Mafia #13 - The Witches of ACville- the play

charlie_stubbs said:
I think Brk is a witch. The vote switch to plantling is strange to say the least.

I still want to see DC's prime suspects. I asked him to post it this morning, but he still hasn't. DC is acting suspiciously. The "drunk" post certainly looks a little contrived, as DD pointed out.
Click to expand...

I would too though I kind of want to see everyones suspects.

I will start with a numbered list:

Brkd-3
DC-3
sploke-4
ogre-5
KOTD-5
Ice-5
plant-5
Chas-5
bluerat- 5
ZS-6
sway-6
DD-7

Not a whole lot of help because a lot of people are 5's after only one night but its a start
 
Lady G said:
JM-holding her "info", also the fish tank thing..now I was teasing her about posting pic's so she could "prove" that was really going on, but really I kinda thought she would at least respond to my post, she didn't and I do find that a little off IMO.

Chas-Coming out and jumping on everyone, stating he is changing his style..I mean really would anyone of said something about him "spacing" his statements?

Brk-Not posting, now this one is new so I'm giving the benifit of the doubt there. But still would like to hear from him/her.

That's about it at this point..not much like I said.
Click to expand...

Lady G said:
I just wanted to comment...ummm so? I saw nothing suspicious and didn't want it to look like I did at that point, so what?


For one I don't think I have really been all over the place, so not sure where that came from. Also I find it odd that you mention 3 different ppl here but vote for someone not on your "suspisions"? I agree w/ question answer theory but....it just seemed odd in this post. Also did you read the posting that lead up to the mis spelling comment??? Pointing out here that Plant did infact name me on her list, LG missed it


Ok, I wasn't going to pick on you much the first day b/c of you being new and all, but this just jumped out at me and I HAVE to say something here. I highlighted the part I found "odd" now typing mistakes happen (believe me I do my share and get reamed for it) but where you ready to say Ice and Dep ARE innocent???
Hmmm...this just doesn't sit well w/ me B.

And with this post I would like to add Plant to my list. I can't shake the whole post to KOTD about his pm that is my biggest thing...I know it doesn't seem like much. Then added to that is the post where she say's I've been all over the place...yes I know most 1st day's I am and before the day is over I will of most likely seen something odd by each person, but at that point really I hadn't been. Then the whole bringing up the "mis spelling" posting between Sploke and I, if she had read what lead up to that she should of known what was going on...nothing really to note, just a little 1st day fun. Lastly she makes a list of who she feels is suspisious, but vote for someone else?? Ice has posted alot so far and I really see the "getting answers" vote as more for low posters JMO.

And for now I am going to vote to burn Plant at the stake.
Click to expand...

Lady G said:
Actually Ogre, there may be something to this Ice, Br, Dep thing you have...Br is new (obviously) in his post that bugged me he wrote that Ice and Dep are seem to be innocent. Now either he is witch (sounds funny calling a guy witch) and wants to make it look like he thinks they are innocent b/c he knows they are not (being on his team), or he is naming them as innocent knowing they really are and if he is burned we would think they are evil also thus taking 2 innocents when he is found to be witch. Honestly at that point when he named them as innocent, I don't think much had happened to actually come out and say I think so/so is innocent.

For the record, I am thinking our newb is witch, not sure on Dep or Ice at this point. Dep isn't posting much to judge on and Ice really seems like Ice to me throwing things out "just to see how others react". Then pouncing on them when they do.
Click to expand...

Lady G said:
You could obviously add me to that whole "odd" thing!!:D

"Yes, Jmax does, and I was wondering why Ice didn't mention that. Also I was wrong about the 4 way tie. JM actually had 3 votes when Ice pulled off of you and voted for Z and then switched to me which tied us. Can't help but wonder if there's a connection there"
This is really what I wanted to comment on, of coarse it wont bring it over in my quote..since it was a quote w/in a quote...but yes I was wondering that myself, that would be why after he posted it I pointed out Jmax had one also and then started looking more into things as they were posted and decided she fit the whole "bat" theory best IMO.

Since this was brought up I do at this time want to retract my vote for Plant...and vote to burn Jmax

Of coarse this is subject to change at anytime, others it may be switched to would be DC, back to plant or Ice.
Click to expand...

Lady G said:
Guy's I'm getting the pre-burning jitters....my head keeps going back and forth right now between Jmax and Plant, then DD's post about Jpap stands out to me AHHHHH, I wish Jmax would post I hate voting someone who hasn't posted any response and am thinking about switching back to Plant, I feel strong about both.
Click to expand...

suspects bolded

Take from it what you will. I actually think it helped keep Plant on my witchy side.




KingOfTheDeep said:
this is a very good post, very logical..i can definitely see the point about LG, and i have been suspicious of her since my first post..

so for now, i vote to burn ladyG
Click to expand...


This post I found really interesting. DD puts LG in the cat category for that spell. KOTD latches onto it but there are people who actually have cats in their avatars that would make just as good a match.

Doesn't seem like much but neither was the reason for buying into the LG vote.

So my list basically stays the same

Bk
DC
Z
KOTD
Ogre
Plantling

Not knowing how many witches there 1 or 2 would have to be dropped,I doubt there are 6 of them, probably 4. I'm leaning to the bottom 2 as less witchy then the others.
 
I have DC listed as one of my top contenders. I think all the reasons have already been stated.

There seems to me to be a connection between Ice and DC. I still like Ice as a witch, so that pushes DC to witchiness as well.

As to the fourth and/or possible fifth witches. I have no idea at this point.

I vote to burn brk
 
After a review of DC's posts. I find nothing terribly original in any of them. HE always seems to be agreeing with someone else or stating something obvious or without any support (" I still think DD is innocent and I'm beginning to believe Sway more now by some of her recent posts")

So, based on those weak findings, I'm still thinking he's witchy.
 
OgreMkV said:
After a review of DC's posts. I find nothing terribly original in any of them. HE always seems to be agreeing with someone else or stating something obvious or without any support (" I still think DD is innocent and I'm beginning to believe Sway more now by some of her recent posts")

So, based on those weak findings, I'm still thinking he's witchy.
Click to expand...
This is what i get too. Generally agreeing, not much beating the bushes, then the drunk post, which DD pointed out looks like a excuse for low posting....very witchy...
 
For now, I guess I will put my vote in for BrkD. I see he hasn't been here since 2ish am this morning so I am curious to see how he reacts to the votes. I would like him to convince me that I am incorrect in my thoughts. I am open to accepting that he is a townie if I feel by his explanations, that he is.

As far as DC, I am also concerned to see what his defense would be as he is who I will probably change my vote to due to his unhelpful posts and the drunk one. The problem is, I just don't think it's a lot to go on in calling him witchy but I am watching him.

Ice, I was more so leaning Ice witchy yesterday but these posts today seem to change my mind. I don't know if it is him being helpful or him trying to lead the town away. He is a leader and knows how to direct the group. For that, I am afraid and is what makes me nervous about him.

Ice, I do have a question I would like you to clarify for me. Why is it if B is found witchy, that plant is cleared and probably innocent?

For now, I vote to burn BrkD at the stake
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom