Lady G,
It does not matter if you believe him or not.
What harm is there in sticking a stake into rbishop?
He looks vampish anyway.
If CS is wrong, you will still be alive and the town will make sure he is staked the next night.
It does not matter if I believe Mad or not, if he is the Hunter, then he will take out CS.
Besides losing rbishop, I do not see the problem.
But, if you want to make a stand between who CS and Mad from what has been posted. I can understand not wanting to believe CS, but I can not see any reason at all to believe Mad. He messed up. I am sure he knows it. There is no real damage control. It was a mistake. His, not yours - unless you told him to do it. He should have came out as the Seer, but I think part of the plan was to draw the hunter out. Maybe. I am not sure if that group thought of that or not.
I would respect you much more as a player just to fold so we could get on the next game. The vampires have lost. Move on.
//game off//
Is there another game in the works??
//game on//