Mafia #14 -- The Play

[OgreMkV]

Here is the scary part, I agree with Ogre's list so far. I know it is real early to make a list, but the top three I think should be watched. I also have a bad feeling about DP. I think they should have had a better excuse for not coming to the thread sooner.

It's not quite a first, but I'll note the date

 

[judgemax]

Not coming to the thread sooner?? I think the only one on that "list" that didn't show early was DP. Let's see I posted like 3-4 times before you came on and posted...and not protecting him but Charlie posted quite a few before you came on also, oh went back and looked Jmax posted a few before you also...so yeah the only one on that list that didn't post before you was DP. Kinda odd for you to say we didn't have good excuses for not posting earlier when you in fact posted after 3 of the 4 on that list.:huh:

not defending JL, but I think when he said they he was referring to dp.

 

[jpappy789]

Actually there is a great difference in her play to how she acts when she is innocent to when she is mafia.. She is acting just like she did in Game 5 where she started out quiet and then went completely on the defensive and ended up being mafia. Granted she is being driven to the defensive but her the biggest thing I have seen so far that points her as mafia was that list..

I would have to disagree. Jm always acts defensive, at least from my perspective. The one thing that is different is the vote on blueiz thing.

This has possibilities...

I agree, though at least 2 or 3 of those people seem suspcious to a good majority of the town which kinda has me worried. Although the chanzes that they are all innocent is a lot slimer this game so I am not quite as worried as games in previous formats...

 

[Lady G]

Here's why I think you are protecting charlie. At least three players have said that he is acting oddly. Two of them have voted for him.

Charlie does defend himself, but you have too... at least twice and I believe three times, you have said that you don't see it, or he's acting normally, or something like that. Ice has called you on it once.

I'm just putting you on my short list of mafia.

Ok, just a quick correction..I never said I didn't see it in Charlie. Yes, I said he is acting normal..I think he pretty much acts the same innocent or guilty. In this game so far though I do seem him as more on the guilty side.

ok, I am not on the defensive. I could care less if any of you think me suspicious. I am innocent, and It feels good to sit here and know that, I am a loud person, I talk alot, I talk fast, ...get used to it, ..it doesn't make me guilty, you people complain if I don't post, because it makes me look guilty, you complain when I do, cause it makes me look guilty, if I use generalizations it makes me look guilty, if I name specific people it makes me look guilty, If I am happy it makes me look guilty, if I don't I look defense, and you guessed it, guilty, ..so in short, I look guilty, ..no matter what, so either vote me, or get off your high horses and look for actual mafia. lol<--- that was for lady G

:worthy:

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Not coming to the thread sooner?? I think the only one on that "list" that didn't show early was DP. Let's see I posted like 3-4 times before you came on and posted...and not protecting him but Charlie posted quite a few before you came on also, oh went back and looked Jmax posted a few before you also...so yeah the only one on that list that didn't post before you was DP. Kinda odd for you to say we didn't have good excuses for not posting earlier when you in fact posted after 3 of the 4 on that list.:huh:

What?! He said that you didn't have good excuses for not posting? I think he was referring to DP. You seem a bit "panicked". Why?

 

[judgemax]

:worthy:

I hope you realize that the "lol" was for you, the whole post was directed to everyone who always claims I look guilty, ...

 

[clown-lover]

I would have to disagree. Jm always acts defensive, at least from my perspective. The one thing that is different is the vote on blueiz thing.

No she doesn't.. I'm not saying this is up to the level of the neon julie incident (I don't think she'll ever make that mistake again) But instead of concentrating at the job at hand she is concentrating on the minutia and being overly defensive.. In the past when innocent she really has let it slide and she isn't letting it slide.

I agree, though at least 2 or 3 of those people seem suspicious to a good majority of the town which kinda has me worried. Although the chanzes that they are all innocent is a lot slimer this game so I am not quite as worried as games in previous formats...

We all should be suspicious all I was saying is that there is some merit to the list.. Not everyone but it does have possibilities. Right now I'm still looking at everyone but some more than others simply because they have made themselves more interesting than others.

 

[Madcrawdad]

what if we are just social by nature? Does that mean i now have to act mean, and suspicious of every one? I'd think they'd slip up more in a casual conversation then when being hard pressed, but thats just me.:huh:

You should be suspicious of everyone. Nobody's going to slip up during a conversation about a T.V. show and say that they're mafia. Only way to find out who is who, is to kick down some doors.

 

[Blueiz]

Its really quaint how yesterday you made one post to say hi and today you are out of the gates guns blazing on the Judge putting her on the complete defensive while you stay on the offensive. You at this point are on my radar because you have done nothing of true substance. I am not saying that the judge is or isn't mafia but at this point in the game as far as I'm concerned everyone is mafia including yourself. This ploy btw has been tried by many mafia.

I made 3 posts yesterday. I do have a 4 year old daughter and am a single mother as well. Sunday afternoons are our time together. As far as the rest..everyone is suspect in my book as well. I know Im innocent.

 

[judgemax]

No she doesn't.. I'm not saying this is up to the level of the neon julie incidenthave to laugh because it now has a name, and it sounds like a story about a hooker in the redlight district, and my name is also julie, so I got this really horrible visual. (I don't think she'll ever make that mistake again) and, um, there was no mistake, I was innocent, and NJ was mafia?...what was the mistake?...But instead of concentrating at the job at hand she is concentrating on the minutia and being overly defensive.. In the past when innocent she really has let it slide and she isn't letting it slide.again, I have tried to let it drop several times. read the posts, before you try and stick up for your team mates, are you trying to save her because your the one who told her to say grasping at straws?...:raspberry:



We all should be suspicious all I was saying is that there is some merit to the list.. Not everyone but it does have possibilities. Right now I'm still looking at everyone but some more than others simply because they have made themselves more interesting than others.