Zombies -- Mafia #11

[Swayde]

this next point is too important to add by way of edit :

Ice voted for Charlie and explained why - rather lose a townie than risk a power role. There is some logic in this.

Neither you nor jappy explained with clarity why Charlie. And you picked him at a point when there was other options as regards non power players. Ice picked him in a straight shoot out between JL and Charlie. Ice's reason has some merit to it. Yours has less/none and it seems like you are now adopting Ice's reasoning.

Well you are wrong. I voted for Charlie before Ice did. And You are also wrong, because I did give a reason.

I can see it going both ways here. If Charlie doesn't come back and post a vote then yeah, he's going to die and the vote would be wasted. Or, it could be a safe vote because odds are we're going to take out a townie tonight with our lynch, there are only 2 out of 15 players that are evil. Heck the odds are more likely of us lynching a power role than it is to hit a zombie *cringes* However, it's not like Charlie to not show up and cast a vote and he really does look quite suspicious so far. There's been no weasle kicking and no early vote to get reactions and I have been very tempted to vote for himself several times today.

The more I think about it, the more I actually agree with a vote on Charlie.

I retract my vote on Jpappy and vote to lynch Charlie.

That response was directed at DC who was opposed to the idea.

 

[Coler]

Well you are wrong. I voted for Charlie before Ice did. And You are also wrong, because I did give a reason.

I'm sorry 'do you actually read what people post' ?

I never said you voted for Charlie after Ice...in fact I said you voted for Charlie before Ice...which was what we like to call 'the point'

 

[Swayde]

nope I didn't decide you were both zombies - you may have missed some of my posts while typing.

swayde/jpappy anyone ?

It sure does seem like you believe JL and Ice both to be zombies based on this quote...

Ice has his vote on JL and if JL is a zombie then so is Ice...otherwise JL is just not a bad suspect at the moment. I retract my vote for Ice and I vote to lynch JL

You are voting for JL, and I have to assume you believe he's a zombie, unless you are. If you assume JL is a zombie than based on your own words you assume Ice is too.

 

[Swayde]

I'm sorry 'do you actually read what people post' ?

I never said you voted for Charlie after Ice...in fact I said you voted for Charlie before Ice...which was what we like to call 'the point'

Frankly, I don't get your point.

 

[Coler]

am I getting under your skin swayde ?

is that because its all crusty and worm ridden ?

 

[Coler]

It sure does seem like you believe JL and Ice both to be zombies based on this quote...



You are voting for JL, and I have to assume you believe he's a zombie, unless you are. If you assume JL is a zombie than based on your own words you assume Ice is too.

don't make assumptions.

consider carefully the meaning of the word if.

 

[OgreMkV]

Coler, two things that I see in your posts that I disagree with is that (and you might in the future) is taking the second night turn into account. It very well could be that Ice was innocent on day one, but isn't innocent now.

The other is just a nit pick. When the zombie turns someone tonight or in the future we won't know who it is.

Finally, I think we've been over the charlie thing. The difference between him and KOTD and GGF, was that he did post once or twice, but then nothing. KOTD and GGF never even posted.

 

[Swayde]

am I getting under your skin swayde ?

is that because its all crusty and worm ridden ?

Far from it. I am starting to grow very suspicious of you and your motives. I disagree with you completely and since I know my alignment, that does make me wonder about yours.

 

[Swayde]

don't make assumptions.

consider carefully the meaning of the word if.

This game is all about making assumptions based on what people post. If we are to make no assumptions than we'd have to believe every word that every person types and then we'd never find any evil lol.

 

[Coler]

Coler, two things that I see in your posts that I disagree with is that (and you might in the future) is taking the second night turn into account. It very well could be that Ice was innocent on day one, but isn't innocent now.

Ogre - yup that is a huge factor. However, I decided to start with a known liability...2 zombies on day one, try and pick 'em out.

The other is just a nit pick. When the zombie turns someone tonight or in the future we won't know who it is.

Finally, I think we've been over the charlie thing. The difference between him and KOTD and GGF, was that he did post once or twice, but then nothing. KOTD and GGF never even posted.

Yup - the difference between Charlie and KOTD/GGF was that he had a vote in a tight race. When Ice voted it was a straight shot between JL and Charlie and the 'I'd rather not risk a power role' made some sense, especially if you are unsure of your lynch vote. However, when jpappy and swayde went on Charlie, that logic was somewhat better applied to voting for KOTD and GGF. Also Swayde provides the logic that Charlie seemed suspicous to her. Objectively, I don't accept that he was (suspicious)