Mafia #14 -- The Play

[Blueiz]

6) Anyone can declare to be the detective, or any other power role; indeed, I've seen the bad guys do so quite effectively for a short time.

 

[judgemax]

remind us all, Mz. Soprano

your funny, But seriously, this time, the shoe is on the other foot! I am the innocent one, and you, are guilty as sin. as smart as you are, I would have expected better!

 

[Dangerdoll]

oh, thanks, Mz. Sopr.... I mean Judge

 

[Blueiz]

Below is a quote from my post

Ok, I have thought about this a lot. Before DD wasnt posting hardly a thing. Then she comes out with a few posts. In one of these posts she brings out a post where the detective was mentioned.

Then from LG where she quoted me.

Also I believe there were post about DD asking about the detective. I'll have to go back and see...but I'm pretty sure there were questions about it.

If you believe they were, and Im saying there were, why are you going to have to go back and see, you ARE the det right, shouldn't you already know?

 

[judgemax]

4) Everything stays in the game, no PMing people and setting up deals or alliances, or discussing issues in this game on other sites. The sole exception to this is the authorization by me for special role players to do so.

6) Anyone can declare to be the detective, or any other power role; indeed, I've seen the bad guys do so quite effectively for a short time.

Ok, blue, I understand why you posted rule number 6, but why rule number 4?

and, why are you back peddling?, at this point, IF DD is not mafia, we lynch LG tom. why not try it and see what have we got to loose?, do you have a better suspect? Is DD really on your team?

 

[judgemax]

oh, thanks, Mz. Sopr.... I mean Judge

YOUR QUITE WELCOME! MRS. DON, i mean DD.

 

[Blueiz]

OI posted number four becuase there has been mention of an argument off site, and dd keeps posting weird stuff about talking somewhere else with LG.

I wouldnt call it back peddling, more like something struck me that was really weird and I just put my finger on it. I am not saying anything about anyone. Im simply putting thoughts out here to get views on them. I retracted my vote for dd becaues at this time Im not sure this is not a ploy of some sort. What in the world it could be, Im not sure...why im posting my thoughts out.

 

[Lady G]

When someone "hints" they are a power role, then I think they should be called on it. There is no reason to hint it, we can all see the hint. If anything the mafia is at an advantage, because they can discuss the hint outside the thread.

It is not a good practice for any of the power roles to hint what they are. I am fairly sure the people that have the power roles know this and are not hinting anything.

When someone says they "know" something, I think they should back it up. I was not asking the real Detective or Doctor to come out, I was just stating that judgemax could only "know" if she was the Detective, Doctor, or on the same mafia team. I even asked her to maybe change her wording to: "or could you just have a feeling that DJmajor is not the Detectice, but he could be."

I also find it odd that Ogre got a bunch of heat about this, but I did not get any. I brought it on myself.[/quote]

DD is the only person who really brought this up and she doesn't seem to be putting much heat on Ogre over it to me.

Ok I still don't see it. I took it as him questioning JM , not asking her to come out if she was and not asking anyone else to come out.

I believe you thought you had something. But it didn't pan out.

This was to DD.

Thats because she got nipped before her team could back her up. Do you actually see what she sees Sway? Is Ogre trying to pull the DET out?

I see what you mean now, thanks for clearing it up.

JL, if anything the post by Ogre has brought heat onto DD, not him and maybe onto you also.

If DD hadn't mentioned his post it probably would have just been buried under the other posts.

Since she did comment on it but not yours it looks like you 2 could be teammates. Not only did she make me look her way but she drug you with her.

Not saying you guys are vote worthy but definitely will be under the microscope.

Ahhh, yes it was mentioned.

 

[judgemax]

OI posted number four becuase there has been mention of an argument off site, and dd keeps posting weird stuff about talking somewhere else with LG.

I wouldnt call it back peddling, more like something struck me that was really weird and I just put my finger on it. I am not saying anything about anyone. Im simply putting thoughts out here to get views on them. I retracted my vote for dd becaues at this time Im not sure this is not a ploy of some sort. What in the world it could be, Im not sure...why im posting my thoughts out.

thank you for your reply, but aren't you getting, that DD posted that to imply that LG is mafia with her, mafia are allowed to communicate out of the thread, but only with their teammates. I however have talked to lady G after games (last game) and she and I got along swimmingly, even after I was pretty rough and mean to her, the same the game before, she was pretty rough on me, but there wasn't an issue, so I know, that DD is lying about an altercation, esp. since she can't even suggest what it was about. LG doesn't get upset when it comes to this, she fully understands its a game. :wall:

 

[Lady G]

Below is a quote from my post



Then from LG where she quoted me.


If you believe they were, and Im saying there were, why are you going to have to go back and see, you ARE the det right, shouldn't you already know?

Again you are copy/pasting just the parts of the post to make things look different then they really were.