Mafia #14 -- The Play

[Dwarf Puffers]

Whoa, weird turn of events, but it makes sense with his posts. It's too bad we lost HN, because he's always really good at harassing mafia and I was looking forward to get good lynch picks from him. So the whole DJ thing...Is he really playing so badly as to give himself away? For now it seems like a pretty safe bet.

I vote to lynch DJ.

It's kinda hard to judge by voting record who is what right now, since Chas was acting so funny that it made it easy for the mafia to jump on him.

This post just doesn't feel right with me... It feels false, and what about "Too bad we lost HN, he harrassed the mafia"? That just doesn't settle with me either. Probably not on any "list" by me, but I'm suspicious.

arggg i hate seniors, hmmmm
so your a teacher ogre?

Another of your famous opinnionising on the mafia game; Like others have said, start doing something productive for your team, or you won't last long.

If anything, there are votes on DJmajor. I think the majority of people expect DP to lose interest and die an UD.
As far as DJmajor goes, what do you think of their slip? Any thoughts on DJmajor?

I assure you, as long as everything's fine at home, I'll be attending this game

P.S: Have to get breakfast and then work, probably my last post till this after!

-DP

 

[IceH2O]

Heres an updated list

I think I've even got them broke down into teams

JM
Sway
Blue
Mad


LG
DC
Jpap
DJ

I don't have time to break down why at this time but if you read through you might get the same feeling with these people in mind.

 

[djmajor]

Good Morning , could not sleep thinking about these two innocent deaths and yes I have antics. Kind of the guy whom always would just jump in head first. It was very kind to hear the town that stayed up last night give me the the benefit of the doubt. I have my doubts with random selection or maybe the dice rolled with the experienced players being mafia. I must admit that I jumped on Charlie because he was already on the ground and headed to the rope. I felt it would be easy prey and trusted the high numbers of votes from the older players. I am actually sitting here at the airport thinking now about how many innocent peoplle are left and ask that you enable me to trust someone to guide me through this process of selection. I think we all wanted to saved our own heads on jump on the fallen. I want to be the first to say I am gratefull that it was not my neck. Sorry Charlie. I am going to wait until the final hours and today avoid looking at the running count and seek-out the mafia guy. Please explain what the numbers of the innocents are left.

 

[IceH2O]

I could only guess its 8-8 as we started with 18 players and lost 2 innocents last night.

 

[Dwarf Puffers]

Good Morning , could not sleep thinking about these two innocent deaths and yes I have antics. Kind of the guy whom always would just jump in head first. It was very kind to hear the town that stayed up last night give me the the benefit of the doubt. I have my doubts with random selection or maybe the dice rolled with the experienced players being mafia. I must admit that I jumped on Charlie because he was already on the ground and headed to the rope. I felt it would be easy prey and trusted the high numbers of votes from the older players. I am actually sitting here at the airport thinking now about how many innocent peoplle are left and ask that you enable me to trust someone to guide me through this process of selection. I think we all wanted to saved our own heads on jump on the fallen. I want to be the first to say I am gratefull that it was not my neck. Sorry Charlie. I am going to wait until the final hours and today avoid looking at the running count and seek-out the mafia guy. Please explain what the numbers of the innocents are left.

Kind of hard to believe you couldn't sleep thinking about the mafia game :screwy:

 

[Madcrawdad]

Dead??? It was 5-4 at that time.

You were #7 (of 9) on Charlie...

Can I ask why you threw away a vote onto Sway? I mean if she was such a suspect why didn't you push for her and get some votes floating that way if you knew Charlie was innocent?

I didn't know that Charlie was innocent....just didn't think that he was as lynchworthy as others did. A couple of people mentioned Charlie early on, and half the town was jumping all over him.

I learned my lesson a few games back when Cory Lover said 'Innocent again.' I fought like crazy to get the town not lynch him on Day 1, (based on that single post), as it was a pretty rash move to do so, and on Day 2 he ended up as mafia....oops, I won't do that again.




Heres my post showing the vote break down.



Maybe it should be asked of Jpap or DD, who came off DP to Charlie, and we already assume DJ is mafia. I agree... I was just starting with you.

The votes that are made late and put on a player not in danger always gets my attention
Of course it gets your attention... Funny that you didn't mention it until I asked you a question, though.

Mad onto Sway
Blue onto LG

.

 

[Swayde]

Ok, guys/gals...I couldn't sleep I had to come back and apologize for my last post. I'm sorry I got so upset. You know I had a really bad night at work, came home and found we lost 2 innocents. Then I read ppl saying "he brought it on himself".

When I read this it reminded me of when I was lynched for "freaking out" kinda in the same way (never said I'd take a UD) but still I freaked a little b/c I felt like I was being set up...I have a feeling Charlie may of felt the same way and that emotion came out in me. PPl said the same thing "she brought it on herself" and guess what those ppl were on the bad side.

So now I am going to look into who was on him early, and who said "he brought it on himself". I think this may be where the truth will lie.

