic. Also ogre voted for jl but then switched to jo. more distancing
CL-also on my first watch list. voted ogre(more distancing?) and not many post to go on.

ogre-was on my first watch list, but never made it to my suspect list. reason see above.

i will end the night with this post.

I beleive you may be on to something there BKW.

Okay, Ogre. I am posting abnormally? Please explain further. Have any of my posts seemed illogical, or not in the citizens' best interest? Or is it just post count that has your undies in a bunch? If my post count isn't cutting it, I'll add this one just for you...

Shortly after switching votes to Joander, you posted this.
Well, Citizen Joander wasn't a rebel, and you cast the vote that broke his back, so how about you do a little 'splaining now?



First of all, how about a reason for the late vote switch to Jo? You claimed to have given a reason, but this is the only one I could find. Not very specific, is it?


Then there's this post (I think a response to Z, maybe)

Okay, let's see.... Ogre says 'Hmm, several of my suspects are voting for Joander.' Later on says to Z, 'Yeah, I'm concerned that the Jo thing might be a train started by the rebels. But, I WANT TO LEARN!' Well, it's a good thing you didn't let your brain get the better of you there, before you pulled the pin on ol' Jo.


To top it all off, Day 2 opens with this quote... Not a 'Woops, sorry guys.' Just a 'RB is a rebel!' post.... Why? Because he didn't vote for Jo?


So now that brings me back to your most recent list of scum (RB?, Chas, me, JL66)
You claimed to have suspects who voted for AND lynched a citizen (Dangerdoll, DeputyChief, KOTD, Ogre, BKW, Mee-mee). How come none of these guys made your current list? Apparently you were suspicious of some of them before you voted for Jo. Now that you know he's a citizen, I would think you'd really be interested in going after some of these guys...

So you've got all this going on, and you can say that I look scummy? C'mon, at least act like you're really looking.

I'm not the only one to notice the "my suspects voted Jo" thing.

Ok....well....that sucked.

Well, since it seems finally some people are agreeing with me on Ogre.....I vote to lynch Ogre again. I have very bad 'vibes' coming from him.

CL

I just added this one cause well he was right on most if not all his "gut" feelings in the WW game so hey why not. Really this is NOT a reason to vote someone guys so DON'T decide based on CL's gut feeling I just found it slightly ironic he was voting for someone I'm looking at and just wanted to point out his "gut" feeling that's all.

I would like to hear some more thoughts on MM and Ogre from others.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Where's Z with his famous analysis and vote counts?

Yes, I asked it. Talk about people playing differently than previous games!Can't wait to see the response, which I'm sure will try to cast a rebel spin.

As for my suspicions, they haven't changed much. mee-mee is still my number one and where my vote still stands.

 

[mee-mee]

No reason for why you vote for me...okay...

OK I vote to mynch mee-mee

I better do it now, becuase who knows what tomorro will bring around here lately. Her posts have been rpetty analyzed to death so I'm not going to quote them all for the 3rd or 4th time, but I'm getting the strong feeling that she has some sort of role. I'm just really hoping its as a rebel and not as a CC power role.

Okay so we are supposed to go thru every single post of every person in the game......well I dont have time to do that...I work 12-14 hours a day (we are short staffed at work), so sorry if I dont have to go and pick apart everyones threads....and on the days the games usually start I only have a 1-2 hour window to post...

I voted consistently for someone that I believe to be a rebel and that makes me look like a rebel. Ummm... ok. Questioning everything one sees is exactly what CCs should be doing. Hopefully people will question you too. At least you voted this time though.

and like I said before everyone posts even way after I am in bed ...I really dont have time at night sat-wed to respond to everyone...and when I do, someone comes after me again and again...so i just am not going to say anything for them to analyze....

I don't think any of my posts were inconsistent, rb.... maybe of a different opinion than others, but inconsistent, no.

IMHO, don't lose the realist and anal part of you for you, it works


Yes, chaz... I don't know what it is. What draws us so close pushes us so far. I don't know what it is. I will be watching you dea but not sure if it's because I like to or if it's because you draw major suspicions.

