Mafia #15....The Play....

[plantling]

Yes HN i do have some what of a list going, there are 8 possible Maf. left,
I'm not sure of any just suspicions, posting tactics, demeanor's, guiding the way..

My quick list since HN asked, These players seem to be agreeing alot with a certain person, Always subject to change..

1. ICE
2.JL
3.DD
4.JO
5. ?
6. ?
7. ?
8. ?

Originally Posted by rbishop
to lynch....

brains2 (6) by ice 280 coler 284 joan 297 DD 298 zsand 298 jl66 380

Fairly similar to my list, interesting..

Just to clarify what list I was talking about. Notice only ice, joan, DD, and jl66 are bolded. Coler and Z didn't make his list in the top post.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Wow. I guess I can't come out as the Detective huh? lol

Judge- I can understand why you would investigate me, but why name me? I don't necessarily mind (even though, I now have a target on me), but I would like to know your reasoning after all the discussion about doing it.

Also, I am not 100% sold yet on Coler, but I am close. I'd ask that you look at the cases against him and make up your own mind. There are others looking pretty guilty as well. I need to read back through and think into some of the posts from today.

By the way, why should we believe that you got the innocent investigation and not the mafia's? You could be unknown mafia and offering me up while letting them know at the same time...

 

[IceH2O]

and now that I have a few minutes, I am curious, as to why, Ice and dd are so needing that info?..is there a reason?...and why all of a sudden are some of you whispering my name, that happened last game, and the ones who did that, were mafia, ..little odd to me?...I might be wrong about coler, I never said it was my final vote, however, ..Ice, has me more concerned, and so does DD,

If I had to name a list right now, I would say, ICE, DD, Coler, and KOTD, are the ones I am most interested in hearing from.

I think its hilarious that I outed 3 mafia and you could think me mafia. Don't you think if thought someone was mafia I wouldn't try to out them and hoped it slipped by the others?

I agree with this very much, there are 4 mafia left, if the person who got the investigation comes out, and has an innocent, then the mafia has a pretty **** good shot, at knowing who the remaining mafia are, that would give them an advantage of knowing at max, six people in the game, that narrows the field to half for them, ..That gives them a very unfair advantage

Do you really think that the mafia doesn't have an idea on who to hit? I wouldn't even have thought they would hit the innocent named until you named HN who I was surprised wasn't hit, along with me, the 2nd night.

I was actually hoping that someone would name a mafia that turned out to be one of the 4 innocents so they would then implicate themself.

i don't care if you are looking at me because i voted for you to make it a tie.


my vote was just that, to make things interesting..im pretty sure if the coin toss landed on you..we'd still have only 4 mafia left

think what you want about that.

I agree KOTD and why I didn't switch my vote when you tied it. Also why I didn't try to talk anyone into coming over to LG. I'm pretty sure the votes were on 2 mafia.

Wow. I guess I can't come out as the Detective huh? lol

Judge- I can understand why you would investigate me, but why name me? I don't necessarily mind (even though, I now have a target on me), but I would like to know your reasoning after all the discussion about doing it.

Also, I am not 100% sold yet on Coler, but I am close. I'd ask that you look at the cases against him and make up your own mind. There are others looking pretty guilty as well. I need to read back through and think into some of the posts from today.

By the way, why should we believe that you got the innocent investigation and not the mafia's? You could be unknown mafia and offering me up while letting them know at the same time...

I'm not even sure JM got the investigation, though I have HN as innocent.



I'm more convinced after todays posts that JM is mafia. I meant to put MM/JM in this mornings post but in the rush to get out I forgot.

My list is

Coler
Z
JL
JM

I vote to lynch Coler

You aren't escaping the lynch this time. You don't have enough team mates to do it either.

 

[IceH2O]

You going to vote for yourself again Coler?

I'm thinking that everyone will jump on you to cover their tracks anyway.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Ha !

I'm disappointed it came down to a random coin toss - but hey my own vote was on myself. I'm delighted to still be in the game.

How did your vote on yourself help? All it did was add to the fact that it went to a coin toss. Now you're dsappointed by that?

HN - can you please do me a favour now when we are close to bringing this one home. following an unprecedented 3 mafia kills. Think long and hard about why you are still saying I am mafia.

I have, or do you think my posts are made without thought?

Say what you want about day 1, my Ogre vote etc. I'll continue to defend/explain that. I voted for brains, unwaveringly, and I have already explained my subsequent posts on day 2 and I stand over them too. Lady G was my preferred vote, aside from myself.


Other candidates which I said I would vote for included capt. caveman.

Ask yourself - is this how a mafia would vote & act. You can do a lot better than me for your next mafia hit and you know it.

This would definitely make me believe you were innocent IF the mafia all knew eachother. They don't, so I am suspicious.

Those who said 'you were overly defensive/there wernt enough votes on you to warrant your responses/voting for yourself is defeatist mafia' can go fish - I can smell a train forming and I knew I wouldn't be around during the day (real time day over here) to do anything more to defend myself.

Today is Friday, Tomorrow is Saturday, I hope to have a lot more time, work allowing, for the game and it is very much game on. I will not be voting for myself this round.

Comments in red. As I stated, I'm not 100% sold on you yet, but it does seem to me that you haven't made any cases of your own. You've just regurgitated things and defended yourself. You are too good a player for that.

 

[Rbishop]

Bala Speaks...

"One innocent, and one mafia have been offered the chance to protect one person for game night #4, from a hit or a lynch, even if the protection is for them."