This is going to sound hypocritical, but I also believe there are some who voted another way (yes, I know I did) but I believe there are some who voted another way b/c they KNEW he was innocent. No I did not KNOW he was innocent and really had my doubts about him..and it took everything I had NOT to switch to him, I am also going to look at those who were "on" me for saying I thought he seemed Mafia but not voting him, I have a feeling some of these KNEW he was not Mafia.

I will back on tomorrow and look through everything from the very first post's on, and post what I find.

Well, I just mainly wanted to come on and say sorry for that last "vent" post!! Really that is all it was a vent, I'm sure more will be read into it, but that is simply all it was.

Lady G, there is no way anyone could have known for sure that Charlie was innocent.

 

[Madcrawdad]

My current thoughts, in no particular order:

1. s*%! we lost 2 innocents, and the mafia ratio was pretty high to begin with.

2. How do you prove innocence, without screaming it and being called mafiascum?

3. The current players:

Swayde- makes me nervous. lots of posts, little to judge by

ogre- nothing suspicious yet

Dangerdoll- very conversational and soothing posts, lots of "honeys" and "girls", a ploy to make us comfortable? or just DD enjoying life?

lady g- i still don't like her style or tone- no more evidence than that

jpappy- appears helpful, who knows?

madcrawdad- pushing people for more info, could be baiting

clown lover- no bad vibes yet

cooldude- playing like a noob, suspiciously so, maybe using his stauts as such to play us as per boss' ruling. i don't trust him

johnlarson66- early vote, quiet for a vet. not sure.

jensons- innocent

blueiz- I don't trust her. After LadyG jumped on me, she posted something that seemed to back her up. The vote she then cast for LadyG made me thinkthat it may have been a ruse to keep us off her trail. And, if she is mafia, and suspects that LadyG is on the other team, it would be a good vote.

deputychief- no read

judgemax- leaning innocent

ice- bad vibe, no good reasons

hooked newbie- innocent and gone: no votes placed

dwarf puffers- leaning innocent, but could very well be using past history to play as a sleeper mafia

djmajor- leaning mafia

charlie stubbs- innocent and gone: HN(191) Ogre(382) DP(403) CL(414) DC(417) JPap(462) Ice(464) DD(471) DJ(476)

4. I know that there's not much to go on here, but this is what I can do before bed. At least it's not about Heroes.

5. My top 3: LadyG, Blueiz, cooldude

G'nite all!

~brandy

You really thought JL was quiet? I was thinking just the opposite. I thought that he was more vocal on Day 1 than he has ever been... not saying that plays to his guilt or innocence, just interesting that you would say he was quiet.

 

[Swayde]

Heres an updated list

I think I've even got them broke down into teams

JM
Sway
Blue
Mad


LG
DC
Jpap
DJ

I don't have time to break down why at this time but if you read through you might get the same feeling with these people in mind.

So you don't think that RB split the teams up according to experience for the Old School / New School mafia teams? How do you think he split it or do you think it's totally random?

Here's from the rules...

The players are the townsfolk in the great City of ACville.

Some are Innocents; the remaining are 2 groups of Mafia (Old School/New School); the Mafia will be divided into 2 teams and only know who is in their respective group; they can communicate only with their own group. Each group will get 3 investigations, if they find a member of the other Mafia group they will show as an Innocent.

 

[Swayde]

My main suspects at the moment.

DJ - he really has been screaming mafia, but I can't shake the feeling that he could possibly be another Mike. It seems like a safe bet vote and kinda worries me that some people jumped right on it after night fall.

DP - His start up is still very fishy to me. I have a hard time believing some of his excuses (not the cat thing, very sorry for your loss there), just the whole PM thing, having posts in multiple threads and then not being able to find the game thread. However, I agree with the observation he made of DC's reaction to nightfall and his quick vote on DJ that it looks very odd.

which brings me to...

DC - see above... also this post

No expecting a free ride...Just mostly watching and trying to get a read on people...There are a bunch of people I haven't played with before....I could kick the same weasels as everyone else but to what end...I've pointed out which suspicions I find valid. I find that the first day can kind of set the standard for things and lots of confusions starts at that time. I choose not to add to it at the moment...I suspect all the people who I know play well, I write off the newbs because they are quite sure what's going on (if they're innocent) and they're getting a bit of coaching probably (if they're evil). I guess we should watch for newbs who are playing well so far. In which case cool and blue are doing pretty well. I'll give some credit to blue though, knowing she's pretty clever in regular life...I like watching HN's play since it's usually pretty effective, but then again I have been caught by surprise when he's evil...Gotta keep watching I guess...

That was posted on 10/22 at about 9:30pm, early the next morning he votes for CS who is the top vote getter (same weasles) and the very next night he votes for DJ (a newbie he was going to let slide and not even one he thinks was being coached). And then he mentions HN too. He is right about the just watching and getting a feel thing apparently, he only has 11 posts total, but I know he's normally a low poster, which makes him real hard to read.

Everyone else is on equal footing with me right now. No major alarm bells ringing, but as I said, I don't have anyone leaning innocent right now either.

With all that said, I vote to lynch DeputyChiefJR.