I still would like to know why mee-mee was on people's list yesterday and why she hasn't posted much since. Did she say she was going somewhere or is she "having pc problems" too.....

and hn, yep, the more you guys point out, the more he looks guilty to me.

there you have it. My list of suspicions is mee-mee but watching her only due to the consensus last time.
HN for the points already presented and they are quite telling.
RB for selecting folks and seemingly driving hard into them for reasons of being just different in my eyes
Ogre for different posting patterns.

And the only reason you want me to answer that is because so you can rip me apart again...no thanx....and if I did give you a legitimate answer, you would only find someway to dig it into me...all I am going to say is I am told I need to be reminded of things continuously....I have a short attention span...put the letters together for what short attention span means...and that is all I am going to say...and I forget alot to....so go ahead and dig into me....

I vote to lynch Mee-mee for reasons given earlier

Mee-mee, I read your response to the case I've made for your lynching, and still don't see where you've addressed the oddity of post #246.

In post #46, you clearly show that you grasp that the score is 10 v. 10


Then again in post #63 you show that you've got a handle on things. Citizens have a 50% shot of randomly lynching a rebel.

So why, nearly 200 posts later, at post #246 are you acting like you're now just understanding the breakdown of citizens vs. rebels?

And then what's this last minute vote change? A change of heart? Pretty sure that you were just padding the Jo vote to ensure that you weren't lynched. At least admit it, though, it would look less 'rebellious.'




Mee-mee, please address post #246 to the best of your ability. I know it may seem kind of goofy, but to me, this is a glaring inconsistency in your game that I need to resolve, before being able to consider the possibility that you might be a citizen.

That is all I am going to say...so it seems I will be lynched tomorrow night and I will give a list of who I think is Innocent and who is Suspect to me...

 

[ZSandmann]

Enjoying my weekend. Just wanted to get some posts in before bed. Here's the votes.

Day 2: 12/17 HAVE VOTED ---- Next nightfall will be Monday at 10 PM EST
5-Mee-mee: Zsandmann (474) HN (481) sploke (511) DeputyCheif (566) MadCrawdad (575)
2-HN: mee-mee (487) Ogre (542) Charlie_Stubbs (544)
1-Charlie_Stubbs: Ogre (548)
1-DeputyCheif: jpappy (557)
[FONT=&quot]3-Ogre:[/FONT][FONT=&quot] johnlarson66 (559) Corey Lover (561) DangerDoll (568)[/FONT]

 

[IceH2O]

Thanks Z was just about to post the 24 hours left vote.

I really thought with this setup there would be lots more talking.

You guys/gals have to come out from hiding under your beds..The only way to win is to talk.

 

[mee-mee]

And they always go after the ones who post too much play a different way or post too little or people like to jump on bandwagons...

 

[Dangerdoll]

....I just added this one cause well he was right on most if not all his "gut" feelings in the WW game so hey why not. Really this is NOT a reason to vote someone guys so DON'T decide based on CL's gut feeling I just found it slightly ironic he was voting for someone I'm looking at and just wanted to point out his "gut" feeling that's all.

Actually, because of this very thought and CL's reaction to 2 CC's being outed has me a little more suspicious of him. My vote maybe changing after all however, I still see Ogre's posting style as very different.

And the only reason you want me to answer that is because so you can rip me apart again...no thanx....and if I did give you a legitimate answer, you would only find someway to dig it into me...all I am going to say is I am told I need to be reminded of things continuously....I have a short attention span...put the letters together for what short attention span means...and that is all I am going to say...and I forget alot to....so go ahead and dig into me....

hmmm.... when have I ever ripped you apart, mee-mee? In any of my posts regarding, I questioned other folks' reasoning for voting you in the first place. Yes, that made me suspicious but it never went beyond that for me.... Short attention spans and forget a lot? How about twist a lot?

 

[mee-mee]

Actually, because of this very thought and CL's reaction to 2 CC's being outed has me a little more suspicious of him. My vote maybe changing after all however, I still see Ogre's posting style as very different.


hmmm.... when have I ever ripped you apart, mee-mee? In any of my posts regarding, I questioned other folks' reasoning for voting you in the first place. Yes, that made me suspicious but it never went beyond that for me.... Short attention spans and forget a lot? How about twist a lot?

why are you responding in place of Mad...I was answering them not you...