I've seen this pattern from JM before. Its aggravating but not necessarily incriminating, she goes off about how she's picking up on clues no one else sees and has things figured out, but then doesn't tell anyone whats going on. Not exactly new...
I've seen this behavior from JM before as well. What I do find interesting is her excuse of a million wordxs of all the things she is so busy with but yet still gets to post that she is so if that makes sense. While I am still so sorry for the whole puppy thing that fell into the middle of last game, it was one of the excuses... well, really the only one I would take. Yes, everyone is busy.... perhaps that time spent doing other things could be used to think about who you find innocent or guilty. Then being as you don't have the time to post so much, simply state as much and that you have been thinking.... then post your thought. Should take no more than a few minutes. JM knows better than to post that she's got a few ideas and to leave it at that. She has made her 1st mistake in appearing to be helpful without being helpful. A strong clue that we have found. Sorry Jules...
That said, I'm headed out for the day, got lots of shopping and stuff so won't for a few hours at the least. Townies, hang tight. We are going to finish this one off as victors!
Well statements like this muddy the waters IMO. It's early, but JM's behaviour already looks scummy to me.
Jm that whole "you guys" and stuff did make you look highly suspicious to me last game. I am also very wary of your excuses. You had tons of excuses last game for why you weren't posting, even though you actually were quite active. I see your excuses beginning again. I do believe they are real excuses, however, I think they are unnecessary to give us a laundry list of every activity and to cover your butt so much. Makes you look like your trying to hide something and appear to be a townie, when your really not.
Here Sploke posts that this is normal JM behavior IHO.
DD has played on a mafia team with JM and I. She knows JM is always biting at the bit to post. In the past couple of games JM has been all over the place and her posts made no sense for the most part. She was evil in those games. She was neither posting a lot of crazy this game, at this time I was pretty sure JM was innocent.
Charlie then uses these posts to point fingers.Sway also acknowledges JMs excuses.
DD is the only one to vote JM
I don't think IMO ATM any of the 4 are witches.
I wanted to put JMs lists here for refrence
1st List post 147
so, as follows, my list of "witches are"
Ice: You seem a little jumpy here for some reason, I think you might be a little more so than usual.
KOTD: just got your PM?...which was ok in its self, except, that like 4 people tried to cover for you, and you then brought it back up to re-clarify it, when it was all but forgotten.
PLant, you jumped in right after kings post, and clarified it for him, ..trying to cover the other members of your coven?....
DD: what the hell girl?..jumping quick this game are we?...Yes I was evil last game, lol, but I am not this game, and I have nothing to hide. Last game has nothing to do with this one, and you my dear, are a little feisty.
charlie?..You throw stones so early, but forget that your windows are made of glass?, or are your windows protected by your spells?..
2nd list Post 169
I agree on the DD and plant thing, ..however, I am a little off on the Z and ogre thing..Lady G always seems evil to me, but I really don't know.
Good Morning! Busy Night, it's going to be one of those Day 1's with a thousand changed votes, as long as we end up on a witch though. I don't want to give a list this early, yesterday was mainly fun posts but a few interesting things were revealed.
JM withholds her thoughts, not a betterment for the Town.
Charlie jumped in and accused half the town.
Lady G got rolled by several people but I haven't really seen what the fuss is about.
King got called out for being #13. I know Day 1 is hard, but I hope we can find better reasons than this.
Of all this I think the JM thing bugs me the most.
I vote to burn JudgeMax at the stake.
But I'm also looking for a post from the second newbie.
Here Z votes for JM for witholding info. Post 129.
JM posts a list in post 147 refer to above lists
Post 155 Z says:
BrkD: I don't really understand the way you are coming into this game. You post a lot of accusations but nothing to back them up. And the "room" comment still bugs me.
JM: I don't find you any more guilty than anyone else right now. But I ask you to share any ideas you come up with.
So JM isn't guilty IHO but the vote stays.
Post 260
I agree with you, JM hasn't answered my questions either, but wanted to point out what she said wasn't really a slip. It was withholding information more than anything. I mean it could of been nothing more than a hunch she had but JM's lists are notorious whether she wants them to be or not, and if she has one I'd like for her to share it with us.
At this point JM had already thrown a list twice, but Z still claims she is witholding info.
