Mafia #13 - The Witches of ACville- the play

[bluerat]

on how to confuse myself or you lol im still sifting through the posts in between doing things here and at home

 

[Sploke]

I voted for plantling mostly based on Ice's analysis of the clues. For a first day vote, it seemed to be as good a decision as any.

As far as rb's clues go, the first one could have been as simple as saying, hey maybe we'll actually get a bad guy on the first night, since it hasn't happened yet in any game I've played.

Jpappy seems really eager to jump at people given the slightest chance or provocation, which is making me nervous.

I'm not seeing anything strange from Bluerat, I've talked to her a good deal in chat and yes, she is always a bit hard to understand. I think its more the typing style than anything else, i.e. rather poor grammar and almost a complete lack of punctuation. Thus, it comes off as cryptic where its more likely lazy chat speak.

 

[jpappy789]

I voted for plantling mostly based on Ice's analysis of the clues. For a first day vote, it seemed to be as good a decision as any.

As far as rb's clues go, the first one could have been as simple as saying, hey maybe we'll actually get a bad guy on the first night, since it hasn't happened yet in any game I've played.

Jpappy seems really eager to jump at people given the slightest chance or provocation, which is making me nervous.

I'm not seeing anything strange from Bluerat, I've talked to her a good deal in chat and yes, she is always a bit hard to understand. I think its more the typing style than anything else, i.e. rather poor grammar and almost a complete lack of punctuation. Thus, it comes off as cryptic where its more likely lazy chat speak.

Think what you want sploke. If jumping on people helps get witches then so be it.

 

[ZSandmann]

I heartily disagree with you sploke. jpappy has by far done more leg work so far on Day 2 than any of the rest of us. I've been rereading Day 1 posts during coffee breaks but don't have anything new to add just yet. Ice is also contributing a good bit of feedback. As we have no known Innocent's I take this research with a grain of salt, but it is helpful.

 

[bluerat]

I'm not seeing anything strange from Bluerat, I've talked to her a good deal in chat and yes, she is always a bit hard to understand. I think its more the typing style than anything else, i.e. rather poor grammar and almost a complete lack of punctuation. Thus, it comes off as cryptic where its more likely lazy chat speak.
__________________
thank you , sploke im glad someone has come to my rescue, i am a lazy typer
and i am a bit odd at times and i do go off to another planet sometimes lol
and i think jpap youre jumping in the wrong direction where im concerned lol

 

[ZSandmann]

bluerat if you hit that button in the bottom right of a post that says quote you won't have to copy posts by hand. And sorry for calling you a he several times. For some reason I always assume the masculine online.

 

[bluerat]

thanks Z the other thing i was wondering is how to keep up with new posts as in i have to go out of this topic and come back in to see the next, it looks like i vanish only to come back later . is this the norm?

 

[jpappy789]

I'm not seeing anything strange from Bluerat, I've talked to her a good deal in chat and yes, she is always a bit hard to understand. I think its more the typing style than anything else, i.e. rather poor grammar and almost a complete lack of punctuation. Thus, it comes off as cryptic where its more likely lazy chat speak.
__________________
thank you , sploke im glad someone has come to my rescue, i am a lazy typer
and i am a bit odd at times and i do go off to another planet sometimes lol
and i think jpap youre jumping in the wrong direction where im concerned lol

If you think I am jumping on you then I don't mean to. I find you suspicious and I can mostly contribute that to me being "newb-paranoid" and the way you post. But after the first couple of days you should know that being a confused newb won't cut it.

 

[jpappy789]

Yay! My new n. multies are finally coming out of the shells! They are so cool looking!!!

Just thought I would share my excitmenet...

 

[IceH2O]

Early day which is good, I get to spend time on those posts

Just to refresh your memory, Ice.

Yep at the time I thought LG was acting weird. I even had a vote on her. She cleared herself IMO and thats when I switched over to you.

Ice the reason I asked Lg if she would switch was because she said herself she would switch to plant because she didn't really like her jm vote but plant only had 3 at the time while jm had 5. Then b switched off of jm, probably becuase he didn't want to get blamed for the vote with no reason and I thought lg would end up switching to plant because it made a difference so I asked but it was already night by then...I wasn't trying to push a plant vote. If I were a witch, why wouldn't I just let jm die? Just to clarify...

Never implied you were witch, just wondering if you had the same feelings as me on Plant.It seemed it was so.

as much as I want to have some kind of read from plant and sploke, I get nothing from them. I am concerned though because there were votes on plant last night.... anyone care to justify?

Let me pull the JM posts and I'll let you decide.

What really bothers me about these clues is ow Ice took them and used them to swing his vote to plant because he insinuated that she was the HP even though the clue he used could not be taken that way if you read it correctly...



This first "clue" is directed at the townies



notice how this next one begins...some, meaning all the witches



Ice first thinks it pertains the Hp and thinks it must be plant because a plantinling is green like the font...I agree it is a stretch

I admitted it was a stretch



The Ice's vote on Plant because he thinks she is the HP and he feels compelled to vote for her...seem suspicious to anyone else? Thats quite an accusation for not reading the clues correctly...

Somehow Brkd switch to plantling may be connected to this, I don't know how but Ice seems more witchy to me

You missed this post, was it an accidental miss or a convient miss?

The more I look at the "clues" the more I think they aren't clues. I think Rb is just casting spells.



The 1st one I think is one for me to use to protect myself so I can get through night 1.

The 2nd one is just acknowledging the HP

The 3rd is probably just acknowledging the Prophet

None of them actually point to any one person IMO. The last post does but not as to their game status.

The last one I think its more a spell he casts to get low posters, Blue and possibly JM to post.

I'm going to get down into the nit and grit of the posts and see what comes from it. Hopefully it will either show me who is evil or show me where I was wrong on an innocent. Either way works for me.