 

[judgemax]

Wow. I guess I can't come out as the Detective huh? lol
sorry
Judge- I can understand why you would investigate me, but why name me? I don't necessarily mind (even though, I now have a target on me), but I would like to know your reasoning after all the discussion about doing it. well, because I re-read, and you also questioned about the investigations. I didn't want to come out, or name you, My original plan, was to wait until like one minute before night fall tonight, and say that I had gotten the innocent investigation, that way, if I had happened to be hit, or id the gruesome twosome)DD and KOTD had managed to swing enough votes my way, the mafia had no chance to change their votes, but, because I questioned everyones wanting to know so early, i got jumped on pretty hard. I assumed that most of you would just realize, that my questioning the way I was would tip someone off. I hope that makes sense?...

Also, I am not 100% sold yet on Coler, but I am close. I'd ask that you look at the cases against him and make up your own mind. There are others looking pretty guilty as well. I need to read back through and think into some of the posts from today. I have made my own opinion, i do feel he has been acting strangely, and If you , the only other person I know as an innocent feels the same way ,well, I guess I am voting there.

By the way, why should we believe that you got the innocent investigation and not the mafia's? You could be unknown mafia and offering me up while letting them know at the same time...

Well, had I gotten the mafia investigation, I would have blurted as soon as I have gotten it, when have any of you, known me to play a reserved mafia?...



sorry, by the way, i felt crappy about doing it, and you can lynch me if you need, to be sure that I am innocent, that would leave you a pretty big target, but you would have two nights to get somewhere. I know that never sounds pro-town, to say, however, we are at a slight advantage right now, Since you and I are both innocent, and DD and king have pretty much outed themselves, we can afford to loose me. and hopefully the protection will go on you this night( hint: protect HN) and you then can look at what is going on, ..again, i didn't mean to paint a target on your back, I am very sick, and tired, and I got frustrated. I didn't want to come out, simply because when I did, i knew the how do we know your not the mafia would come, and, lets face it, do I ever really look innocent to you hn?..That is why I chose you (mostly, that and that pit bull attitude, lmao) If I am swearing your innocent, and you know you are, ..well, then you must think me as well..because you hardly ever believe me?..does that make sense either?..

 

[Rbishop]

Update...thru post #1007...

To Lynch....

coler (5) by hk 899 jl 914 judg 952 plnt 1000 ice 1003

kotd (1) by zsnd 923

judge (1) by DD 976

7 of 12 Townies have voted...

No votes from mee-mee, blueiz, Coler, KOTD, joander....

Nightfall for Game Day #4 is at 3 PM EST, tomorrow, Saturday 11/10

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Well, had I gotten the mafia investigation, I would have blurted as soon as I have gotten it, when have any of you, known me to play a reserved mafia?...



sorry, by the way, i felt crappy about doing it, and you can lynch me if you need, to be sure that I am innocent, that would leave you a pretty big target, but you would have two nights to get somewhere. I know that never sounds pro-town, to say, however, we are at a slight advantage right now, Since you and I are both innocent, and DD and king have pretty much outed themselves, we can afford to loose me. and hopefully the protection will go on you this night( hint: protect HN) and you then can look at what is going on, ..again, i didn't mean to paint a target on your back, I am very sick, and tired, and I got frustrated. I didn't want to come out, simply because when I did, i knew the how do we know your not the mafia would come, and, lets face it, do I ever really look innocent to you hn?..That is why I chose you (mostly, that and that pit bull attitude, lmao) If I am swearing your innocent, and you know you are, ..well, then you must think me as well..because you hardly ever believe me?..does that make sense either?..

I can buy this. My main concern and why I was getting ready to put together a case for you was that 3 of the 4 on your latest list (all but Coler) I have leaning innocent. Right now I have my strongest suspicions on Z & Coler, but I can see a case on you as well (Sorry). I almost think we should place 4 votes on three people and watch who moves and why.

I do want to believe you're innocent, but obviously there are reservations.

G/O- Hope you feel better soon even if you turn out to be scum. G/O

 

[judgemax]

I can buy this. My main concern and why I was getting ready to put together a case for you was that 3 of the 4 on your latest list (all but Coler) I have leaning innocent. Right now I have my strongest suspicions on Z & Coler, but I can see a case on you as well (Sorry). I almost think we should place 4 votes on three people and watch who moves and why.

I do want to believe you're innocent, but obviously there are reservations.

G/O- Hope you feel better soon even if you turn out to be scum. G/O

Thank you, I hate being sick, I still have to take care of the kids, and dogs, and clean the house, plus clean up all my own mess from being sick, and no one ever brings me soup, lol

I really do understand your reservations, I can't really show you the pm, or else I would die anyway, As I have said, if you need to, so you have a better idea of who you should really be looking at, I am willing to be lynched(again, its not exactly what most people would call pro town, however, I think you would be able to tell alot by the interactions with me prior to my death.

I had only mildly thought KOTD guilty, until he pulled this today, he and DD seemed to team up pretty quick, and about the same exact time, They might be the communicating innocents, however,. i think, that they are probably the communicating mafia. I had though DD guilty most of the game, (was a hunch) until today when, in my mind, she is guilty as sin. Think about it, most people know if you ruffle my feathers, i will argue back, and sometimes I don't make much sense, and I make myself look guilty, lol, I think they tried, to make me look guilty, in hopes that I would basically hang myself(again, this could all be because of my nyquil induced stupor, but read the exchange, and look at the posts they first pulled to start questioning me on?, they were weak, they both messed up. AGAIN, PLEASE WHOEVER GOT THE PROTECTION, PLEASE PROTECT HN, HE IS A KNOWN INNOCENT, ..and will be of much more help to the town, then me*(esp. doped up on medicine)