Hi King. What do you think of JM right now? Actually this goes to everyone. She's the leading candidate right now and I just want to know how many folks feel she is Innocnet vs. Witchy. If you don't have an opinion that is fine as well.
I have 5 votes on JM, three on plantling and DC, 2 on Ice, and 1 on Charlie and Lady G.
He asks everyone their opinions while still keeping his vote on her. Makes it a point to let us know she is the leading vote getter.
I'm agreeing with the JM sentiments, but I'm not yet willing to vote for her. I'd like to see her reasoning against the claims.
Good call Lady G, just checking. ;-)
I was drinking and watching football from 1 pm until I posted last night, thanks. I really have no reason to play around like I want to trick people so badly. Let's get real here. Sway, you've been after me every game for the same reason and when you finally get me killed you find out I was innocent and then say some silly thing like, "oh I read him wrong." Well it's time for you to stop reading me wrong and look for real suspects. I'm gonna go after JM since we've gotten very little from her since the slip was pointed out. Sorry I was busy out having a life, apparently you actually get crucified in this game for it.
I vote to burn JM at the stake.
Here DC votes for JM for the same reason he is upset at Sway for voting him.
I'm not voting for JM because of her low post counts. I'm voting based on her allusion to having info on the first day. The first day is always a mad grasp for straws. We all know this. Once again I'd like to reiterate a point I've made before, low posts have never pointed to guilt or innocence. In the the BioBadlands game, BKW was quite vocal and was the leader of the badguys. We need to find better clues than this person doesn't talk much.
This post DC says he isn't voting for JM because of the low post but because of very little info. Again at this time JM had posted 2 lists.
DC post 305
I haven't seen a lot that makes me super suspicious yet. The newbies are playing weird but that's pretty normal. Everyone's acting like their normal selves. Right now I think DD, LG and Jpap are probably innocent. Mostly because their styles seem more relaxed and talkative than the times when they're evil. ZSand, Swayde and CS have my interest but I need to see more of them before I make any decisions one way or another. KOTD and Ogre have been quiet but their few posts have had logic to them. I guess I'll keep rereading and looking for stuff.
No mention of JM but the vote stays.
His list of 3 groups I find interesting also.
DD LG Jpap innocents. I think so also, this is a list to help him look good.
Zsand, Sway Charlie. I think he names 1 witch in this list. Preemptive distancing in case the evil one gets lynched. 2 others to use as innocent shields.
Kotd and Ogre, a smidgen of protection here?
Alright, just some notes of interest:
Ice saying he'll vote for low posters in post 11, then in post 28 he votes for Lady G.
Lady G is all over the place again and maybe kicking in doors but also accusing someone of not noticing her misspelling is a bit strange as she misspells all the time.
Charlie, the chicken-choker seems to be kicking in doors as well, but is chicken choker a promotion from shoe-shine boy?
JMax, who has been questioned many times about her supposed thoughts but still yet to appear w/ an answer.
That's all for now, have to go fix and have lunch and the kids have been wanting to go to the park. BBL w/more thoughts. Hopefully the other newbie will have posted by then.
For now just for vote=reaction=answers sake,
I vote to burn Ice at the stake, subject to change.
Here is Plants early list "of interest". Since I consider Charlie innocent ATM its a list of all innocents.It is true at this point JM hasn't made a list yet.
Watch it Jmax, it's words like these that got you in trouble last game, so if you are indeed a townie, then you'd best align yourself w/us by using US's and WE's.
Well intentioned advice or nit picking hoping to get something started?
Jmax also has a bat flying in her background...she has been what I would consider a low poster also.
Yes, Jmax does, and I was wondering why Ice didn't mention that. Also I was wrong about the 4 way tie. JM actually had 3 votes when Ice pulled off of you and voted for Z and then switched to me which tied us. Can't help but wonder if there's a connection there.
Wanted to make sure we also new JM had a bat in her avatar then tries to link JM to me who she has pegged as evil.
well im off to work now and after pondering what i have read
i vote to burn judge
you say alot and nothing at the same time
This vote came out of nowhere, I think she was just following the votes, no opinion either way on her yet.
For the ones on JM I feel as though DC is the best bet. Z a close second.
I still feel as though Plantling might be witch but the posts aren't as harsh as I thought on JM. Could just be that she is on my *** so hard.
I'll get some posts on LG up in a little while, hers will be easier since its mostly lists I want to deal with.
