Zombies -- Mafia #11

Swayde said:
This game is all about making assumptions based on what people post. If we are to make no assumptions than we'd have to believe every word that every person types and then we'd never find any evil lol.
Click to expand...

I clarify. Don't make assumptions about what has been said if you don't get the point of what has been said.
 
OgreMkV said:
Coler, two things that I see in your posts that I disagree with is that (and you might in the future) is taking the second night turn into account. It very well could be that Ice was innocent on day one, but isn't innocent now.

The other is just a nit pick. When the zombie turns someone tonight or in the future we won't know who it is.

Finally, I think we've been over the charlie thing. The difference between him and KOTD and GGF, was that he did post once or twice, but then nothing. KOTD and GGF never even posted.
Click to expand...


KoTD and Guppy both did post, but Charlie was the one who posted with "darn I'm innocent again" and KoTD and Guppy are both known for low posting, Charlie is known for kicking at weasles and posting a lot so it seemed odd to me that he had not voted.
 
Coler said:
Ogre - yup that is a huge factor. However, I decided to start with a known liability...2 zombies on day one, try and pick 'em out.





Yup - the difference between Charlie and KOTD/GGF was that he had a vote in a tight race. When Ice voted it was a straight shot between JL and Charlie and the 'I'd rather not risk a power role' made some sense, especially if you are unsure of your lynch vote. However, when jpappy and swayde went on Charlie, that logic was somewhat better applied to voting for KOTD and GGF. Also Swayde provides the logic that Charlie seemed suspicous to her. Objectively, I don't accept that he was (suspicious)
Click to expand...


So what you don't accept my opinion that his actions and lack of actions made him look suspicious to me, but we're supposed to accept your opinions? You don't have to agree with me, but at least give me the consideration that I trust my instincts and will go with them based on what I've read. And I didn't just pull that suspicion out of thin air either.
 
Swayde said:
Far from it. I am starting to grow very suspicious of you and your motives. I disagree with you completely and since I know my alignment, that does make me wonder about yours.
Click to expand...

suspect away.

go out there, chase down the posts, stick 'em up and show me the basis for it . I welcome the scrutiny.

better yet, vote for me to be lynched :D

who are your suspects for tonight swayde ?
 
Swayde said:
So what you don't accept my opinion that his actions and lack of actions made him look suspicious to me, but we're supposed to accept your opinions? You don't have to agree with me, but at least give me the consideration that I trust my instincts and will go with them based on what I've read. And I didn't just pull that suspicion out of thin air either.
Click to expand...

no I put forward an objective and plausible analysis (one of a few possible views) which does not depend on your instincts, which we none of us are of course privy to.

I would be very, very interested to know right now who your top 4 or 5 suspects are.
 
Coler said:
suspect away.

go out there, chase down the posts, stick 'em up and show me the basis for it . I welcome the scrutiny.

better yet, vote for me to be lynched :D

who are your suspects for tonight swayde ?
Click to expand...


DD is still my prime suspect, my vote still stands on her and will unless something dramatic happens. I am leary of Lady G because she seems to be trying hard to defend DD. I am also suspicious of Ewurm and Bkw, espcially Bkw who has hardly posted anything so far and hasn't even voted. Ice is looking questionable, possible turn victim, not sure...and you are looking pretty suspicious to me as well right about now, although I do think there is a good possibility you are only trying to shake the trees of the people who haven't been held under much suspicion so far to see what falls to the ground.
 
where do you see Lady G protecting me? As far as I knew, everyone was convinced I had some evil plan gong on somewhere regardless of if I had come up with any kind of suspicion or not.

Swayde,
 
where do you see Lady G protecting me? As far as I knew, everyone was convinced I had some evil plan gong on somewhere regardless of if I had come up with any kind of suspicion or not.

Swayde, is that
 
unvote John Larson

My current list

Swayde
Jpappy
Dangerdoll

I said I would give a list of all of you in the game - will try to later but now I think them its hard to separate out degrees of suspicion.

The next few names would probably be something like :

Ogre
JL
edit : Ice should be in about here
edit : Lady G should be in about here
Deputy Chief JR
ewurm

and then you have the rest sort of.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom